Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Warid value rises by over 1,500 times

Update : 22 May 2013, 04:20 AM

The price of a 70% stake of Warid Telecom was $100,000 (Tk7.8m) when Bharti Airtel bought it from Dhabi Group in 2010. Three years later, the remaining 30% stake is about to fetch Dhabi Group $65m from the same buyer.

Bharti Airtel recently applied to the Bangladesh Telecom Regulatory Commission to acquire the remaining stake from Dhabi Group. This makes Warid Telecom’s sell value in 2010 more than 1,500 times what it was just three years ago.

On May 2, Bharti Airtel declared, in a filing to the Bombay Stock Exchange, that it was going to acquire the remaining 30% stake from Dhabi Group and that the parties had reached an agreement. It did not disclose the amount.

The Dhaka Tribune has seen part of the copy of Airtel’s proposal – the "purchase and transfer of stake shares" section, which was submitted to BTRC and dated May 9. It said “…the purchaser will pay $65,000,000 (the ‘Closing Payment’) by wire transfer to a bank account of the Seller, details whereof will be notified by the seller to the purchase at least two business days prior to the closing date.”

“They submitted a proposal to the BTRC last week which was incomplete. We sent them back and they again made all documents available,” BTRC chairman Sunil Kanti Bose told the Dhaka Tribune last week.

He said the telecom firm also held verbal discussion with the regulators before submitting its proposal as they want to change the ownership structure.

The 2010 sale received flak in parliament and several parliamentary standing committees, who criticised it and questioned the low selling price. Under regulations in force at that time, the BTRC received only Tk380,000 from the sale.

According to a decision taken in 2007 and repealed in February 2010, just after the sale, the BTRC was entitled to receive 5.5% of the total transaction.

Sources claimed that Airtel had manipulated the 2010 price to avoid paying too much to the regulators and since the regulation was repealed, the telecom has now declared the true price.

After repeated attempts by the Dhaka Tribune to get a response from the telecom firm, it received a letter from the Airtel spokesperson. “As a law abiding company, all our transactions are in complete compliance with all Bangladesh regulations. However, we cannot share more details due to the confidentiality of the shareholders agreement."

BTRC chairman said, according to the guidelines, operators needed to get permission before going to the joint stock of companies. “We have already sent a letter to the joint stock informing them about the requirement of our approval.”

An audit report by the Comptroller and Auditor General claimed that the government had lost around Tk769.6m in the 2010 transfer as the BTRC imposed lower fees violating an act, which was soon be placed before parliament.

The then telecom watchdog gave permission to Warid to sell the 70% stake for only $100,000 or around Tk7m on January 4, 2010. The BTRC withdrew the 5.5% revenue sharing decision on February 8, 2010.

According to the audit report, the BTRC collected only Tk380,000 as a share transfer fee after accepting the company’s token valuation of Warid at only $100,000, whereas the company’s 2009 audited financial statement showed that the total share capital value was roughly Tk14bn or around $200m, a telecom ministry source quoting the report said.

"If the 2009 audited financial statement of Warid is taken into consideration, the actual transfer fee should have been Tk769.9m, but the BTRC took only Tk380,000 making its revenue loss Tk769.6m," said the report.

The CAG audit report said during the transfer of the 70% stake, Warid manipulated its share price to evade the transfer fee as the Tk100 face value of each share was shown at Tk0.06 just before the transfer. At that time Warid transferred 114,474,640 shares of the company to Airtel worth Tk6.868m without permission from Securities and Exchange Commission, it said.

In February 25, 2010, Warid increased its number of shares from 200m to 470m through and transferred additional 259,828,057 shares to Airtel at a rate of Tk79.82.

"In a month’s gap the share price rose to Tk79.82 from Tk0.06 which makes it clear that the devaluation of share prices was intended to evade the government tax," the report said.

The BTRC chairman said, “We have given our reply to Comptroller and Auditor General [about the CAG report] and they are satisfied.”

Telecom ministry secretary, Md Abubakar Siddique, told the Dhaka Tribune that they had already requested the audit office to settle the issue.

Source said the Auditor General already visited the BTRC office last week, but the issue is yet to be resolved.

The parliamentary standing committee on planning ministry in its 14th and 28th meetings, between 2011 and 13, asked the telecom ministry to explain why the transaction for the 70% stake was “so low”. It also wanted to know how much money the government had lost by this transaction.

Sources said the audit report will now go to parliament and will be discussed by the parliamentary standing committee on public accounts. 

Top Brokers