A recent ruling by a US federal court has cast significant doubt on the legality of the 10% Global Reciprocal Tariff imposed by the Trump administration, yet it has simultaneously triggered a fresh wave of uncertainty for international exporters.
While the New York-based United States Court of International Trade declared the tariff illegal on May 7, the immediate suspension of the duty applies only to the three specific plaintiffs involved in the lawsuit.
For the vast majority of importers and global exporters, including those in Bangladesh, the 10% surcharge remains in effect, leaving businesses in a strategic limbo as they await further judicial or administrative clarity.
The court's decision, reached in a 2-1 vote by a three-judge panel, concluded that the administration overstepped the legal authority granted by Congress.
The judges characterized the tariff as unauthorized under existing law, specifically questioning the application of Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974, which the administration had used to justify the measure as a tool to reduce the trade deficit.
Despite this strong language, the court limited its mandate to the three entities that brought the case: the State of Washington, toy manufacturer Basic Fun!, and spice importer Burlap & Barrel.
Consequently, while these three parties have seen the tariff halted and are entitled to refunds, the rest of the world’s trade with the US continues to be taxed at the higher rate.
This partial victory has created a complex landscape for the Bangladeshi readymade garment sector and other major exporters.
Industry leaders, such as former BGMEA director Mohiuddin Rubel emphasize that the ruling does not grant blanket relief. He noted that because the 10% duty remains active for everyone else, the burden of higher costs persists, affecting pricing strategies and long-term order planning.
The situation is particularly sensitive for Bangladeshi exporters, as any volatility in US trade policy directly impacts the nation’s largest export market during an already challenging period of high interest rates and global economic cooling.
Legal experts anticipate that this ruling will open the floodgates for more companies to seek similar relief through the court system, potentially leading to a mass reclaim of paid duties.
However, the Trump administration is expected to appeal the decision, which could move the case to the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals and eventually the Supreme Court.
For now, exporters must navigate a market where the primary judicial authority has labeled a tax illegal, yet the executive branch continues to collect it from almost every vessel arriving at US ports.
The ultimate fate of the reciprocal tariff policy will depend on whether future rulings expand this protection to all importers or if the administration successfully defends its trade powers in a higher court.



