Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Adani Sends Rejoinder, Our Response

The rejoinder does not factually contradict any part of our news story

Update : 04 Sep 2024, 06:04 PM

Adani Group has sent a rejoinder to a Dhaka Tribune report published on August 22, 2024 titled “Is it time to renegotiate the Adani deal?” 

The rejoinder reads, in pertinent part: 

"Adani's power generation cost was lower than Payra, Rampal and other comparative plants, as per the latest annual report of the Bangladesh Power Development Board published in 2022-23. Adani’s power costs Tk14.02 per unit whereas Rampal costs Tk14.12 and Payra costs Tk16.02 per unit, according to the financial year 2022-2023 BPDB report. How could the power be costlier then? 

In addition, the average cost over the last 15 odd months, including capacity charge, fuel cost, and variable cost, is for Adani Tk11.89 whereas for Payra it is Tk12 and for Rampal Tk13.57.

The price of Adani power is very much aligned with the current Indian exchange market rate. Adani’s power price never goes up suddenly which may be the case in exchange markets. Such unjust comparisons are attempts to defame Adani.

It is to be noted that we are providing uninterrupted electricity to Bangladesh as per our commitment at a time when $800m has remained due in payment. For any other company, local or foreign, it is almost impossible to operate with such an outstanding amount.

On top of that, Adani built a 245 km transmission line between Bangladesh and India to supply uninterrupted electricity to the Rangpur Rajshahi divisions which is one of its kind.

Additionally, Adani Power has not, as a gesture of goodwill on its own, billed for fixed costs when transmission infrastructure to evacuate electricity was delayed on the Bangladesh side. We would take all actions in the interests of the electricity consumers of Bangladesh. 

We would have reiterated these had the Dhaka Tribune contacted us for comment, which is journalistic good practice." 

Our Reply

The rejoinder does not factually contradict any part of our news story. We never suggested Adani power was more expensive than Rampal and Payra coal power plants, so using them as points of comparison does not call our report into question.

Our report showed a comparison between Adani's electricity rate for Bangladesh, against the existing electricity exchange market rate. We reported that in 2023, Bangladesh purchased Adani's electricity for Tk14.02 a kilowatt-hour (or a unit), at a time when Bangladesh purchased an additional 1,100MW of power from India's electricity exchange market at Tk7.83 per unit. Adani has not refuted this factual assertion which was the basis of the Dhaka Tribune story.

Additionally, the rejoinder’s claim that the statistics are “decade-old” is incorrect, as they were obtained from Bangladesh PDB’s last annual report of FY2022-23.

Finally, the public relations officer of Adani's Bangladesh division was contacted by Dhaka Tribune regarding the issue of debt arrears, who informed us that Bangladesh had just started repayment.

We stand by our report.

Top Brokers