Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Banking sector’s troubles are much deeper than thought

Total distressed assets in the country’s banking sector reached Tk3,77,922 crore excluding loans that were unclassified by court orders

Update : 17 Aug 2023, 08:47 PM

The “Financial Stability Report 2022” by the Bangladesh Bank, released following the International Monetary Fund's (IMF) guideline of $4.7 billion in budget support, reveals a far more troubling picture of the banking industry. 

The disparities in data compared to the central bank's previously published quarterly report has prompted economists and banking professionals to question the efficacy of banking sector policies, as the discrepancies between the reported and actual data cast doubt on their effectiveness. The Financial Stability Report is believed to have presented a more accurate portrayal of the current state of the banking sector.

Within the economic and banking community, concerns have risen regarding the escalation of defaulted loans in Bangladesh. The prevailing issue is that the growth of capital does not correspond proportionately to the increase in these defaulted loans. 

Additionally, there has been a noticeable rise in the risk-based assets held by banks. There is a growing suspicion that several banks are not disclosing precise financial data, leading to a gradual erosion of the capital base of the country's banking institutions instead of its intended strengthening.

The assessment among economists and banking experts is that the recently unveiled Financial Stability Report offers more accurate insight into the true condition of the banking sector. The disparity in data between the earlier quarterly report and the comprehensive Financial Stability Report underscores the necessity for more transparent reporting and stringent oversight to ensure the health and stability of Bangladesh's banking industry.

“Earlier report was published with the provisional data of last year. Now we used the revised figures of earlier data. Due to this, changes have been seen in some indicators,” said the Director of the Financial Stability Department of the Bangladesh Bank, Md Ala Uddin: 

According to Bangladesh Bank's quarterly data for 2022, the amount of rescheduled loans of banks in the country was Tk29,283 crore but the latest published Financial Stability Report 2022, of Bangladesh Bank for the same year paints a different picture. Its mentioned amount is Tk63,720 crore. 

That is, actual rescheduled loans increased by more than 177%.

A similar mismatch was observed in 2021 data as well. 

Under the previous accounting system, the central bank had indicated that rescheduled loans amount for the year 2021 was Tk12,380 crore. 

However, the most recent financial stability report has revealed a significantly higher figure of Tk26,810 crore for the same category. 

Simultaneously, as of the conclusion of the preceding year, the accumulated value of rescheduled loans had reached Tk2,12,780 crore, which accounts for 14.40% of the overall loans within the banking sector. 

Consequently, the value of rescheduled loans has now surpassed that of defaulted loans.

Yet, the latest financial stability report underscores a significant disparity in distressed assets. 

The central bank's transition to adopting international financial reporting standards has led to the incorporation of non-performing, rescheduled, and written-off loans. 

These elements collectively contribute to a staggering sum of nearly Tk3,77,922 crore as distressed assets within the banking sector by the conclusion of 2022. This amount is over three times larger than the previously disclosed figure for default loans by the central bank. 

According to their records, default loans had amounted to Tk1.2 lakh crore at the close of the previous year in December.

According to the financial stability report of Bangladesh Bank, the amount of distressed assets in the banking sector in 2021 was Tk1.78 lakh crore. 

In the previous report of the central bank, the amount of distressed assets in that year was mentioned as Tk1.47 lakh crore.

Zahid Hussain, former lead economist consultant for the World Bank told Dhaka Tribune that there is a concentration of rescheduling loans in some banks as there is a correlation between loan concentration and loan rescheduling.

The share of rescheduled loans in total loans increased from 12.9% in 2021 to 14.4% in 2022. 

This cannot be added, as some seem to be doing, to the NPL ratio because it includes the part of the rescheduled loans which have turned non-performing again and hence are included in the reported NPL. 

A non-trivial 19.6% of rescheduled loans in 2022 were nonperforming, constituting 33.9% of recognised NPL. 

Adding the stock of written-off (net of recovered) and the non-classified part of the rescheduled loans to the recognised NPLs, the incidence of "distressed" assets was 23.9% in 2022, equivalent to about Tk3,600 billion (1.4 times the planned FY24 Annual Development Programme). 

This does not include the known unknown billions of loans stuck in courts, he explains.

Mentioning other data from the report he said Bangladesh's banking system, a proven dynamic force, has been struggling in the last two roles. 

Asset growth (7.5%) in 2022 was the lowest since the pandemic. 

Growth in loans and advances (13.5%), the largest (68%) part of banking sector assets, was better.

According to him, the buffer is actually less than what you may gather from the data. Underlying the increase in CRAR is the increase in net profit after taxes of the banking sector in 2022 relative to 2021 from Tk50.2 billion to Tk142.3 billion respectively. 

This happened at a time when the growth and quality of assets deteriorated. He questions whether it be that the reported net profits are overstated when measured by BB's regulatory standards.

The answer unfortunately is affirmative. Under provisioning against non-performing loans was equivalent to 77.3% of the reported profits in 2022. The provisioning shortfall spiked in the last two years. 

The maintained provision rate to gross NPL ratio decreased from 64.5% in 2021 to 60.6% in 2022. The CCB shrinks to 0.1% of the risk-weighted assets, compared with the reported 1.8% when under-provisioning is accounted for, he added.

Ahsan H Mansur, executive director, Policy Research Institute, said: “We were warning of this for a long time saying the difference in figures is far greater than reported by the Central Bank, and now Bangladesh Bank is reporting the numbers we were warning of. 

“It is true that the situation in the banking sector has deteriorated. Due to an increase in rescheduling, bank collections are decreasing. One has been holding funds for a long time. This is not improving the liquidity situation in the market. That crisis in the banking sector is highlighted in the financial stability report.

“Showing artificial improvement of the balance sheet will not go far. The way loans are rescheduled, interest waived, such practices have thrown the banking sector into this crisis.”

Top Brokers