Publish : 30 Nov 2021, 07:02 PMUpdate : 30 Nov 2021, 07:02 PM
In this article we take up the charges or costs for non-performing loans.
In article 5 it was demonstrated that the cost of lending, with no allowance for non performing loans, is approaching 8%.
When the bank has a large number of loans some of these will not be repaid.
It is not easy to determine who will repay.
This assessment is one of the critical factors in operating a profitable bank.
The system that Bangladesh Bank has put in place works as follows: Every loan has a repayment schedule and the bank keeps track of the actual payments of interest and principal made by the borrower.
If the repayments fall behind schedule then the bank is alerted to potential difficulties and is required by Bangladesh Bank to make provisions in the event that the loan does not get repaid.
The impact of this is to reduce the asset value of the loan and to reduce the equity of the bank.
The provisions are a cost of doing business.
If the bank is doing well in choosing clients, the volume of NPL will be low and the bank will be profitable.
If the client selection is poor then the provisions will be high and profitability low.
An example will illustrate this:
You make 10 loans each for Tk1 lakh to be repaid after a year. When the time comes for repayment one borrower does not; nine repay.
You have got Tk9 lakh back for the Tk10 lakh you lent.
When you make the loans you need to ask everyone to repay Tk91/9 lakh.
Then you will receive the Tk10 lakh you lent.
This is the pure loan loss cost.
In this case you require 11% extra to cover the losses.
No cost of funds, operating costs, or return on investment are included.
The rule is simple: if the fraction of defaults is x then the extra charge is x/1-x.
If the private banks have 7% bad loans then the bad loan charge is 7.5%.
There are three points to make.
1. All loans are backed by collateral. If the loan is not repaid then the bank will try to take the collateral. In Bangladesh this normally means that the bank will auction off the land that forms the collateral for most loans. In theory the collateral should have a value greater than the loan; but the reality of trying to hold auctions for land is different. There is no really satisfactory data on the actual value of the collateral collected. From some knowledge of what banks report and of the outcome of court cases a reasonable number is 35%. In the above example the cost of the bad loans would be 4.8%[Bad debt costs are 7.5%x0.65=4.55; with this in the x/1-x formula we obtain 4.8%.
2. The bank is failing to earn interest on the non-performing loan. This reduces earning. With a 9% lending rate the effective interest rate is (0.925 X 9%) or 8.3%.
3. The bank may be successful at delaying the onset of provisions by rescheduling. Rescheduling rarely results in improved administration of a project enabling a loan to be repaid; instead it just delays the day when the bank recognizes that it is not going to collect on this loan. A typical outcome is to spread the provision of three years or (4.8/3) or 1.6%. This creates an illusion that the costs of NPL are lower than they actually are.
Cost of lending
The cost of lending at the end of 2021 we have estimated at 8% adding on the bad debt costs we reach 9.6%-12.0%.
But earnings are reduced to 8.3%.
Private banks are now losing 1.3% - 4.6% on every loan that they make!
The situation has deteriorated from the early part of the year due to rising deposit rates.
In all of these numbers we have perhaps overestimated the costs of operating banks but we have also underestimated the volume of non-performing loans.
There are 10 private banks with average deposit rates below 3.5% in June 2021.
At that time these banks were certainly profitable.
But with rising deposit rates and the expectation of higher rates over the next year (from international inflation) the pressure on the private banks will grow.
Not all loans should have the same lending rate. A customer with a record for repaying promptly has a lower probability of default so the cost of the loan should be lower; that is, reliable customers can borrow at lower rates.
In the United States the concept of the “prime rate” defines the lending rate to customers who have very good repayment records; the risk of lending is almost zero.
Other customers’ borrowing rates are determined by their credit experience and linked to the prime rate that serves as a floor.
Bangladesh context
In Bangladesh there is a tradition that all customers should have the same rate for borrowing.
Of course this is not what happens in reality, but nevertheless this is a common idea.
Bangladesh Bank rules call for a very limited spread between the lowest and the highest risk loans [3%].
The result is low risk, good businessmen pay more than what is warranted by risk; high risk poor businessmen pay less than they should.
In effect the narrow spread between low and high-risk loans subsidize incompetence.
The current 9% cap on lending rates will cause considerable difficulties for private banks during the next three years.
There is no reason to be concerned for the state banks as these do not really function under the rules of good banking. The real concern is for the health and growth of the private banking sector.
The 9% cap and rising deposit rates results in banks losing money.
To prevent that they will weaken all of the rules on identifying NPLs and making provision.
Banks will find ways to avoid classifying a loan as non-performing.
The squeeze of profitability encourages bad lending practice.
Later in this series we will return to some of the critical issues on interest rate policy.
With a rising inflation rate driving up deposit rates, the interest rate structure, already inappropriate as discussed in this article, will have a devastating impact on the private banks.
A bank will lose money on most loans.
The banking system will be happy to finance the growing government deficit.
It is cheaper for the government to reduce the saving certificate program by changes in taxation and lowering interest rates and allow the banks to take up a larger share of the deficit financing by purchase of government securities.
Over the past 15 years the Bangladesh economy has matured and grown briskly under strong government leadership.
With the threats of global inflation and Covid-19 a continuing risk, a strong private banking system is a necessary condition for continued strong economic growth.
To achieve this, the rules on interest rates must be modernized.
One path forward that is a sound continuation of past policies is to establish a prime rate capped according to the government’s analysis of the economy, while allowing other lending rates to adjust to the individual bank’s perception of customer risk.
In such a program the prime rate must be adjusted as the deposit floor moves with inflation.
The best policy would be a floor on fixed deposits and no cap on lending rates.
Better to control deposits, let the major private banks work out a prime rate, and allow banks to establish lending rates appropriate to the credit risks that they assess.
Forrest Cookson is an economist who has served as the first president of AmCham and has been a consultant for the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics.
ANALYSISPowered by Froala Editor
The state of lending rates - Part 2
In this article we take up the charges or costs for non-performing loans.
In article 5 it was demonstrated that the cost of lending, with no allowance for non performing loans, is approaching 8%.
When the bank has a large number of loans some of these will not be repaid.
It is not easy to determine who will repay.
This assessment is one of the critical factors in operating a profitable bank.
The system that Bangladesh Bank has put in place works as follows: Every loan has a repayment schedule and the bank keeps track of the actual payments of interest and principal made by the borrower.
If the repayments fall behind schedule then the bank is alerted to potential difficulties and is required by Bangladesh Bank to make provisions in the event that the loan does not get repaid.
The impact of this is to reduce the asset value of the loan and to reduce the equity of the bank.
The provisions are a cost of doing business.
If the bank is doing well in choosing clients, the volume of NPL will be low and the bank will be profitable.
If the client selection is poor then the provisions will be high and profitability low.
An example will illustrate this:
You make 10 loans each for Tk1 lakh to be repaid after a year. When the time comes for repayment one borrower does not; nine repay.
You have got Tk9 lakh back for the Tk10 lakh you lent.
When you make the loans you need to ask everyone to repay Tk91/9 lakh.
Then you will receive the Tk10 lakh you lent.
This is the pure loan loss cost.
In this case you require 11% extra to cover the losses.
No cost of funds, operating costs, or return on investment are included.
The rule is simple: if the fraction of defaults is x then the extra charge is x/1-x.
If the private banks have 7% bad loans then the bad loan charge is 7.5%.
There are three points to make.
1. All loans are backed by collateral. If the loan is not repaid then the bank will try to take the collateral. In Bangladesh this normally means that the bank will auction off the land that forms the collateral for most loans. In theory the collateral should have a value greater than the loan; but the reality of trying to hold auctions for land is different. There is no really satisfactory data on the actual value of the collateral collected. From some knowledge of what banks report and of the outcome of court cases a reasonable number is 35%. In the above example the cost of the bad loans would be 4.8%[Bad debt costs are 7.5%x0.65=4.55; with this in the x/1-x formula we obtain 4.8%.
2. The bank is failing to earn interest on the non-performing loan. This reduces earning. With a 9% lending rate the effective interest rate is (0.925 X 9%) or 8.3%.
3. The bank may be successful at delaying the onset of provisions by rescheduling. Rescheduling rarely results in improved administration of a project enabling a loan to be repaid; instead it just delays the day when the bank recognizes that it is not going to collect on this loan. A typical outcome is to spread the provision of three years or (4.8/3) or 1.6%. This creates an illusion that the costs of NPL are lower than they actually are.
Cost of lending
The cost of lending at the end of 2021 we have estimated at 8% adding on the bad debt costs we reach 9.6%-12.0%.
But earnings are reduced to 8.3%.
Private banks are now losing 1.3% - 4.6% on every loan that they make!
The situation has deteriorated from the early part of the year due to rising deposit rates.
In all of these numbers we have perhaps overestimated the costs of operating banks but we have also underestimated the volume of non-performing loans.
There are 10 private banks with average deposit rates below 3.5% in June 2021.
At that time these banks were certainly profitable.
But with rising deposit rates and the expectation of higher rates over the next year (from international inflation) the pressure on the private banks will grow.
Not all loans should have the same lending rate. A customer with a record for repaying promptly has a lower probability of default so the cost of the loan should be lower; that is, reliable customers can borrow at lower rates.
In the United States the concept of the “prime rate” defines the lending rate to customers who have very good repayment records; the risk of lending is almost zero.
Other customers’ borrowing rates are determined by their credit experience and linked to the prime rate that serves as a floor.
Bangladesh context
In Bangladesh there is a tradition that all customers should have the same rate for borrowing.
Of course this is not what happens in reality, but nevertheless this is a common idea.
Bangladesh Bank rules call for a very limited spread between the lowest and the highest risk loans [3%].
The result is low risk, good businessmen pay more than what is warranted by risk; high risk poor businessmen pay less than they should.
In effect the narrow spread between low and high-risk loans subsidize incompetence.
The current 9% cap on lending rates will cause considerable difficulties for private banks during the next three years.
There is no reason to be concerned for the state banks as these do not really function under the rules of good banking. The real concern is for the health and growth of the private banking sector.
The 9% cap and rising deposit rates results in banks losing money.
To prevent that they will weaken all of the rules on identifying NPLs and making provision.
Banks will find ways to avoid classifying a loan as non-performing.
The squeeze of profitability encourages bad lending practice.
Later in this series we will return to some of the critical issues on interest rate policy.
With a rising inflation rate driving up deposit rates, the interest rate structure, already inappropriate as discussed in this article, will have a devastating impact on the private banks.
A bank will lose money on most loans.
The banking system will be happy to finance the growing government deficit.
It is cheaper for the government to reduce the saving certificate program by changes in taxation and lowering interest rates and allow the banks to take up a larger share of the deficit financing by purchase of government securities.
Over the past 15 years the Bangladesh economy has matured and grown briskly under strong government leadership.
With the threats of global inflation and Covid-19 a continuing risk, a strong private banking system is a necessary condition for continued strong economic growth.
To achieve this, the rules on interest rates must be modernized.
One path forward that is a sound continuation of past policies is to establish a prime rate capped according to the government’s analysis of the economy, while allowing other lending rates to adjust to the individual bank’s perception of customer risk.
In such a program the prime rate must be adjusted as the deposit floor moves with inflation.
The best policy would be a floor on fixed deposits and no cap on lending rates.
Better to control deposits, let the major private banks work out a prime rate, and allow banks to establish lending rates appropriate to the credit risks that they assess.
Forrest Cookson is an economist who has served as the first president of AmCham and has been a consultant for the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics.