Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

ANALYSISPowered by Froala Editor

A retrospective look at Bangladesh's exchange rate management

This article examines the management of the foreign exchange rate over the past few years and then considers the challenges of the near future
Update : 08 Dec 2021, 03:40 PM

This article examines the management of the foreign exchange rate over the past few years and then considers the challenges of the near future. 

The patterns of international trade have been disturbed by the Covid-19 pandemic.

For Bangladesh this has meant a sharp drop in exports in FY21 followed by a sharp recovery in the first part of FY22.

The significance of this sharp recovery is not yet clear.

Has Bangladesh's RMG industry captured a large increase of the global market?

Or is this a response to temporary production slowdowns in other major RMG producers?

Imports also dropped sharply in FY21 with a sharp recovery to date in FY22.

This is the result of importing goods that have been delayed due to market uncertainty and logistic problems.

Remittances on the other hand increased in the last financial year but are now falling, probably due to the increased under invoicing associated with rising imports.

Over the past two years foreign exchange reserves increased from $31.7 billion to $46.5 billion by the end of October, 2021, leaving the economy in a comfortable position. 

The current account deficit improved from a $4.7 billion deficit in FY20 to $3.8 billion in FY21.

Our forecast is that the current account will go deeper into deficit,of range $10-$13 billion in FY22.

However, allowing for the substantial inflow of capital the overall balance should be in the range $+1 billion to $-3 billion.

This forecast assumes that the exchange rate will be unchanged.

By the end of FY22, the reserve position will continue to be strong.      

During FY22, pressure will emerge to depreciate the Taka.

If Bangladesh Bank is prepared to spend a maximum of $3 billion the exchange rate can be maintained at approximately its current level. 

More likely the rate can be maintained for a $1 billion sale to the market with a small depreciation. 

This will certainly be the approach of Bangladesh Bank.

Upcoming trends

But more serious is the trend over the next two years, FY23 and FY24.

If exports are strong, GDP growth will be strong and imports will grow rapidly.

Remittances are likely to stagnate around the level of $20 billion and perhaps lower as import growth continues.

In these conditions, maintaining the current exchange rate with a rising inflation rate and probable depreciation by competing countries will weaken exports and block export diversification.

More likely export growth will not be able to support the imports needed for 8% GDP growth, as remittances will increase only slowly if at all, and prospects for large inflows of foreign capital depend on a strong export performance.

New FDI is likely to focus on domestic markets, not exports hence actually weakening the foreign exchange position.

Put differently, FDI is important for raising productivity growth and new technologies but does not really help with the balance of payments.

The near future will require stronger economic prospects for exports. Export subsidies are not a very good policy; the subsidies are small and the regulatory hindrances are not removed.

Depreciation is a necessary but not sufficient condition for export diversification.

How the market works

At present the exchange rate level is announced by the central bank informally, but still the banks respect the level.

This permits very small changes in the exchange rate as the central bank makes micro adjustments combined with selling dollars to keep the exchange rate steady.

The difficulty with the micro-adjustment strategy is it pretends to tackle the real problem but does not.

The basic problem of the economy is to accelerate growth and diversify exports.

The exchange rate is right in the middle of the issue.

The current policy of maintaining a stable nominal exchange rate is a direct hindrance to raising the competitiveness of exports.

The RMG sector is competitive for the important range of products that it produces, but its diversification into markets for higher value items and manmade fibers based garments has been slow with unproven competitiveness.

Few RMG manufacturers are prepared to take the risk. 

Other potential exports with multibillion dollar potential, such as shrimp and footwear, are hamstrung by the government's market interference and by the exchange rate management.

The lack of flexibility and the overvalued exchange rate suggest a difficult three years with a slow loss of foreign reserves and a slowing economic growth rate.

This strategy provides insurance against inflation and shifts wealth away from the garment sector owners, discouraging their interest in investing to raise productivity. 

The dilemma arises from the actual strength of the Taka.

As of the time this is written there is a high wave of imports combined with a falling level of remittances.

There is a slight market adjustment but policy seems to be to maintain the current Taka value.

But at its present value the exchange rate blocks diversification of exports.

The nation’s growth strategy is based on rapid export growth (8th Plan and Perspective Plan both require export growth significantly higher than GDP growth.)

The level of the exchange rate and the rising inflation rate will make achievement more difficult.

Problems

The most telling indicator of the problems of the exchange rate arises from the developments of the real effective exchange rate.  The REER corrects exchange rates for differences in the inflation rate in different countries.

As an example consider the trade of Turkey and Bangladesh with the United States. 

Currently the inflation rate in Turkey is about 20% per annum and in Bangladesh 5%.

For our example we take the exchange rate as one lira equals $0.2 dollars and one Taka equals $0.0125 dollars.

An item costs 100 lira to produce in Turkey and Tk1,600 to produce in Bangladesh.

The item is sold for $20 in the USA; the American importer is now indifferent between buying in Turkey or Bangladesh. 

After one year of inflation the production cost in Turkey is 120 lira and in Bangladesh Tk1,680 (we assume costs rise with inflation.)

If there is no change in exchange rates the Turkish producer sells for $24 and the Bangladesh producer sells for $21.

To keep even with Bangladesh Turkey has to depreciate the lira to $0.175 per dollar.

Without the depreciation Turkey is no longer competitive on this item.

If your inflation rate is faster than your competitor’s you have to depreciate to maintain a competitive position.

There is some offset for imported raw materials if the inflation rate for these is less than domestic inflation rate.

But the raw material costs tend to increase and currently costs are inflated by rising transport costs.

For example the CPI for Vietnam is about 2% per annum vs 6% for Bangladesh.

To stay competitive with Vietnam Bangladesh has to depreciate about 4% per annum.

Bangladesh is depreciating about 2% to stay competitive, as the Bangladeshi producer has to reduce the price about 2% per annum. 

The REER does this calculation for all traded goods averaged over all trading partners.

The Taka has been appreciating about 4-5% per annum as measured by the REER.

This steadily reduces the competitive position of Bangladesh. 

The case against depreciation of the Taka is that it will increase inflation. That is true.

But the remedy is to reduce inflation so that competitiveness is not eroded by a high rate of inflation.

If the authorities cannot control the inflation rate then depreciation must follow and the country accepts the inflation.

Overvaluation of the Taka leads to less exports and more imports and ultimately to slower GDP growth.  

Over the past decade the Taka has depreciated 2% per annum while inflation has increased at 6% per annum.

Compared to a country where the depreciation rate equals the inflation rate a Bangladesh exporter falls behind 4% per year.

The RMG exporter reduces his margins, cuts costs often with reduction in quality and generally is under great financial pressure.

The exporter is in a very difficult position with this regular loss of 4% per year.

Taking account of imported new materials the loss will range from 1%-6% per annum.

This downward pressure on profitability is why export diversification does not take place.

To keep the economy growing rapidly either the inflation is contained, best done with a lower government deficit, or the Taka is allowed to depreciate at a pace to maintain broad competitiveness.

 

Forrest Cookson is an economist who has served as the first president of AmCham and has been a consultant for the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics.

Top Brokers