Large fashion brands sourcing clothes from Bangladesh for the UK market reportedly paid below the cost of production, according to a survey.
The survey was conducted on 1,000 Bangladeshi manufacturers and was published on Sunday.
The majority of Bangladeshi factories selling to 24 of the largest global retailers report the retailers paying the same prices almost two years on from the start of the pandemic, despite the cost of raw materials increasing.
Aberdeen University's Business School carried out the research titled ‘‘Impact of Global Clothing Retailers' Unfair Practices on Bangladeshi Suppliers During Covid-19” alongside trade justice charity Transform Trade and the report looked at the period from March 2020 to December 2021.
According to the research, 78 high street brands source from four or more factories and of them, 90% were reported as engaging in unfair practices. These practices included cancellations, failure to pay, delays in payment and discount demands, with knock-on effects including forced overtime and harassment.
Among them, 86% cancelled orders, 85% reduced prices compared with the ones agreed upon in the contract, 50% refused to pay for goods already in transit and production and 85% delayed payment for goods already dispatched for more than three months.
The research said that 50.7% of suppliers experienced unfair purchasing practices.
Larger brands buying from many factories including H&M, Zara, Next, Gap and Primark were engaging in unfair purchasing practices more frequently than smaller brands, suppliers told the surveyors.
Regarding the report, Faruque Hassan, president of the Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association (BGMEA) told Dhaka Tribune that the incidents like order cancellation, discount demand and inability to pay due to the bankruptcy of many brands happened during the Covid-19 time.
“Many brands have also offered lower prices saying they have reduced work orders,” he added.
The report said that 12 of the brands listed in the report were members of the Ethical Trading Initiative which aims to promote workers' rights around the world.
However, a number of retailers denied the claims made in the report, the survey stated.
Professor of Sustainability Accounting and Transparency at the University of Aberdeen Business School Muhammad Azizul Islam led the project.
He said that two years on from the start of the pandemic, Bangladeshi garment workers were not being paid enough to live on, with one in five manufacturers struggling to pay minimum wage while many fashion brands which use Bangladeshi labour increased their profits.
“Inflation rates soaring around the world are likely to have exacerbated this even further,” he added.
Fiona Gooch, a senior policy advisor at Transform Trade, termed this research a wake-up call.
“When retailers treat suppliers badly by breaching previously arranged terms, it is the workers who suffer. If a retailer fails to pay the agreed amount or delays payments, the supplier has to cut costs some other way. This is frequently passed on to their workers who have the least power in the supply chain,” she added.
Faruque Hassan said unfair prices impact the wage of workers, which is why they have always been demanding fair and ethical prices to ensure a living wage.
“It is the responsibility of brands as well as retail consumers to focus on fair payment to ensure fair and ethical supply chains,” he added.
The report also said that nearly two-thirds of the factories reported receiving some financial support from the Bangladesh government or Bangladeshi banks in order to remain afloat.
The ready-made garment industry accounts for 85% of Bangladesh's export income, with more than 12 million Bangladeshis dependent on the sector.
The research was funded by the University of Aberdeen through an award from the Scottish Funding Council under the Global Challenges Research Fund (GCRF).



