Business leaders, although welcoming many of the policies in the proposed budget for fiscal year 2022-23 (FY23), were cautious about certain aspects, as some taxes were hiked, contrary to their expectations.
The trade bodies include Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association (BGMEA), Federation of Bangladesh Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FBCCI), Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce and Industry (MCCI), Dhaka Chamber of Commerce and Industry (DCCI), Bangladesh Chamber of Industries (BCI), and the Foreign Investors' Chamber of Commerce and Industry (FICCI).
The BGMEA expressed concern over increasing source tax on export earnings to 1% from the existing 0.5% in the proposed budget.
The FBCCI said good governance was a major challenge in implementing the proposed budget.
The MCCI thinks that there is ample scope for reforming tax policy, increasing the capacity of tax administration, and providing proper public services.
The DCCI felt that enhancing private sector investment, employment generation, revenue shortfall and financing were some of the challenges of the proposed budget.
The BCI expressed concern over the increase of source tax on export from 0.5% to 1% which will have a negative impact on export, considering the present global scenario.
The FICCI raised concerns about the reduced allocation for some key mega projects in the proposed national budget.
BGMEA
The apparel-sector’s apex trade-body in a recent statement also said the source-tax hike would make the situation difficult for the industry in the current global situation.
However, they also hailed the government for some of its budgetary proposals, including VAT withdrawal on sub-contracting, extension of 15% corporate tax for textile sector for additional three years, continuation of cash incentive, and import duty reduction to 5% from the existing 25% on sewerage treatment plant.
"We hope that the prime minister and the finance minister will consider keeping the source tax for the garment industry at 0.5%," BGMEA acting president S M Mannan Kochi said in the statement.
He also requested the government to continue the existing 0.5% source tax for next five years to help the industry create more employment after overcoming the present crisis situation.
FBCCI
FBCCI president Md Jashim Uddin, in their post-budget briefing on Saturday, noted the importance of ensuring clear direction and planning for the continuous development of efficiency, transparency, accountability and quality of supervision in the implementation of the proposed budget.
He proposed to include in the budget- employment growth, increased domestic investment, increased food production and continued fertilizer subsidies, emphasis on health, education and human resource development, export diversification, job creation and rural development and completion of PM incentive packages and expansion of social security initiatives.
Jashim also expressed his dissatisfaction for not implementing the FBCCI’s recommendations related to tax and VAT.
Replying to a query, the FBCCI president said the trade body does not support money laundering and it brings back the process by paying a nominal tax.
This will discourage honest business in the country, he said.
MCCI
In the existing infrastructure, many eligible organizations with high earnings remain outside the purview of tax, while Individuals/businesses regularly paying taxes are burdened with more and more taxes. This needs to be addressed properly, said the MCCI in their post-budget press release.
The chamber advised the government to adhere to proper and effective financial management to limit expenditure on the financing of government projects in order to keep the budget deficit in check.
MCCI called for government measures to keep prices of energy, food, fertilizers, under control in the upcoming financial year.
The government should not hesitate to increase the deficit if it is required for essential expenditure, infusing funds into the economy and raising aggregate domestic demand. It must look beyond the banking sector for financing this deficit, the release also mentioned.
The size of the Export Development Fund (EDF) needs to be raised at least up to $10 billion from $7.5 billion and should be accessible to all the exporters, it also read.
MCCI appreciated the lowering of the corporate tax rate by 2.5 % (from 22.5% to 20% for listed companies (those that issue shares worth more than 10% of its paid-up capital through IPO) and from 30% to 27.5% for non-listed ones).
The chamber also lauded the government for lowering the tax-deduction-at-source (TDS) rates for the supply of goods and increasing the perquisite threshold.
However, the Chamber suggests reducing the rate of TDS on services such as construction, infrastructure, which generate employment.
However, MCCI was disheartened as no remarkable suggestions for the structural reforms of the VAT Law were present in the proposed budget.
MCCI also appreciated the budgetary provision for a study on central bank digital currency as well as exploring the means to introduce digital banks.
DCCI
In order to attain the targeted GDP, the government needs to focus on widening the tax net gradually, automation of tax structure, fixing up the rational target of revenue collection and consistency of government expenditure, said DCCI president Rizwan Rahman in their post-budget reaction.
Budget implementation is a great challenge and the inconsistency between income and expenditure in the proposed budget may lead to dependency on bank borrowing or loans from foreign sources. Dhaka Chamber thinks that a planned, timely, cost-efficient and implementable budget is more effective than a big budget.
Since the middle and lower-middle-income groups of the society are facing the pressure of inflation, taking it into consideration, the limit of individual income tax can be increased. However, few slabs can be created for the higher income level group but obviously in a rational manner, Rahman also advised.
BCI
The BCI, an apex body of the industries, proposed to keep source tax as before.
Anwar-ul Alam Chowdhury (Parvez), president of BCI, appreciated the proposal to continue the cash incentive given on remittance income and also proposed to encourage remittance income by rescheduling dollar price.
He said the ongoing global economic period was crucial and that earning foreign currency has become difficult.
“I hope the 12% tax rate for all export-oriented industries like readymade garments (RMG) will increase exports, which was a fulfillment of a long-standing demand of BCI,” he added.
He further said that inflation control is a key challenge and, in the budget, this has been set at 5.6% while the current rate is 6.3%.
However, the budget did not give a pathway for that, he mentioned, adding that to control inflation the capacity of local industries should be expanded.
FICCI
"We feel instead of reducing the allocation in mega projects, the government could concentrate on enhancing the quality of spending, which could bring further efficiency as well as generate employment," the apex chamber of multinational companies doing business in Bangladesh said.
It also expressed concern about financing the deficit from banking sources, as that may tighten the liquidity situation.
Also, FICCI has said an entity is required to pay the Workers Profit Participation Fund (WPPF) as per the provision of labour law.
It is not a dividend but rather an expense, a portion of which is also payable to the government. It is an expense not at the discretion of the company but a compulsion. Moreover, an individual is required to pay tax on it for an amount exceeding Tk50,000. Disallowing such a legitimate business expense will increase the tax burden of the compliant businesses, FICCI said.
"Considering the overall existing macroeconomic situation and increasing inflation rate, we feel the tax ceiling for individuals should have been increased, which has not been changed for the last two fiscal periods," FICCI said.
"Reduced tax rates at 10-12% have been introduced for all general industries exporting goods and services. Insertion of the definition of export will reduce the complexities of the export of goods and services. We also believe that this sort of export-friendly initiative will bring export diversification and bring down the trade deficit with other countries."



