In French, there is a saying “je ne regrette pas” which quite literally means “I do not regret.”
But when it comes to e-commerce purchases, I think all of us can raise our hands collectively acknowledging that we regretted our decision at least once in our lifetimes, especially when we paid in advance for something we never received.
Sporadically we also received items that we never even ordered in exchange of something we did order from these online shops.
But all these problems are likely to be put to rest as Bangladesh Bank announced at the end of June that they will only clear payments for “products or services to e-commerce shops” only after the clients have received the goods they ordered.
Furthermore, in order to get clearance for payments, the e-commerce shops will have to provide evidence proving the fact that they have actually delivered the correct goods (or service) to their clients.
Needless to say, this proof is a document that may be signed by the client and may or may not resemble a Bill of Lading.
As per the additional secretary of the Ministry of Commerce and the head of the e-commerce division Md Hafizur Rahman, "A letter has been sent to the Bangladesh Bank on Sunday to issue a circular to the payment gateway companies (banks) to withhold the advance payment of customers for online shopping until the goods are delivered."
This decision came as a result of a gradually ascending liability of Tk403.80 crore as reported by the central bank for the e-commerce Evaly.
Reportedly, a disastrous and ineffective discount policy has led them to this stage where they can only pay a third of what they owe to their e-customers.
Owing to their incessantly increasing liabilities, Bangladesh Financial Intelligence Unit (BFIU) of the central bank has asked for the bank account details of 11 other e-commerce traders, namely the newborn Alesha Mart alongside Aladiner Prodip, Adyan Mart, Bajaj Collection, Boom Boom, Dalal Plus, Dhamaka Shop, Eorange, Needs, QCoom, and Sirajganj Shop.
Nevertheless, it should be noted that the CEO of Evaly remains optimistic about Evaly’s future and expects profits to rise as they soon plan to reduce the amount of discounts.
Regardless, a wave of happiness has circulated around the country after the announcement was made by Bangladesh Bank because some colossal benefits are to follow.
The primary advantage is that clients who have not received their desired products from the e-commerce shop in the estimated delivery time can cancel their order any time and get a refund.
As per Md Hafizur Rahman, buyers can cancel their orders even after two or more days!
Those who are genuine buyers and have suffered due to the recklessness of online shops are likely to benefit the most from this.
Additionally, online shops that have intentionally or unintentionally abused their liberty are going to be hushed away from the market because of their ingenuity.
However, for new and young entrepreneurs, this rule, if brought into flesh, will be problematic and demotivating to say the least because while there may be unprincipled sellers, there may also be unscrupulous buyers.
As surreal as it may seem, some clients intentionally or unintentionally give false addresses, reject the goods even when they are of the correct type and condition and after this rule, will place orders only to cancel them later on.
This will adversely affect the revenue of sellers and even increase their transportation and courier expenses.
A more practical problem is that signatures given by the clients in the e-commerce’s invoice (or receipt) may not match the signature they use for their bank accounts.
Therefore, a procedural complexity will only increase the delay in payment to the seller.
To add to the potential woes of the sellers, the "Digital Commerce Operational Guide-2021" discernibly states that e-commerce shops will have to deliver the goods within 5 days of advance payment (10 days if in rural parts of the country).
Given the pandemic, this may be difficult for the online shops because they too have to bear the consequences of strict lockdowns and travel restrictions.
The guideline also facilitates those affected to pursue remedies in the court of law at the Directorate of National Consumer Rights Protection and other courts if necessary.
Evidently, there is no denying that these rules will benefit the larger portion of the population i.e. the clients of these online shops.
Furthermore, maintaining these rules and staying within the legal limits will also enable the e-commerce shops to balance their liabilities with assets and their profits with losses.
In essence, that can be said to be the main idea behind the adoption of these methods.
Therefore, it can be concluded that the announcement made by the Bangladesh Bank was an appropriate decision and perhaps, the call of the hour and is likely to benefit both the buyers and sellers of the virtual realm in the long run.
The author is an LLM graduate and is a reviewer of the International and Comparative Law Journal.



