Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

OP-ED: The dilemma of imposing taxes on menstrual products

The most difficult one being that in one sense of course we want to tax menstrual products, in another our reaction is - don't be so silly

Update : 26 Jun 2021, 10:51 PM

The removal of VAT from menstrual products contains a number of interesting economic and political observations for us. 

The most difficult one being that in one sense of course we want to tax menstrual products, in another our reaction is - don't be so silly, of course we don't want to.

In a political sense I've always rather enjoyed the recent British experience. 

There has been a campaign for some two decades now to exempt tampons and pads from that value added tax. 

Successive governments had to point out that European Union rules meant that this could not happen. 

Something which has once been subject to VAT cannot, under the rules, then be moved into that class not subject to it. 

That's that – one Chancellor (our finance minister) even made a direct appeal to overturn this idea in this one specific case and was rebuffed. 

It was only after Brexit that this could indeed happen and the VAT was removed.

Given the impossibility even while there was the desire a workaround was devised. 

The VAT that was being paid because it must be charged was put into a separate fund and used to subsidise varied women's groups and charities. 

Once the VAT was removed then so was that set aside – which has led to a lot of shouting about how the current government doesn't value women because it isn't spending as much money on them. Despite, you know, not charging women the money in the first place. 

Which is an interesting little political lesson, it's very hard to reduce spending on a special interest group even when the original reason for doing so has passed.

But there's a larger question here too. We get less of whatever it is that we tax, that's just how it works. 

We also need to raise money to pay for government because at least some of what government does is worth doing. 

Not all and we can have lovely arguments about which but some tax revenue is going to be necessary.

However, how much less of the thing we get that is being taxed depends. Depends upon what is called, in the jargon, the price elasticity of demand. 

Or, how much less of this do we get when we raise the price? 

If we tax land there's no difference in the amount of land. 

If we tax incomes then some people will work less to not pay the tax. So, the price elasticity is higher for incomes than land. 

We can – and do – go through the whole spectrum of everything and work out what these changes in the amount are when the price changes.

When we want to raise money this makes a big difference. Because if people do the same amount, or nearly the same amount, of whatever even when we tax it then we can have a nice high tax rate and collect lots of revenue. 

If peoples' behaviour changes a lot with a small change in price as a result of the tax then we can't get much money from that tax, can we? 

So, we desire, on efficiency grounds, to tax things with a low price elasticity of demand. 

And we can't tax things with a high one because if we do everyone will stop doing it and we get no cash out of them.  

Efficiency tells us we should tax necessities then. Because if something is necessary then people will still buy or do it at the new and higher and taxed price. 

Menstrual products are necessities – we want to tax them therefore. We want to tax them lots and lots in fact for women will still buy them and we've got to get our tax from somewhere.

This then runs into our basic ideas about fairness – equity is the jargon name for this. 

But it's not fair that women should have to pay a high tax on tampons. 

The thing about that observation being that it's entirely and wholly true.

This bringing us to our basic point, that there's an inherent tension in the design of any tax system. All too often the things that we can tax very highly, because they're the necessities that people will still do even when paying tax, are the very things we don't want to tax because they're necessities. There's that conflict between efficiency and equity in a tax system that is.

There is actually no way out of this. 

It's just something we have to make a decision about, what are we going to favour, revenue or fairness, when talking about this specific tax? 

Or, as a truly basic lesson in economics, there are no solutions, only tradeoffs. 

We've just got to try to make the best ones we can in any specific situation. 

The actual task of an economist not being to say which tradeoffs should be made, but to lay them out so the decision can be taken.


Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London

Top Brokers