Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

OP-ED: Where does economic growth go?

Millions of jobs in the newly flourished industries have partially checked unemployment and created avenues for women’s involvement in income generation

Update : 23 Jun 2021, 11:33 PM

The Per Capita Income (PCI) of Bangladesh has reached $2227 in FY 2020-2021 from $2,064 during last year. 

Our PCI has grown from $418 in the year 2000 more than 5.3 times over the last two decades. 

In 2041, the PCI of Bangladesh is expected to arrive at $12,500 as per Bangladesh’s Second Perspective Plan 2021-41. 

By 2041, we are also expected to have 9.9% GDP growth and eliminate poverty. 

Unfortunately, this increase of PCI and growth of our economy have not yet benefitted all equally and less likely to do so in the future if left as it is. 

Of course, improved infrastructures and roads have aided everyone to some extent. 

Millions of jobs in the newly flourished industries have partially checked unemployment and created avenues for women’s involvement in income generation. 

But benefits of the growing economy have not been fairly distributed. 

A simple example: During the lockdown aimed at limiting travel during Eid, those who did not own a private vehicle faced much more difficulty than those who owned one. 

The rich had the means to travel, and the rest had to walk, risk their lives in camped ferries, and few people even died during disembarking an overloaded ferry.

One of the pillars of our economy is the export income earned by garment industries. 

Beside creating millions of jobs, the garment sector earns billions of dollars every year. 

But a recent report revealed, about 43% of female garment workers suffer from malnutrition. 

Why do they not eat enough nutritious foods? Among many reasons, the primary issue is the level of income -- with which RMG workers cannot afford their food requirements. 

If a billion-dollar industry is being run by workers who suffer from malnutrition, we can easily imagine the extent of inequality in our society.

Inequality

The legal minimum wage for garment workers in the country is Tk8,000 ($94.32) a month. 

This is insufficient if we consider it in comparison with the poverty line income, or the cost of basic needs. 

According to the latest Household Income and Expenditure Survey 2016, the minimum amount that a person needs just to stay out of poverty is $26.84 per month. 

Frankly, a family of four members struggles to survive with only one worker’s monthly income.

The scenario becomes even more dismal if we consider the higher thresholds of poverty line benchmarked by the World Bank, which is $3.2 or $5.5 per person per day, instead of $1.9 -- typical of lower-upper middle-income countries.

Recently, Bangladesh’s foreign exchange (forex) reserve crossed $45 billion-mark for the first time in history. 

But if we think of the condition of the overseas workers who beside the garment workers greatly contribute to it by remitting foreign currency, we find that they are also inhumanely treated. 

During the pandemic we have seen them suffering from difficulty in getting Covid-19 test, ticket confirmation, as well as because of the airport and consulate facilities abroad.

The condition of the overseas migrant workers is another side of injustice.

Further neglect

A look at the front lines of our food supply system further reveals signs of grim neglect and inequality. 

PPRC Governance and Economic Survey 2015 revealed disparity among different segments of the population. 

For instance: The average monthly income of people in rural areas -- with agriculture as the major income source -- is Tk18,349. 

The amount is significantly less than the national average monthly income of Tk31,883.

Further, if adjusted for inflation, real income of the rural population has decreased by 9.73% compared to 2012. 

Overall, in Bangladesh, the average monthly income of the bottom 40% of the population is Tk10,657, while for the middle 50% and top 10%, the average monthly income is Tk25,763 and Tk147,388, respectively.

Overall, value of the poor people’s lives is decreasing as our PCI is increasing. 

This can also be proved with other data.

While Bangladesh achieved unprecedented GDP and PCI over the last decades, we tend to forget the continuous rise of inequality over the last 50 years. 

Measure of income inequality from data of BBS show, nationally Gini has risen from 0.36 in 1963 to 0.482 in 2016.

We are achieving the highest levels of growth, and at the same time, we are experiencing the lowest levels of poverty reduction among South Asian countries. 

An analysis of BBS data reveals that the rate of poverty reduction has decreased to 1.2% points annually during 2010-2016 from 1.7% points during 2005-2010.

Moreover, ILO Global Wage Report 2018-2019 found, Bangladesh achieved 3.4% real wage growth in the last 10 years, which is lower than the median growth of 3.7% in South Asia.

Nonetheless, the rich are getting richer. 

As per data from Bangladesh Bank, account with deposits of Tk1 crore and above rose to 71,346 last year from 62,710 in 2019. 

At the same time, poverty rate increased by 7.0 percentage points to 30% in the last fiscal year as per the World Bank’s estimation.

Unsurprisingly, the rise in funds in the accounts with deposits of Tk1 crore and above coincides with the whitening of black money and in the current FY -- the government is allowing declaration of undisclosed wealth and income in tax returns upon payment of 10% tax. 

This does not even require revealing the sources of income. 

In the book The Growth Delusion: Wealth, Poverty and the Well-Being of Nations, David Pilling has argued statistics of growth do not consider an equitable distribution, hence living people are left out of sync. 

The obsession with growth hides the inequitable accessibility of health, education, security, opportunity, goods, and so on.

Rather than being fascinated with the increased PCI, we should be concerned with the ways new wealth can be equitably distributed among the masses. 

Unless we can do it, the growth will only increase misery for most of the population. So, we must track and reveal -- who really are benefiting from the country’s economic growth.

 

 

The author is an anthropologist and teaches at the University of Dhaka. Currently, he is working as a research fellow at the International Institute of Asian Studies (IIAS), Leiden University, The Netherlands.

Top Brokers