The announcement of the budget is near and the main structure is complete.
This article covers some modest thoughts about what to look for in the budget.
There are four points that are important to achieve the primary purpose to lead the society out of the ravages caused by the pandemic.
Above all, one must recognize that there are two key points to keep in mind:
First, economic recovery is slow and only the buildup of aggregate demand will provide higher incomes for the non-agricultural informal workers numbering 35% of the labour force. Spending by the government is expansionary only if the recipient buys something. Typically, very low-income households will spend, whereas wealthier households save or pay down debt. This does not stimulate the economy.
The same effect is found in the stimulus programs of Bangladesh Bank: The program to pay the RMG workers is effective only to the extent that the workers spent the money rather than save or reduce their debts. The loans to enterprises are effective if they buy raw materials, pay workers and increase production; but what seems to have happened is that the loans have been largely used to pay down existing debt.
The fact of distributing money or making subsidized loans improves the economy only if actual spending for goods and services takes place. Otherwise households and enterprises have saved the funds, not put the money into circulation.
Second, the pandemic is far from finished. It is impossible to know how it will evolve over the next year, but everyone must be cautious as the health authorities keep warning us. Bangladesh continues at great risk. What has happened in India is a lesson for us all.
Below are the four points, we need to base our pandemic recovery plan on:
Cash payments
The impact of the pandemic is to reduce employment particularly with micro and small enterprises, that lack the financial resources to survive a few months with low revenues.
These enterprises, largely in the informal sector close down and workers lose their jobs or the salary is reduced as sales decline. Income decline in the informal sector seems to be largely through reduced hours and earnings, while workers appear to maintain their employment in the informal sector. Such enterprises come to life only when demand returns to levels that are more normal.
Larger enterprises can use the banking system to survive as has been possible through the large programs of Bangladesh Bank. But has not worked very well for small and micro enterprises.
Central to the management of the impact of the pandemic is insuring that persons in the informal sector cut off from income and food receive sufficient funds or direct grants of food to support life.
Government distributed cash and food in 2020 support to some extent for low income households. A continuing effort is getting underway at the end of the current fiscal year.
Much more remains to be done.
This effort should be continued in the coming financial year on a larger scale.
To be effective, the list of persons to receive benefits should be steadily improved by experience in implementing the program.
A good rule of thumb is to support the poorest 20% of households. We define poorest by the lowest per capita expenditure households. Expenditure data is much reliable than income data. There are approximately 40 million households in Bangladesh with average size 4.0 persons. There are several million persons resident in institutions such as barracks, prisons, schools, etc.
The target of 20% covers about 32 million persons.
We estimate based on the House Income and Expenditure Survey that before the pandemic the average income of these poorest 8 million households was Tk170,000 per annum. Expenditures were Tk126,000 per annum.
These are adjusted for economic growth and inflation since 2016. This corresponds to $1.40 per person per day, below the World Bank’s $2/day poverty line.
Income loss from the pandemic was about 30%. This corresponds to a loss of Tk40,000 per household.
The objective is five payments of Tk4,000 each, for Tk20,000 per household.
This amounts to about 50% of the income loss of the poorest part of the economy, a total program costing about $2 billion, less than 1% of GDP.
There are two keys to a successful program: The recipients must have a mobile banking account and families included should include the lower income households.
This type of program is the most important for supporting the economy through the pandemic. One hopes that it would be included in the forthcoming budget.Provision should be made for continual improvement of the list and insuring the telephone access is available to enable direct, prompt transfer of the funds.
The lower 20% are all living in poverty and to lose their income is devastating. This recommendation is widespread among Bangladesh economists.
The proposed program in this article is larger than what is usually discussed but this is the level needed to have a real impact on economic welfare of the poor and to increase aggregate demand. The program should increase GDP about 2%.
One hopes the government will implement an aggressive program to protect the poor that is bearing the greatest impact of the pandemic.
RMG sector
The second most important issue for recovery of the economy is to provide necessary support for readymade garment manufacturers. This sector is the key export sector and along with the textile sector the core of the manufacturing sector, comprising about 50% of the value added in large and medium manufacturing. As a consequence of the pandemic the sector faces a drop off of demand and rising competition from other suppliers.
There are a number of short-term issues that need cooperation and support. BGMEA has asked for a repeat of the lending program from 2020. In this program the banks lent money to the companies for the purpose of paying their workers over the three months April, May and June 2020; the loan was subsidized by the central bank which undertook to pay part of the 9% interest rate of the loan. The loan would pay 65% of the base salary of the worker. For the worker this guaranteed they would be at least partially paid for three months.
The factory could participate in this if the owner wanted to do so and if the commercial bank was willing to make the loan. BB effectively guaranteed repayment of the loan. This program was good for the banks that earned 9% on then with little risk of loss.
For companies without orders this in principle enabled them to hold their workers expecting orders to increase enabling the workers to return to work.
For companies that have orders they would pay the workers according to the work they performed using the funds borrowed and the company’s own funds as the payments from the buyers were much delayed.
Factories needs for working capital increased due to the late payments by the buyers. In effect the BB takes on part of the cost associated with the extended period of holding working capital.
The original program was designed hastily but has been criticized for abuse, taking money but not retaining the workers. No doubt, there seemed to be very little effort to supervise the program.
This program seems to have been moderately successful. BGMEA has asked for an extension of this program.
Perhaps a better approach is to finance working capital as required but to assume payment will take 270 days after shipment to arrive, but maintain the subsidy to the interest rate.
There is no way that all workers can be retained. There is a large turnover of workers every year so long term retention of workers who are not working is meaningless. Most factories experience more than 5% turnover of the labor force.
The sector can be given short term support by increasing the export subsidy to 5% from the existing 2%. In addition the subsidy program should be paid rapidly on export documents. This support should be temporary.
It is imperative to keep the RMG and textile sectors strong so as to respond promptly when orders begin to expand. But paying companies to retain workers that are not working is not very sensible.
Health
The nation is threatened with a serious new wave from infections coming from India. There is a great deal to do to prepare for this in advance. Increased availability through more production of oxygen and cylinders, more ventilators, more hospital beds, mobilization of medical students and retired doctors and nurses to staff additional hospital facilities. Finally, purchase of vaccines: The budget should provide funds for purchase of 120 million shots of 2 shot vaccines.
Much more needs to be done to expand testing for surveys of infections and increasing capacity for much more genome sequencing.
Improved data is needed to fight the next round.
Finally, it would be helpful if the PM were to appoint an overall supervisor tasked with pushing through a major procurement and preparation program to guard the society against a future wave.
Taxation
In the past few years, the government has placed very heavy demands on the NBR. The requirement to increase tax collections by unrealistic amounts has led to a breakdown of the revenue system. Rather than a set of rules to enable calculation of the amount due the revenue officers just ask for as much as they can get so that they can meet their revenue targets. All of the fancy carefully worked out rules are tossed out the window.
The government will often claim that the NBR officers are corrupt and that putting them under pressure will force them to give more to the government.
The NBR officers believe the tax payers are hiding income and it is necessary to squeeze money out of them.
From all of these behaviors one ends up with an over-stressed tax system where rules have little meaning. Tax tribunals are far behind in dispute resolution.
This is a good year to not pressure NBR. Let them determine what they can collect rather than the government telling NBR what they have to collect. This will enable the budget process to work smoothly and realistically.
Every year economists argue for establishment of an office of tax policy separate from NBR. This tax policy office would work to establish rules and rates. NBR would collect the taxes but would not make the rules.
Perhaps this year an office of tax policy would be established.
The author is an economist who has served as the first president of AmCham and has been a consultant for the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics.



