Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

OP-ED: The cloudy future of Europe

This is the first of five articles pointing to deeply disturbing changes that are not directly related to the pandemic. These changes will dominate the next decade

Update : 11 Mar 2021, 10:36 PM

Over the past year, there has been a total focus on the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic while many other issues have been less recognised. 

This is the first of five articles pointing to deeply disturbing changes that are not directly related to the pandemic. These changes will dominate the next decade. 

For hundreds of years, conflicts between the UK and shifting coalitions of European nations have fought wars for dominance and resources. 

For much of the period since 1648, the UK acted to balance among the European continental powers so that no coalition was too strong. At the same time, England succeeded in gaining control of Wales, Scotland and parts of Ireland forming the UK.  

By 1900, the UK was the most powerful nation assessed by its economy, its empire, its military power, and the centre of the world’s financial system. 

In literature, physics, biology, chemistry, engineering and mathematics, it was a world leader. Its literature, music and philosophical thought blossomed on the freedom the society provided. Challenges were coming, but one must acknowledge British dominance.  

After the first half of the 20th century with Europe destroyed by violence, the UK’s resources stretched to the limit and with the Russian bear knocking at the door, a major effort was made by the nations of Western Europe to join together in an economic union and to extend this more and more toward closer political ties.

The key was to draw France and Germany close together, hoping to end the violence that had long plagued Europe. These ideas grew to form NATO, the military alliance that joined Canada and the US to the Western European nations; and to an economic community built through a series of steps that began with the unification of the European coal and steel sectors. 

This continued to a customs union that gradually extended over many issues, such as product standards, common interventions in key sectors such as agriculture, labour regulations and environmental rules. 

The greatest step was the unification of the currencies and the establishment of the European Central Bank.   Merging the European economies, the EU emerged as a major economic power with an enormous integrated market.   Reluctantly, the British joined. 

There was never complete agreement among the British people on the merits of joining, and resistance to this involvement continued at a low key. 

Within the Conservative Party, in particular, there was a strong feeling that British sovereignty was being surrendered to the EU Commission. The British refused to join the Euro system, thus avoiding the final step of economic integration.

Eventually, the Conservative Party as the government of the UK in 2010, under great pressure from their members and supporters made the fatal mistake of calling for a referendum on continued British membership in the EU. 

The referendum was held in June 2016 and the British people voted to depart from the EU. By the end of 2020, the major agreements governing the UK’s departure were completed.  

The political cowardice shown by David Cameron, the prime minister, in giving in to the pressures for a referendum will mark him as one of the men that reduced the UK to a midsized, irrelevant nation. 

Within the Westminster system, there is no room for deciding policy by referendums; it is the responsibility of parliament in a representative democracy to make such decisions; Cameron’s inability to stand by the principal led to the sad outcome. 

Cameron himself was never in favour of leaving but failed to reject the concept of choice by referendum. The parliament would never have voted to leave the EU. 

Most economic analysis from reputable analysts forecast a decline in the British economy as a result of leaving the EU. 

One thing that is validated and supported by all economic analysis is that breaking up a group that had been trading without internal tariffs and quotas into two blocks that will impose trade restrictions results in the reduced economic welfare of both. 

But the smaller group will suffer a greater loss. I am very pessimistic about the economic, political and military results. 

The last 75 years have seen a renaissance of Europe. Art, literature, music, science and economic welfare have all recovered to world leadership levels. 

Political ventures of war and conflict have been settled through military and economic alliances. There are plenty of problems, but these were manageable with the UK’s participation. 

The large volume of trade, the free movement of labour within the EU, and the common currency for most of the EU were the foundations on which a very strong political-economic group was being constructed. 

The British brought to this union long experience in governance within a democratic framework. Other EU nations have more limited experience and the presence of the UK was vital to maintain good governance.  

With the departure of the UK, there is a real concern that this leads to the breakup of the EU. 

The UK was a strong stabilising element that commanded the respect and confidence of many of the small countries of the EU. 

During the next decade, Scotland will likely separate from England and join the EU as an independent country. Northern Ireland is likely to depart the UK and form a new nation with the Irish Republic. 

England and Wales, the remains of the day, will shrink as a nation, perhaps re-joining the EU, or perhaps just accepting their diminished role as a little England.  Lots of sleepy charm, but no longer a leader of the world.  

The London that we all love will shrink in wealth, excitement and art as the financial sector [The City] departs for New York and Europe. 

A sad loss of importance for the nation that above all others showed the way to freedom through democracy and wealth through markets and free trade. 

Perhaps like all nations [empires] that rise to control the world, the British needed their empire exploiting others to achieve high wealth for a small part of the economy; just as the Americans needed slavery and taking the land from the Indians. 

European imperialism is over; what is needed is a large market properly governed, exactly what the EU sought to achieve without an imperial agenda.

The UK is in a decline that will not stop soon. For British people, Brexit is a disaster.  

The fate of the EU in the next few years is equally cloudy. With the departure of the UK, power in the EU shifts even more to Germany and Eastern Europe. 

Italy and Spain have weak economies. Germany dominates and France does not have a strong manufacturing sector to balance Germany’s. 

The EU will find a way to rebuild its relationship with the US that was so badly damaged by the Trump presidency. Obama had opposed Brexit and encouraged the UK to remain; Trump was a proponent of the British leaving.  

In the past 50 years, the EU with Britain as a member worked closely with the US.  That alliance is now in doubt. 

The departure of the UK reduces the ability of the alliance to do well together. Britain was a lynchpin between the EU and the US. 

American political developments have led to a loss of confidence in the post-war alliances, made more difficult by Brexit. 

Increasingly, the world will become a three-player game: China, the US, and the EU. Little England, after centuries of leading, since 1945 in tandem with the US, will no longer be a significant force.  

To those who admire the great political and cultural accomplishments of Britain, the decline is a source of great sadness. 

Our world is built on the foundation laid down by Newton [physicist and mathematician], William Shakespeare [the man who saw all], Michael Faraday [the unraveller of electricity and magnetism], Adam Smith [formulator of markets], David Hume [the greatest philosopher who took on religion], Arthur Wellington [soldier who defeated Napoleon], Winston Churchill [war leader without peer], Jane Austen [whose stories taught us about the reality of families], Paul Dirac [who took the first steps towards particle physics], John Stuart Mill [who made us see what liberty really means], Alan Turing [winner of World War 2, inventor of the computer, and great mathematician], and John Maynard Keynes [economist, founder of modern economic policy and international finance]. 

These thirteen men and women of Great Britain developed the basics of the present successful societies of Japan, South Korea, Western Europe and the US. 

Our freedom, science, technologies, liberties, literary world and economic systems rose from their seminal work. The very world leadership of Great Britain was one of the driving factors in their achievements.

 

The author is an economist

Top Brokers