Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

OP-ED: Are there too many banks?

Good, there should be such a discussion

Update : 05 Dec 2020, 11:53 PM

There is a discussion going on about the banking system in Bangladesh, as this newspaper reported on November 26. 

Good, there should be such a discussion. However, there is a philosophic difficulty with what is being said about what should be done. 

The initial observation, there are far too many weak banks, is entirely true. This is not, though, the same as an observation that there are too many banks. Which is the assumption that is being made. 

Khondkar Ibrahim Khaled, a former deputy governor of the Bangladesh Bank, points out that there are so many banks that soon they will be like grocery stores. This is to make the assumption that there is something wrong with grocery stores. 

Myself, I rather like grocery stores. I want some food, there is a store with food in it on every corner. I can, therefore, easily get the food I want. There are grocery stores that specialise as well, up market, simple products, things for foreigners, or different diets or cuisines. 

Great, variety and choice, all at reasonable cost and all easily available. Why wouldn’t we want our banks to be like that? We desire banking services, why shouldn’t there be an ecosystem providing them which is as convenient and sensible as grocery stores? That is, the thing being warned against is what we should be having as our goal.

Which brings us back to our original observation about weak banks. It’s not that there are too many banks, rather that too many are weak. This rather changes the prescription for what we ought to do about it all.

If we simply have too many banks then the advised action -- force many of them to merge -- works. Having fewer is a solution to having too many. 

If the problem is weak banks, then the solution is different. For merging weak banks, even with strong ones, just retains the weakness in the system. It doesn’t eliminate it. That portion of the merged banks that was weak is still weak, that is.

The proposed solution is that the central bank should be able to insist upon banks merging. This places too much power in the hands of the central bank, but that’s a political complaint, not an economic one. 

Who has to merge with whom always will be a political question, won’t it and it’s not obvious or certain that we want to increase political power inside the economy.

The better solution is to have -- and enforce, always an important part -- rules that insist upon the strength of banks. 

As everywhere else, you must have a capital ratio of this, must not lend too much of the portfolio into this or that company or even business area and so on. Insist that only banks which are strong may remain as banks. But also, and crucially, allow as many who meet these standards to be banks.    

As with grocery stores, anyone who agrees to and does meet the standards for hygiene and so on can be a grocery store. So it should be for banks. This removes that worry about the concentration of economic power into the political system, because we have just the one set of rules. Meet them and you’re fine.

That’s what the general structure should be, at least. As ever with banking things do become a little more complicated. Because there will be times when a bank fails. 

Sometimes because it has violated the rules but sometimes just because. The whole system of banking has a weakness built into it, what happens if we all turn up at the same time and ask for our money back? 

The bank goes bust, it just does. Equally, if a bank lends to the wrong people and loses it capital we don’t want that to mean that all the depositors lose their money. This means that the central bank does in fact need the power to be able to order mergers. 

We take the bust bank and split it into two parts. The part that went bust -- the “bad bank” -- and put that over to one side. There it can just moulder away, do no more new business, and we can allow it to decay away over time. 

The good bank, the bits that didn’t go bust plus all the deposit money, can be allowed to gain new capital and start all over again. Almost certainly, as a part of a merger with another bank.

So what is being said should be done and what should be done aren’t entirely different then. The central bank does need the power to compel banking mergers of weaker banks. It’s the when and the why that’s being argued over. 

When a bank is too weak to meet the prudential rules then yes, merge, close down, you’re breaching the prudential rules so you must do something to meet them. But being able to insist upon bank mergers just because there are too many banks, no, that’s the wrong way to go about it.

After all, if we had lots of banks and were able to easily deposit money, borrow money, at reasonable prices and in convenient locations, that would be a real problem we had there, wouldn’t it? Banks would be like grocery stores and that would just be terrible.   


Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London

Top Brokers