The proposed budget for fiscal year 2019-20 lacks accountability, transparency, and proper guideline for reducing inequality and ensuring inclusiveness, experts have said.
Moreover, they fear, the huge borrowing target from the banking sector to meet budget deficit will hinder the private sector investment.
Business people, economists, politicians and researchers came up with the observations at CPD Budget Dialogue 2019 organized by Centre for Policy Dialogue in the capital yesterday.
CPD Distinguished Fellow Mustafizur Rahman moderated the dialogue, where Planning Minister MA Mannan was present as chief guest and CPD Chairman Professor Rehman Sobhan presided over the event.
Kazi Nabil Ahmed, MP, Member, Parliamentary Standing Committee on Ministry of Finance, attended the program as special guest.
“In my opinion, the proposed budget unfortunately lacks accountability and transparency as when a government agency is saying a thing, another is saying the other, which is not good for a democratic government,” said Mohammad Fazlul Azim, chairman of Azim Group.
When the government would say something, all its agencies should respect it, he said.
CPD, a local think tank, has found discrepancies between data provided in the budget speech.
“There is a substantial difference between data provided National Board of Revenue (NBR) and Ministry of Finance (MoF),” CPD Executive Director Fahmida Khatun said in her keynote presentation.
“This may be due to institutional incompetency or a informed political choice,” she observed.
In the case of tax deduction rates at source on the bill of contractors and suppliers, the first slab was mentioned to be up to BDT 25 lakh in the budget speech, she cited, adding that a document provided by NBR mentioned the first slab to be up to BDT 15 lakh.
In both documents, the second slab followed the upper limit of the first slab, which she said created much confusion.
In addition, a politician observed that higher borrowing target would hinder investment ultimately affecting employment generation.
“To meet the budget deficit, Tk47,000 crore would be taken from the banking sector, which will hurt the private sector investment. As a result, employment generation will be hampered,” said Barrister Rumeen Farhana, BNP's reserved seat lawmaker.
On top of that, default loans have turned into epidemic but there was hardly any action against it, she said.
No direction about decreasing inequality
“We all recognize the high positive achievement of high growth and poverty reduction and other factors contributing to these. However, this issue of reduction of poverty is not the same thing as reduction of income inequality and growing social disparity what was evident from the budgeting presentation and the also discussions taking place over this,” said Professor Rehman Sobhan.
A lot of these economic and social disparities originated from government allocation decision for giving subsidies and tax exemption spending public money or inability to make decision, which would arrest this, he observed.
“Bangladesh is in the second position in terms of the rising number of rich people. In the country, four crore out of 16 crore people are poor, of which about two crore are ultra poor. Inequality is increasing day by day but there is no clear direction in the budget to address it,” said Farhana.
Responding to comments of the discussants, Planning Minister MA Mannan said: “Government's aim is to remove poverty and it is on the right track.”
To this end, the minister said, the government was building infrastructure, community hospitals, schools, power plants to take services to people's doorstep to reduce inequality.
"In addition, we are taking measures including strengthening Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) to improve transparency and accountability in data, and budget allocation and expenditure," said Mannan.
Mannan said in Bangladesh people affected by hardcore poverty was not more than 50-60 lakh at this moment while the number of poor people was around 3 crore.
He claimed the government achieved much progress in reducing poverty.
Question raised over GDP growth
“Bangladesh has attained over 8% GDP growth but it is not consistent with other indicators. This growth is one kind of bubble,” said Amir Khasru Mahmud Chowdhury, standing committee member of Bangladesh Nationalist Party and former commerce minister.
GDP growth was being used as a political tool, said Khasru, mentioning that when it was being said that the country was marching forward, private sector investment remained stagnant.
On the ailing banking sector, Khasru suggested that the banks should rather be allowed to die instead of pouring public money into them as recapitalization fund.
On the proposed 15% tax on excess reserve exceeding 50% of a company's paid up capital and 15% tax on stock dividend, Amir Khasru said that the proposed measures would discourage capital creation and reinvestment.
He claimed that market capitalization to GDP ratio on the Dhaka Stock Exchange was 20% in 2006-10, which was now 14%.
Heath and Education sector needs more
In the proposed budget, there were some good initiatives such as an allocation of Tk100 crore for startup, 2% incentives for remittance, 1% cash incentives for RMG sector in all markets, step to bring 3,000 education institution under monthly pay order (MPO) coverage, said Kazi Nabil Ahmed.
Besides, different types of policy supports, including allowing whitening of undisclosed money, were offered to attract private investment, said Nabil.
He mentioned that allocation for health and education sector, Tk87,000 crore, was not limited to the two ministries but involved 28 ministries in total.
'I am not saying that it is enough for 16 crore people. These sector needs more allocation," Nabil.



