An all round rejection of the polls, scores of reports, television footage, video clips, and witness accounts dispel even the slightest doubt that the city polls were unfair. Even winning candidates have acknowledged the allegations, even if partially, saying fouls are inevitable in a sport.
This, however, sharply contradicts the statements of the Election Commission claiming the polls in the two Dhaka city corporations and Chittagong were fair and consequently calls its integrity into question.
The ruling government, which saw all its mayoral candidates win, remains the only political camp vouching for the fairness of the polls.
Following the controversial national elections of January 5, 2014, and the recent city polls, the intent of the EC led by Kazi Rakibuddin Ahmad and its ability to cope with pressure are in serious doubt.
Critics have branded the election office spineless and subservient to the government, especially because there have been a number of city polls, since the national election, under the same commission that were considered fair by and large.
The main political opposition, BNP, had swept all those city polls of Rajshahi, Barisal, Khulna, Sylhet and Gazipur.
Many have gone as far as to say that this commission is the worst that Bangladesh has seen since its independence in 1971. Some have also alleged that the commission’s abject failure destroyed the image of this constitutional body and people’s faith in the electoral process.
The Election Commission is the supreme authority and solely responsible for holding free, fair and credible elections. Hence it is empowered by law with ample power to conduct fair and credible elections.
Although the chief election commissioner made the right of noise on the eve of the city polls saying that irregularities would be dealt with strictly, Kazi Rakibuddin Ahmad was silent when reporters confronted him even as reports of ruling party’s widespread vote rigging were coming in.
Rakibuddin, instead, demanded on Tuesday that the journalists show him where these were going on. Later on Tuesday he went on to say that the elections had been fair, to be echoed only by ruling Awami League leaders.
Mohammad Ali, former election commissioner, said city polls plainly showed that people’s apprehension of vote rigging had come true and that the commission should have deployed the army without backtracking from its original directive which called for army patrols on city streets.
“Everything was shown in media. So everybody knows what happened,” he said adding none of the previous city polls had been so controversial under any other commission.
Ali, who was commissioner during 2001-2006, said, “We have conducted Chittagong city polls and the Awami League backed candidate won the polls during a BNP tenure. To maintain law and order, we had transferred the then Chittagong police commissioner as he was biased.”
Imtiaz Ahmed, a professor of International Affairs at Dhaka University and political commentator, said, “We can blame the Election commission but I think it is up to the government whether they want a fair election. Because the problem is those who are in power want to stay on through election. It makes the job tough for the commission. Yes, the commission can resign but will it bring any change?”
Tofail Ahmed, a local government expert, said, “It does not seem that there was such a body as the election commission during the polls.”
He said the commission could have done a number of things but did not. “They have the army, police and magistrates. What did they do during the polls? The commission has completely failed. That is why voter turnout was poor.”
Salahuddin Aminuzzaman, a teacher of Dhaka University, said: “As a citizen, I am frustrated over the election. Election Commission’s role was not visible, and they could have been more active.”
A local government expert seeking anonymity said it was not an election at all.
Shakhwat Hossain, former election commissioner, said that the electoral system seemed to have been non-existent.
He said the Election Commission had no control from the very first day that was even more plainly seen on the day of the election. “I also feel sorry for the election officials, with whom I have worked, as they have nothing to say.”
Iftekharuzzaman, head of corruption watchdog Transparency International Bangladesh, said the Election Commission and law enforcers had failed to carry out their duties which raised questions about the entire election.
“We are deeply concerned about the failure of a constitutional body like the Election Commission. The commission has embarrassed itself denying the allegation of mass rigging even after sufficient proof and information. The Election Commission has not only failed to carry out its role but due to its biased behaviour, this constitutional body’s image and trust was also destroyed.”
Ataur Rahman, a political scientist, said the incumbent commission should be pressured to quit the office accepting their failure to hold a fair election and the whole election office should be recast.
“People have lost their trust in the electoral system and the culture of election has all but fallen flat on its face. This is very alarming. Even gentlemen will not be encouraged to contest polls anymore.”



