Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Criticism hounds EC formation law bill

The bill had been widely demanded by political parties

Update : 15 Oct 2022, 03:05 PM

The government is rushing to enact a bill on the reconstitution of the Election Commission, but electoral experts and civil society members claim the bill is still not ready.

The EC law bill in its current iteration grants too much power to the prime minister in the process of appointing the chief election commissioner and election commissioners, which may hamper the holding of free and fair elections, they alleged.

The parliamentary standing committee on the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs has already reviewed the bill, and it is set to be placed in parliament today. The tenure of the incumbent KM Nurul Huda-led Election Commission will expire on February 14.

According to the bill, a six-member search committee will be headed by a judge of the Supreme Court's Appellate Division. The committee will also include a High Court Division judge, the comptroller and auditor general, the chairman of Bangladesh Public Service Commission, and two other persons nominated by the president.

The search committee will recommend two names for each of the election commissioner posts and the chief election commissioner post, and the president will form the EC from among these names.

Power through the president

Experts said there is no scope for the president to take a decision on anything other than the appointment of the prime minister and the chief justice under Article 48 (3) of the Constitution. Any other decision of the president has to follow the advice of the head of the executive branch, and that is the prime minister.

As a result, giving the president the power to select the members of the Election Commission as well as two members of the search committee would give the prime minister undue influence in the formation of the commission, they argued.

Members of civil society suggested that the leader of the house in parliament, leader of the opposition, and leader of the third largest political party in parliament nominate members of the search committee instead of the president.

“The prime minister will definitely play a key role in forming the election commission as per the bill, as the president has to take all decisions by following her advice,” said election expert Dr Badiul Alam Majumdar. 

“The EC will not be independent and accountable to the people under the proposed law, as they will be appointed on the will of the prime minister,” he added.

He further called for the names recommended by search committees to be made public, so that all stakeholders could give their opinions on the candidates before the Election Commission was formed.

Views of all stakeholders need to be considered

On Saturday, former chief election commissioner ATM Shamsul Huda said: “There is no real representation of people in the current parliament. The draft law should be finalized after considering the views of all concerned.”

He urged all major political parties to be actively involved in the process of enacting the EC law.

BNP lawmaker Harunur Rashid has already strongly opposed the bill, describing it as “nothing but a search committee bill.” 

He added that it did not reflect the views of civil society and political parties.

“There is nothing new in the bill. Many questions have been raised about the bill, and the proposed law will not resolve the present crisis,” he further said.

On Monday, BNP MP Rumeen Farhana claimed the parliamentary standing committee on the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs had neglected her recommendations when reviewing the bill.

President Abdul Hamid began dialogues with political parties on the reconstitution of the Election Commission in December last year. The enactment of a law on the formation of the commission was a major demand of several political parties during the dialogues.

In late December, Law Minister Anisul Huq had ruled out the enactment of an EC law on an urgent basis, saying that it would take time to enact the law properly. 

“Yes, the constitution has provision to make the law and we want to do it. But since it’s a very important law it can’t be done overnight,” he had said during a program in Dhaka on December 30.

Later, the law minister said: “The law is going to be drafted as the political parties demanded it during the dialogues with the president.”

On January 17, the Cabinet approved the draft of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioner Appointment Act, 2022. The bill was first placed in parliament on January 23, before being sent to the parliamentary standing committee on the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs for review.

The parliamentary standing committee finalized the draft with two changes to the eligibility and disqualification section on Monday.

Top Brokers