Although Bangladesh is paying tribute to the intellectuals martyred during the 1971 Liberation War on Friday, confusion abounds when considering who the intellectuals that contributed to Bangladesh’s independence actually are.
The Ministry of Liberation War Affairs is yet to prepare a list of the martyred intellectuals, despite repeated pledges to do so.
After the Awami league assumed office in 2008, the government’s sincere and gradual initiatives to honour freedom fighters and intellectuals by preserving the war’s history had raised hopes among cultural personalities, intellectuals and historians.
However, controversies arose regarding the creation of the freedom fighter list, with many fake freedom fighters becoming revealed, and both the freedom fighter and martyred intellectual lists have been pending since.
Intellectuals and young professionals from 1971 who have risen to fame in the modern day have expressed their disappointment with the entire process.
Many of them fear they may not be honoured even after their death.
Meghna Guhathakurta, researcher and daughter of Shaheed Jyotimay G Thakurta, said: “We want to pay tribute to the martyred intellectuals, but how can we honour them if we do not know who they are?”
She added that such information needed to be documented, in order to make the history of the Liberation War more credible.
Meghna further said intellectuals massacred by the Pakistan Army during Operation Searchlight were often discussed as if they were separate from others killed during the War for Independence, but everyone who gave their life for Bangladesh in the war should be commemorated.
Martyrs' list still absent
Liberation War researcher and history professor Muntasir Mamun said nearly fifty years had passed since the Liberation War, and the chance for making a creditable list of martyrs was fading away with time.
“Within a few years, such records could face manipulation as there would be a scarcity of credible sources,” he said.
Prof Muntasir added that the creation of the list is a slow and arduous process, and establishing an exact number of martyrs would be difficult as different figures are quoted by different sources.
In a statement on December 20, 1971, a spokesman from the Provisional Government of Bangladesh said 360 intellectuals were killed before the Pakistan Army surrendered on December 16.
On December 18, two days after the war was won, famous filmmaker Zahir Raihan was made convener of the Buddhijibi Nidhan Tathyanusandhan Committee, a 17-member group tasked with investigating the massacre of intellectuals during Operation Searchlight.
The committee examined a list compiled by Major General Rao Farman Ali in his diary at the governor’s house. A list of martyrs prepared by the committee included 20,000 names, recorded both from Major General Rao Farman’s list as well as national newspapers of the time.
According to the committee’s report, the killings took place on more than 5,000 sites across country, of which 2,000 can be memorialized while the others have been taken over by construction.
Zahir Raihan himself disappeared on January 30, 1972, while trying to locate his brother and renowned writer Shahidullah Kaiser. Shahidullah had been picked up along with the majority of martyred intellectuals on December 14, 1971.
How many intellectuals actually died?
After Zahir Raihan’s disappearance, the work of the Buddhijibi Nidhan Tathyanusandhan Committee was disrupted by several coups and political instability.
On the other hand, the documentary “Bangladesh” by ASM Shamsul Arefin quoted a 1972 government publication as saying that 1,109 intellectuals were killed during Operation Searchlight.
According to the documentary, the deceased included 21 university, 637 primary, 270 secondary, and 59 college teachers, 50 physicians, 41 lawyers, 13 journalists, and 16 composers, filmmakers and cultural personalities.
A biographical encyclopedia of martyred intellectuals by the Bangla Academy titled “Shaheed Buddhijibi Koshgrantha” put the number at 232, but said the list was “neither complete nor comprehensive.”
Meanwhile, the Banglapedia says 1,111 intellectuals were killed in 19 districts during the Liberation War.
However, Liberation War researchers argue that the number of martyred intellectuals could be over 10 times higher.
A number of recent incidents have led to calls for completion of the freedom fighter and martyred intellectual lists.
Cultural personality Nasir Uddin Yousuf Bachchu lamented that distinguished photographer Anwar Hussain was buried without state honours earlier this month, despite being famous for his work during the Liberation War.
“I don’t know why he was not given a guard of honour, even though he was buried at the freedom fighter’s graveyard,” Nasir said.
“The government’s work to preserve the history of the Liberation War had raised hopes that the unrecognized intellectuals and war heroes would get proper honours, but the hope seems to have been in vain,” he added.
Staff Photojournalist Pavel Rahman said many renowned people who did not participate in the war directly but contributed through their work do not want extra facilities from the country.
“However, they at least deserve state honours after their death,” he added.
Liberation War Affairs Minister AKM Mozammel Huq said separating the intellectuals from among 3 million martyrs was a difficult task.
He added that they had asked for help from local administrators and had received some feedback, but the information so far gathered was not very credible.
“The project to list martyred intellectuals needs an overhaul,” he said.



