The International Crimes Tribunal 2 has said it found prima facie evidence on a news item published in the daily Prothom Alo and an editorial published in The New York Times, adding that “the news item and the editorial in question seem to have been based on misconception and exceeding limit of recognised norms.”
Justice Obaidul Hassan, chairman of the tribunal, and Justice Md Shahinur Islam came up with the opinion yesterday in a suo moto order.
The tribunal also asked the Prothom Alo editor to submit by December 31 the full text of a statement where 50 eminent personalities expressed concern over the punishment of journalist David Bergman for contempt of court.
The tribunal registrar and spokesman, Mustafizur Rahman, briefed the media about the order yesterday afternoon.
Based on a statement, the Bangla daily on December 20 published a report titled “50 people express concern over Bergman’s punishment.” On December 23, The New York Times also published an editorial titled “Muzzling Speech in Bangladesh” where it criticised the conviction.
The tribunal said: “Further necessary order will be passed on analogous examination of the statement published in the daily Prothom Alo and the editorial published in The New York Times.”
In the order, the tribunal said: “The news speaks of a ‘statement’ made by 50 citizens expressing view and criticism on the order punishing David Bergman on contempt charge. The news item prima facie shows that the ‘statement’ expresses concern about the freedom of expression of journalist, researcher and analyst on the issue of ‘death figure in 1971.’ Presumably the signatories are in impression that the contemnor has been punished for making criticism on ‘death figure in 1971.’”
The tribunal also said: “...In order to dispel misconception and since the tribunal is obliged to protect its jurisdiction and authority, we indispensably need to know whether the statement has been made in the interest of public and on the basis of which analysis the signatories have made such statement.”
On its editorial, The New York Times said the court was “wrong” in its contempt order and said it should overturn Bergman’s sentence and conviction.
The tribunal said: “We fail to understand how a daily newspaper of international repute asks a court of law of a sovereign country by saying - ‘it should immediately overturn Mr Bergman’s sentence.’”
The tribunal initiated contempt proceeding against Bergman, editor (special reports) of daily New Age, in April after the court found “prima facie elements of contempt” in his three write-ups posted in his personal blog in November 2011 and January 2013.
In December, the tribunal 2 found him guilty of contempt. The tribunal sentenced him to “imprisonment till rising of the court” and fined him Tk5,000 for demeaning the court authority through his two other articles.



