Yesterday was a bad day for the prosecutors of the war crimes trials, as two of their colleagues got bashed by the two International Crimes Tribunals for poor performance and lack of preparation.
The first International Crimes Tribunal yesterday indicted alleged war criminal Syed Hasan Ali for the crimes that he had committed against humanity in Kishoreganj district in 1971.
Before passing the indictment order, a tribunal judge asked prosecutor Abul Kalam whether he had anything to say.
When Kalam prayed to the judges to frame charges against the accused, Justice Jahangir Hossain said: “You have mentioned in the formal charge, submitted by you, that Hasan Ali had attacked the Purba Para. But in another place [in the documents] you said it was Pal Para.”
When the judge asked Kalam which name should then be taken as correct, the prosecutor replied that it would be Pal Para.
Justice Jahangir then said: “There are many such errors [in the charges submitted by the prosecution]. We do not want to disclose them in front of everyone.”
But, a little later, the justice quoted another section from the charge documents: “In one place it is written that two tolas of gold and TK24,000 were looted. But in another place it is said 20 tolas of gold and TK25,000...Someone can mistakenly write 20 instead of 2 by putting an extra zero, but how can 24 become 25?”
He also said: “Mr Abul Kalam, law profession is not so easy although it is a noble profession...Please study before coming here.”
Then the chairman of the tribunal Justice M Enayetur Rahim asked prosecutor Kalam to take his seat.
Meanwhile, the second war crimes tribunal, hearing arguments in the war crimes case against Abdus Sobhan, yesterday rebuked prosecutor Sultan Mahmud Simon for not being able to give satisfactory answers to questions.
It happened when the tribunal, comprising Justices Obaidul Hassan, Md Mozibur Rahman Miah and Md Shahinur Islam, asked the prosecution a question and prosecutor Simon kept on groping into the case documents to find the answer.
The tribunal told Simon that he looked as if he had been reading the case materials for the first time. “You [Simon] should have done homework and should have read [case materials] before coming to the court,” the tribunal said.
These are not the first time that the tribunals had came down hard on the prosecutors for poor preparation and performance.
In the past, one of the tribunals dismissed a prosecutor from the courtroom for not being prepared.
Even the Supreme Court, while hearing on the appeals of war criminal Kamaruzzaman, criticised Attorney General Mahbubey Alam and other state counsels for the same reasons.
The attorney general himself have spoken openly about the poor performance of the prosecution team which is said to have led to the overturning of the death sentence given to Delawar Hossain Sayedee.
Charges against Hasan
Yesterday, the first International Crimes Tribunal framed charges against Syed Hasan Ali for committing crimes against humanity in Kishoreganj in 1971.
The three-member tribunal, headed by Justice M Enayetur Rahim, framed the charges against Hasan on six counts of crime. The two other members of the tribunal are Justices Jahangir Hossain and Anwarul Haque. The court also fixed December 7 for hearing the opening statement in the case.
According to the prosecution, the 65-year-old alleged war criminal was a commander of the razakar force, an auxiliary of the Pakistan army in 1971, in Tarail of Kishoreganj.
The probe against the accused began on June 6 last year.
His father Moslem Uddin was the president of the local peace committee during the Liberation War.
On April 27, 1971, Hasan looted and torched seven houses included those of Hasan Ahmod Alias Hachu bepari in Purbopara of Sachail village in Tarail.
On August 23, 1971, he looted the houses of Martyr Tofazzal Hossain Bhuiyan alias Lalu Bhuiyan in Konabhawal village in the same upazila. He also allegedly murdered Tofazzal and abducted two others.
On September 9, ten house was looted and torched by Hasan in Shimulhati village. Twelve people, including Okru Pal, was murdered.
On September 27, he looted good worth Tk25,000 at Borgaon village in Tarail. He also murdered eight including Satish Ghosh and abducted and confined 10 others.
On October 8, Hasan ransacked six rooms at the homestead of Kamini Kumar Ghosh in Arai-ura village in Tarail. Kamini and one Jibon Chakraborti was abducted and later murdered.
On december 11, at least 100 houses were looted and torched by Hasan Ali in Poshchimpara of Shachail village in Tarail and one Rashid Ali Bepari was murdered.



