Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

90% physicians slip through tax net

Update : 15 Oct 2014, 10:02 PM

The National Board of Revenue (NBR) has taken an initiative to identify tax-evading physicians and bring them under the tax radar, as around 90% physicians with taxable incomes reportedly do not file their income tax returns.

NBR officials said although physicians earned large amounts of money from private practice and diagnostic centres as well as their regular salaries from public or private hospitals or institutions, an overwhelming majority of them did not pay any tax.

They added that most taxpayers who did file their returns, showed less income in tax statements than what they actually earned.

According to data compiled by the NBR, only around 10,000 physicians have tax files whereas the Bangladesh Medical and Dental Council (BMDC) has already published details of 60,000 registered doctors and dentists on its website.

There are also a large number of unregistered doctors who earn a lot by consulting patients at different chambers.

Many top physicians allegedly hide information about the wealth generated from different commissions, diagnostic centres and chambers. These doctors reportedly charge higher fees from hospitalised patients and also get a considerable amount of commission if patients are hospitalised with their references.

NBR Chairman Md Ghulam Hussain recently told the Dhaka Tribune that around 90% of the physicians did not pay proper amounts of tax and so initiatives would be made to bring them under the tax net.

“Efforts to bring not only the doctors but also other professionals within the tax net have started and will continue,” he added.

CIC investigation

The Central Intelligence Cell of the NBR has already prepared a list of 537 physicians and collected their income tax-related documents from its respective field offices.

Asking not to be named, a senior NBR official told the Dhaka Tribune that the physicians’ concealment of income-related information would be detected by auditing tax files.

 “Doctors make a lot of money from attending patients at different chambers. None of them charge less than Tk500 and some charge even more than Tk1,000,” another NBR official said.

The official added that renowned physicians consulted 30 to 80 patients every day, but their income tax statements did not reflect that sort of income.

He said tax officials had already served letters to different banks and financial institutions, asking them to submit documents related to financial transactions of around 200 top physicians who were suspected of concealing wealth information. The CIC has sought details of financial transactions made by these doctors between July 2007 and now.

Following a huge mismatch between those physicians’ declaration of income in tax returns and their actual earning, tax officials have also decided to scrutinise their tax files, while the rest would also be brought under tax net, the official added.

Former NBR chairman Mohammad Abdul Majid, however, opined that had the circle officials concerned done their work properly, there would have been no need to bring such regular cases under special intelligence activities.

“If the regular activities, which should be properly monitored, are brought under the special activities of the CIC, the philosophy of tax collection is hampered. The authorities should encourage professionals to pay tax and the circle offices should do their work properly on time to bring people under tax radar,” he said.

Earlier in a primary investigation, the NBR had found that these physicians evaded tax through concealing wealth information.

If found true, the NBR will file tax evasion cases against them unless they pay all due taxes along with a 30% penalty for concealing wealth information.

If the tax-evading physicians fail to pay the taxes properly, officials may freeze their bank accounts if needed.

Chasing tax target

The NBR has found that there is a big potential in collecting income tax from professionals among whom physicians were heavyweights, an NBR official said. He added that it was mostly physicians who did not file tax returns; those who did only showed their income from hospitals but concealed their income from chambers or private practices.

Although there are some doctors who showed their actual income and paid taxes regularly, their number is reportedly small.

According to the income tax ordinance, doctors, chartered accountants, cost and management accountants, lawyers and income tax practitioners will have to submit Taxpayers Identification Number certificates for obtaining practising licence.

The government has set Tk57,500 crore as income tax collection target for the current fiscal year, and to make this happen, tax officials are expanding their tax net by finding potential sectors and bringing the tax-evading sectors under their radar.

‘NBR disrespectful to doctors’

Meanwhile, the NBR’s way of representing doctors was criticised by Bangladesh Medical Association Secretary General M Iqbal Arslan, who told the Dhaka Tribune: “The state expects tax from citizens and to make this happen, the authorised body NBR can take necessary moves. However, the NBR has presented and publicised the matter in a way which makes it seem like only doctors are evading tax, which is disrespectful to us.”

Dr Rowshan Ara Begum, whose financial transaction details were sought by the NBR, told the Dhaka Tribune that tax officials should have informed the doctors before making such decision to facilitate the process.

“The NBR asks for information from banks, but they should first warn us through a show cause notice or let us know first about the matter, if there was really any mismatch. I have paid advance tax up to June 2015. I have heard about the matter, but the NBR did not serve any letter on me asking me to pay due tax, if there is any,” said Rowshan, who is a professor at Holy Family Red Crescent Medical College Hospital.

Dr Rowshan, however, appreciated the NBR’s move to bring the physicians who do not pay tax under radar.

“There are many people who earn more but do not pay tax. The board should not pressurise us [who pay the tax], rather it can bring the physicians who are yet to pay tax having taxable income,” she added.

Top Brokers