People around the world have been persecuted as long as history and people in every corner of the world have been forced to flee the countries of their birth in search of freedom from persecution, political violence, or armed conflict. During the liberation war of 1971, the persecuted people of Bangladesh have sought refuge and taken shelter in India as there was a well-founded fear of being persecuted and killed by the military of Pakistan. The Muslim minorities of Myanmar have also been persecuted in Myanmar for many days and finding no other alternative, they have taken shelter in Bangladesh. Moreover, the people of Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria and Gaza have also become the victim of persecution by the US and Israeli forces, left their country of origin and became refugees.
According to Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, persecution is the most important ground of becoming a refugee by a person who is a victim of persecution or has fear of being persecuted. The convention states that, “A person is a refugee who owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable or owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country.” From the definition of refugee provided by this Convention, it is clear that, mere persecution per se is not enough to constitute the claim to be a refugee or to seek the refugee status. Rather a well-founded fear or apprehension of persecution or infliction of harm is indispensable in order to be a refugee, as the term “fear” has been qualified by the term “well-founded.” This implies that there must be adequate facts on the ground to justify the notion of fear and the fear must be reasonable, exact, and imminent, which might arise from a variety of circumstances.
Though there is no universally accepted definition of persecution and various attempts to formulate such a definition have met with little success, from a general point of view, persecution indicates a repulsive behavioural attitude towards a person that it undermines his or her physical or psychological quietude and sometimes may even cause death of that person.
Persecution refers to a systematic as well as chronic maltreatment to the mind or body of an individual or group of individuals by another individual or group. Article 33 of the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees points out that, persecution refers to infliction or threat to infliction of psychological or physical harm or harassment, fear or pain, isolation or imprisonment by which the fundamental human right of a person is severely infringed to subjugate or eliminate him or her for reasons of race, cast, religion, nationality and political opinion, place of birth or membership of a particular social group. Though there are naturally some overlaps among them, the instances of the most common forms of persecution are political, religious and ethnic persecution.
There are numerous cases in this regard where the concept of persecution was properly clarified by the courts. Persecution was well defined in the famous American case called Al-Ghorbani vs Holder, 2009, where it was held that “persecution is the infliction of harm or suffering by the government or persons. The government is unwilling or unable to control or overcome a characteristic of the victim, because a critical element of persecution is motive and a petitioner must provide some evidence of it, direct or circumstantial.”
Membership of a particular social group or any political party may sometimes be a valid ground for seeking the status of refugee as has been mentioned in the definition of refugee under the 1951 Refugee Convention. In the case of Matter of Acosta, 1985, the US Board of Immigration Appeals held that persecution on account of “membership in a particular social group” refers to persecution that is directed toward an individual who is a member of a group of persons, all of whom share a common, immutable characteristic, ie, a characteristic that either is beyond the power of the individual members of the group to change or is so fundamental to their identities or consciences that it ought not be required to be changed.
In a reputed case of Chan vs the Minister of Immigration, 1989, Chan Yee Kin was a citizen of China and was a member of a faction of Red Guards which lost the struggle for control of that organisation in his local area, who was questioned by the police and was detained for two weeks in 1968. He tried to escape but was caught and received increasing periods of detention. In 1974 he escaped to Macau and stowed away on a ship to Australia which he entered illegally in 1980. He applied for refugee status on November 29, 1982. He was refused the status of a refugee within the meaning of the 1951 Refugee Convention. The court inter alia held that the phrase “well-founded fear of being persecuted” had produced some difference of opinion in the interpretation of the definition of a refugee. There must be a state of fear of being persecuted and a basis “well-founded” for that fear. While there must be fear of being persecuted, it must not be in the mind; there must be a sufficient foundation for that fear.
From the above discussion it may be observed that in order to seek the asylum or refugee status and eventually to be a refugee, the claimant must have a well-founded fear of persecution. If this definitional condition of seeking refugee status is not fulfilled by the applicant, there is a probability of rejection of the application by the refuge state. Proof of sufficient fear is a must for the application to be granted by the host state.



