Bangladesh Law Commission Chairman Justice ABM Khairul Haque has said there is no reason to panic about the restoration of parliament’s authority to impeach Supreme Court judges.
He made the statement at a press briefing at the Law Commission office in the capital yesterday.
Justice Khairul said: “Britain, the birth place of democracy, has the provision of impeachment for many centuries, especially from 1689. America has the first written constitution which contains the impeachment provision from the very beginning, 1787. The provision prevails in India, too, from 1950. If they can practice the power of impeachment by the people’s representative, what is the reason [for us] to be afraid?
“In many places around the world, parliaments criticise judges harshly. But the law does not stop for that reason.”
The Bangladesh parliament had been given such authority in the original constitution of 1972. But Gen Ziaur Rahman had changed the constitution through a martial law order and included the provision of Supreme Judicial Council through the Fifth Amendment to impeach or remove judges, he said.
Khairul said the High Court had cancelled the Fifth Amendment in 2005 and the Supreme Court in 2011 said in a judgement that the provision of Supreme Judicial Council would remain in force until December 31, 2011.
“The impeachment power will not curtail the independence of the judiciary.
“We have to remember that our country is run by the people of this country. And parliament represents the people. Not only the judiciary, all departments are bound to be accountable to the people,” said Justice Khairul.
Mentioning that the whole country was suffering from a decline in values, he said: “Judiciary is not an isolated island. Judges did not come from heaven. They came from among the people.”
The former chief justice thinks that the impeachment provision will not create any problem in the judiciary.
“I am not disappointed. If you see the history of impeachment in our country, you will see no impeachment has taken place since the beginning until January 1975.
“During Ziaur Rahman’s regime, there was no impeachment provision, but the judges of that time said ‘constitution is supreme, no doubt. But it is subordinate to the martial law proclamation.’ Why did they give such speech though there was no impeachment provision?
“In parliamentary democracy, any speech in parliament is fully privileged. There is no scope to criticise or challenge it,” said Khairul.
In response to a query, the Law Commission chairman said the government would have to formulate a law determining the procedure of impeachment.
“The judges must be given scopes to defend themselves if any allegation of misconduct or inability is proved against them,” Justice Khairul said.



