The war crimes tribunal yesterday heard the explanation of UK-born Bangladeshi journalist David Bergman and set April 17 for passing order on whether to bring contempt charges against him or not.
The tribunal had asked him to explain his blog posts in person or by engaging a lawyer. The order was issued after a Supreme Court lawyer filed a petition for judicial notice mentioning that Bergman has to face contempt as he said the number of 30 lakh martyrs during the 1971 Liberation War was wrong.
Bergman in his written explanation said the alleged “criticisms” were no more than an academic analysis and based on review of research studies and articles, and not expressed in sensationalist terms. He pleaded that his blog posts be considered by the tribunal to fall within the limits of “fair comment on a judgement.”
Through his lawyer, Bergman also said the subject matter of the blog article was in no way related to any substantive issue pending before the tribunal while the figure of those killed in 1971 was not a fact in issue in the trial.
Working with an English newspaper in Dhaka, Bergman said upon consideration of the facts, circumstances and submissions, the tribunal might be pleased to dispose of the matter upon an acceptance of the explanation.
During the hearing, the tribunal led by Justice Obaidul Hassan said: “The number of 30 lakh martyrs is a historically established fact and the people of Bangladesh are emotionally involved with this.”
The number of martyrs has also been mentioned in the verdicts already pronounced. “Anyone can research on this number, but they have to be aware if any comment hampers the dignity of tribunal.”
Defence counsel Mustafizur Rahman Khan said the criticisms might hurt the sentiment but not amounted to contempt.
Mizan Sayeed, counsel for the petitioner, said this type of criticism was unfair as it was done with a bad intention.
According to the petitioner, Bergman made the comments in two blog posts uploaded on November 11, 2011 and January 28 last year following the indictment of Jamaat-e-Islami leader Delawar Hossain Sayedee and death penalty awarded to another former Jamaat leader Abul Kalam Azad alias Bachchu Razakar.



