Four years into its inception, the International Crimes Tribunal is now dealing with cases against some accused who are not big fish.
War crimes activists have expressed frustration as the tribunal’s investigation agency and the prosecution are not taking the second phase of trial seriously.
So far, the two tribunals gave verdicts in the cases against 10 war criminals including then Jamaat-e-Islami chief Ghulam Azam who masterminded the anti-liberation activities. Of the convicts, Jamaat leader Abdul Quader Molla has been executed after the appeals case was disposed of at the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court. The case of Delawar Hossain Sayedee is near end at the same Appellate Division bench.
The war crimes tribunal was established on March 25, 2010 in line with the International Crimes (tribunals) Act 1973, and the first trial began in October 2011 with the case against Sayedee.
Then the law minister, Shafique Ahmed, said they were thinking about the trial of 16 alleged war criminals at the first stage. Later another tribunal was formed to speed up the trails.
The government represents the victims or their families who filed cases against alleged war criminals.
Until date, the tribunal has convicted nine men – three in absentia – on charges of genocide, murder, rape, arson, looting, religious persecution and incitement. They have been sentenced to either life in prison or death penalty.
Six war crimes suspects are currently on trial while investigation is underway against several others.
Since the beginning, the BNP-Jamaat alliance and the war criminals have tried their level best to foil the trial, but failed. Even they also tried to leak draft of a verdict before its pronouncement to create controversy. The tribunal handled all these hassles carefully. However, in the recent times, the prosecution members have engaged in some controversies within the team.
Shahriar Kabir, a renowned writer and activist, said there was no difference among the war criminals. “All of them are same. So if anybody takes the accused of the second phase as weak criminals, they are wrong.”
He said the justice seekers lost their patience as it took more than one month to reconstitute the tribunal 1. Two of the three-member panel resigned while the chairman went on retirement. “But now we need more patience, especially within the prosecution team,” said Kabir. The government should sack immediately anyone who tries to create division within the prosecution.
The tribunal officials say since the trials of almost all the “big fish” ended now the boat was near the bank.
Mafidul Huq, a trustee of the Liberation War Museum, said there was no scope to identify the continued trial as second phase.
“We just got the probe report against Jamaat-e-Islami as an organisation for its role during the war. We need patience and have to be responsible.”
The special tribunal established to bring to justice those responsible for atrocities during the 1971 Liberation War is itself in the dock. It has been criticised for political biasness and failing to meet international standards of due process and fair trial.
After the execution of Quader Molla, several international-acclaimed media labelled him as “prominent Islamist leader,” “opposition politician” or “Muslim leader” – not a war criminal. Over 60 people were killed in demonstrations carried out to protest the tribunal verdicts. These happened because of Jamaat’s propaganda against the tribunal.
According to the government, war crimes accused and Jamaat leader Mir Kashem Ali had given a US lobbyist firm $25m to make the tribunal controversial. He is an Executive Council member of the party and also its treasurer.
Imran H Sarker, spokesperson of Gonojagoron Moncho, said: “We want a permanent tribunal. We have raised our voice to achieve this. We are not in a hurry, but want to see the end of trial against Jamaat as a criminal organisation.”
The government in February last year amended the ICT Act to incorporate provisions of filing appeal against a tribunal order by the prosecution and trying parties or groups for such offence.
Law Minister Anisul Huq assured that there was nothing that could break patience. He said: “We are conducting the trial in our own way and with international support. We will continue it until we try the last war criminal of the country.” Admitting that there had been haphazard situation in the recent times, the minister claimed: “Now we have settled most of the issues.”
‘Trials would be symbolic’
After assuming power in 2009, LGRD Minister of the Awami League-led government Syed Ashraful Islam assured then US ambassador James F Moriarty that the trials of suspected war criminals would be “symbolic” and would not become a witch hunt.
According to a US embassy cable released by whistleblowing website WikiLeaks in 2011, Ashraf said the trials would involve only a handful of people. “Those convicted would likely [to] receive lenient sentences,” Ashraf said while talking to the US envoy on June 18, 2009. He predicted that the process of gathering evidence and taking the cases to trial would be a “long process” that likely would take more than five years.
While Ashraf acknowledged the trials could strain national unity, he said it was necessary to bring closure to a topic that continued to bitterly divide the country.
“Ashraf acknowledged that Pakistan strongly opposed the planned trials but said Bangladesh would pursue bilateral talks at the highest level in Islamabad to explain why the trials would go forward,” Moriarty wrote in the cable.



