The High Court bench led by Justice Naima Haider thinks that the Contempt of Court Act, 1926 is in operation now following the scrapping of the new Contempt of Court Act, 2013 by another bench.
However, lawyer Shahdin Malik, who stood for Mizanur Rahman Khan, the joint editor of the daily Prothom Alo, in a contempt case, argued that there was no existence of a law on the matter.
He said: “After the enactment of Fourth Amendment to the Constitution [in January 1975], Baksal was established and freedom of press was throttled. The Fourth Amendment was annulled through the Fifth Amendment. The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court has scrapped the Fifth Amendment but the Fourth Amendment was not revived automatically. The Act of 2013 repealed the law of 1926. So, annulment of the 2013 law on September 26 means there is no law on contempt of court.”
Shahdin cited the General Clauses Act, 1897 and said the parliament had not yet said the law of 1926 was in operation.
He told the court that Mizanur could not be punished as there was no law on contempt now.
Opposing his view, lawyer Rokanuddin Mahmud said: “The Act of 2013 had a provision that the act of 1926 was repealed. This provision was also cancelled by the High Court. So the Contempt of Court Act, 1926 is revived.”
After about three-hour-long hearing, the bench of Justice Naima Haider and Justice Zafar Ahmed ordered Prothom Alo Editor Matiur Rahman to appear before the court at 10:30am today to ascertain that the affidavit placed at the court was of his own.
The bench issued a suo moto rule on March 2 and summoned the daily’s joint editor for writing a column criticising the anticipatory bails granted by the bench. Mizanur had to stand in the dock from 2:20pm to 5:15pm yesterday.
At the onset of the third day hearing at 2:20pm, Justice Zafar asked Shahdin whether accused in other countries also had to come to the dock on criminal matters. The lawyer replied in the affirmative.
Supreme Court lawyer ABM Waliur Rahman Khan argued that the bench and the members of the bar, not the journalists, had the exclusive right to criticise anticipatory bails.
When Shahdin submitted the written replies of Mizanur and Matiur, the bench asked the lawyer to bring the documents today after correction.
The defence lawyer told the court that it would not have been possible for the media to flourish, if the Supreme Court had not protected freedom of expression and press.
Justice Naima, after going through the written reply of Mizanur, said he had challenged the rule with an allegation that the bench had not specified the alleged contemptuous words. “But we underlined those parts which were contemptuous,” she said.
Rokan termed the reply “sickly drafted by a person having a sick mind.”
Mizanur, in his written reply, said there was no law for granting anticipatory bail but the Supreme Court had earlier granted this type of bails on special circumstances.
On this point, Justice Zafar said: “No law is needed to give anticipatory bail since the judgement of the Supreme Court is a law.”
The journalist in the reply also said the bench led by Justice Naima had violated the guidelines issued by the Appellate Division in the landmark case of State vs Zakaria Pintoo.
At one stage, Justice Naima said: “From his reply, it is assumed that we have to learn how to write a verdict from Mizanur Rahman Khan.” Then Rokan said all the newly-appointed judges of the High Court must attend the class of Mizanur.
Rokan also labelled Mizanur as “insane.” The lawyer said: “The present time journalists who are not lawyers do not report correctly for their lack of knowledge on law. When lawyers were the reporters, they did not make mistakes.”
Justice Naima at one point read out the pertinent portion of the Code of Conduct of 1993 for journalists which states that they cannot write anything that may influence the verdict of a case.



