The High Court yesterday cautioned the media saying that it would issue contempt of court rule consecutively against the media who would not refrain from publishing statements, articles or anything except for the reports of proceedings, on the ongoing contempt of court allegation against Bangla daily Prothom Alo.
The court also issued a contempt of court rule against editors, publishers and printers of the two Bangla newspapers – the Samakal and the Naya Diganta – for publishing statements of several organisations which demanded apology from Supreme Court lawyer Rokanuddin Mahmud for his comments during a hearing on Thursday.
The court also ordered Dhaka Reporters Unity President Shahed Chowdhury and General Secretary Ilias Khan to appear in person before the court on Wednesday to explain their statements.
The bench of Justice Naima Haider and Justice Zafar Ahmed passed the orders saying: “On Thursday, we cautioned the Prothom Alo to abstain from any publication except for reports on the contempt of court allegation as the matter is sub-judice. But the daily Samakal and the Naya Diganta did not bother as they published statements against Rokanuddin’s submission which is also a part of the court proceedings hence get privileges. So contempt rule is issued against them and will be issued against those who will not care [the court’s directives].”
On March 2, the same bench on its own motion summoned Mizanur Rahman Khan, the Prothom Alo joint editor, for writing a column which questioned the anticipatory bails granted by the bench. The court also issued a contempt of court rule against its Editor Matiur Rahman and Mizanur.
The two accused yesterday had to stand in the dock from 2:20pm. At 3:30pm, Mizanur was provided with a chair following a plea through defence lawyer Shahdin Malik.
At the outset of the second day hearing, lawyer Rokanuddin around 2:40pm drew the attention of the court to the statements of DRU, Dhaka University Journalists’ Association, Jagannath University Journalists’ Association and Barisal Division Journalists’ Association against the lawyer.
Rokan on Thursday said: “There is no organisation to regulate the journalists. As a result, they write whatever they wish. They think themselves above the law. They discredit others after being bribed. They think themselves very powerful.”
Justice Naima Haider, during yesterday’s hearing, asked whether it would be against the principle of natural justice if the same bench, against whom an alleged contempt committed, conduct could the proceedings of the matter.
Rokan said it was the inherent jurisdiction of the bench to try this. Then the judge said: “We made the question so that no question is raised in the middle of the case.”
On the matter, SC lawyer Ahsanul Karim said as per article 108 of the constitution, the bench has all the power to try a contempt matter against them. He also labelled Mizanur as a “habitual contemnor” against who four contempt petitions were pending.
Justice Naima observed that those matters should have been disposed of.
Lawyer Salauddin Dolon said Mizanur had tried to break up the relation between journalists and lawyers by writing such articles. “If he was really a well wisher of the judiciary, he should have filed public interest litigation against mass bail,” he said.
The lawyer also said by granting anticipatory bail, the bench brings the fugitives under the law as they were ordered to surrender before the lower court. In 90% of the cases, they were sent to jail after surrender.
Pro-BNP lawyer Ruhul Quddus Kazal said as per the constitution, the HC has to give same sentence to Mizanur like daily Amar Desh’s acting editor Mahmudur Rahman who had been given six months’ jail by the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court.
SC lawyers Ajmalul Hossain QC, Zainul Abedin, Asad Ullah and Kazi Aktar Hamid also placed arguments against Mizanur.
The bench will sit today at 2:15pm and hear defence arguments on the columns and ordered Mizanur to appear in person at that time.



