The arms and smuggling cases filed in connection with the seizure of sensational 10-truckload arms can be referred as example of unhealthy practice how innocent people, mostly porters, are victimised to divert investigation with a view to save real culprits.
Two cases – one under Arms Act and the other for smuggling – were filed in connection with the chilling recovery of weaponries at Chittagong Urea Fertiliser Limited (CUFL) jetty on April 2, 2004. After multiple investigations since 2004 to 2011, the number of accused in the arms case reached at 50 and in the smuggling case 52.
In the verdict delivered on Thursday, the judge acquitted 36 accused of the arms case and 38 of the smuggling case.
All those freed were initially implicated by the second investigation officer, AKM Kabiruddin, who submitted charge sheet in the arms case in 2004 – during the BNP-Jamaat-led four-party alliance government.
They were also made accused by the third IO, Mir Nawsher Ali, who filed charge sheet in the smuggling case the same year. The charge sheet was almost identical with Kabiruddin’s except for the inclusion of only a few names.
The fifth and last IO, Moniruzzaman Chowdhury, after further investigation, accused 11 new persons including two former ministers, some military and civil officials who were in intelligence, and a leader of India’s separatist group United Liberation Front of Assam (Ulfa). Moniruzzaman kept all the names mentioned earlier by Kabiruddin and Nawsher.
But only 14 people have been convicted by the court that awarded death sentence to them in the smuggling case and life-term imprisonment in the arms case.
Of the 14, only three were made accused in the charge sheets submitted by Kabiruddin and Nawsher.
Moniruzzaman said those who were acquitted had not been involved with the arms smuggling. They were hired porters, boatmen, day labourers and workers. They were brought to unload the boxes of arms from two fishing trawlers at the jetty and carry those to the trucks parked there.
“These people were not aware of anything about the arms,” he said.
Some people from villages in the jetty area were made accused who rushed to the spot to watch the incident out of curiosity.
He, however, could not say why those ordinary people had been made accused in the initial investigations done by two of his former colleagues at the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) of Police.
“As I knew that there were involved in the arms smuggling, I did not try to prove their offence. The previous investigations were carried out to conclude the probe making them accusing in the cases,” he said adding that he would not know most of the acquitted accused.
During his investigation, none of the stalwart witnesses or accused brought any allegation against the 38 ordinary people.
Marium Begum alias Badani, an elected member of ward two under Boirag union of Anwara upazila, was one of the 16 people from her locality who were made later acquitted.
She told the Dhaka Tribune yesterday: “Still I do not know why I and other 15 from my locality were made accused. We are innocent.
“Three months after the recovery of arms, I came to know that I was an accused in the cases along with 15 others of my area.”
Marium said she had to suffer a lot during this period. “But I am happy now as I was acquitted,” she said.
IO Moniruzzaman said: “I conducted the investigation only on seven points. These [acquitted] accused were not part of my investigation.”
The seven points were: who brought the arms from abroad, for which country the arms were brought; to whom those arms were going to be delivered; by which vessel the arms were brought to Bangladesh from abroad; how the CUFL jetty was used for unloading the arms though it was reserved only for fertiliser export; how two police sergeants took away two arms from the jetty (later recovered by RAB) and in which country arms were manufactured.
Kabiruddin and Nawsher’s investigations were flawed and there were no findings about the seven issues. So the trial court had ordered further investigation during 2007-08 caretaker regime.
Only arms smuggler Hafizur Rahman Hafiz, Deen Mohammad and Hazi Abdus Sobhan have been convicted and awarded death sentence from the list of charge sheets submitted by the second and the third IO as their involvement with the smuggling was proved.
The 11 other convicted include former state minister for home affairs Lutfozzaman Babar and industries minister Motiur Rahman Nizami.



