The right to freedom of expression upholds the rights of all to express their views and opinions freely. Undoubtedly, in the technological era freedom of expression became a basic foundation of democracy and can be considered as one of the most fundamental aspects of all kinds of freedom. However, there may be some extreme forms of expression which need to be curtailed for the protection of human rights of others. Because in the course of exercising fundamental rights one cannot infringe or abuse right of others.
Hence, our constitution guaranteed this right namely freedom of thought, conscience and of speech under article 39. However, recently government has made an amendment of the Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Act of 2006 which may cause a big threat to the freedom of expression which is one of the fundamental rights of the citizens. The amended act authorises the police to arrest any person without warrant, and increases the punishment of convicts minimum seven years to maximum 14 years imprisonment.
Previously in the original ICT Act of 2006 the maximum punishment was 10 years and police had to seek permission from the authorities to file a case and to arrest any person under this act. Most importantly, one of the harsh provisions of this amended act is that the crime under this act is non-bailable. With regard to the current ICT Act most of the experts argued that the government through this amendment further blackened an existing exploitative law. A constitutional expert Dr Shahdeen Malik urged the government to remove section 57 of the ICT Act saying that the clause will take the country towards the medieval age (The Daily Star, September 7, 2013).
Further, the unclear wordings of section 57(1) of the act may create possibility of abuse by the distinct authorities. For example, this section clearly failed to spell out the nature of the information which will ‘tend to deprave’ or ‘corrupt persons.’ Moreover this act does not contain any clear provision as regards ‘publication of information’ and the ‘type of information’ that may degrade and distort others while Right to Information Act, 2009 has recognised the freedom of expression as an important fundamental right of the citizens (Preamble of RTI Act, 2009).
Thus, at the outset it can be said that section 57 of the ICT (Amendment) Act, 2013 is in conflict with the provision of article 39 of the constitution which guarantees the right of freedom of speech and expression. Secondly, we must say that the provision of the detention without any warrant is in conflict with the article 43 which guarantees the right to privacy. Therefore, as per the article 7(2) of the constitution section 57 should be declared void as article 7(2) of the constitution stipulates that, “This constitution is, as the solemn expression of the will of the people, the supreme law of the Republic, and if any other law is inconsistent with this Constitution that other law shall, to the extent of the inconsistency, be void.”
To conclude, I must say that we all have to raise our voice against such provision which is totally absurd and ridiculous. Otherwise democracy cannot exist as freedom of expression lies at the heart of democracy. At any time this law may be used against us in the name of preventing cyber crimes. And we all need to remember that free speech and expression is a basic and valuable characteristic of a democratic society which can never be undermined.



