Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Quader Molla: Judgement trashes defence claims

Update : 05 Dec 2013, 08:38 PM

The release of full verdict in Abdul Quader Molla appeals case means it is a universally-recognised principle of law that a criminal case is not hurdled by any limitation as to time. No law requires the prosecution to offer any explanation for delay.

From the very beginning of the trial against identified war criminals, defence counsels raised question on holding the trial some 40 years after the Liberation War. They identified the trial as “politically-motivated.” At every step when they argued before the tribunal and the Appellate Division, the defence lawyers argued that if the accused had not been from a “strong opposition,” and involved with the Awami League, they would not be tried.

About the claim of the defence that the accused had been tried for “political purpose, the full verdict says: “There is nothing in the record to show that the prosecution was for political purpose. The mere fact that the perpetrator of an offence is a politician does not mean his trial is to be treated as one for political purpose.”

On the other hand, it also states: “If allegations are proved beyond reasonable doubt against a person, it matters not that he is a politician, law does not and cannot provide impurity to politicians. It is to be borne in mind that crimes against humanity had political connotations any way.”

When top collaborators Shah Aziz and Col Mustafiz had become the prime minister and the home minister of the country, after the assassination of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, the verdict asks whether it was possible to bring the war criminals to the book. 

In the final verdict, the judges included examples of many international trials including the war crimes trials which tried criminals more than 55 years after the crime had takne place.

The part “Delay and Allegation of Political Motive” reads: “One can also not be oblivious of the fact that Eichman was tried in 1961 for the offences he committed between 1939-45, Suharto and Pinochet were indicted decades after the offences they were charged with, were committed.”

Referring to the case against Maurice Papon, who was convicted in 1998 for crimes against humanity for his participation in the deportation of Jews in concentration camps during World War II, the verdict says he was tried almost 50-55 years after the crimes had taken place.

The judgement also mentions about the trial against Suharto and Pinochet from Cambodia, Nikolaus Klaus Barbie (World War II accused) and Polyukhovich who were also tried ages afterwards.

Top Brokers