The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in its full verdict said they sentenced Jamaat-e-Islami leader Abdul Quader Molla to death as the apex court thinks no other punishment can be proper for his horrific crimes committed during the 1971 Liberation War.
“Death is the only appropriate sentence [for Quader Molla],” the judgement said ordering that he be hanged until death.
The Supreme Court released the full text of 790 pages of its judgement yesterday, 78 days after it pronounced the verdict on September 17 that awarded the Jamaat leader the death sentence, overruling the judgement of the International Crimes Tribunal 2 that had given him a life term.
The release of the judgement paved the way for the government to start the process of executing the death sentence of Quader Molla, well-known as “Mirpurer Kasai” (Butcher of Mirpur) for his heinous crimes.
The Jamaat assistant secretary general, Quader Molla was brought to Dhaka Central Jail around 5pm yesterday from Kashimpur jail, about 30kms from the capital.
State Minister for Law Quamrul Islam said the verdict would be implemented as soon as possible.
The International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973 says: “The sentence awarded under this Act shall be carried out in accordance with the orders of the government.”
Some legal experts say article 47(3) of the constitution gives protection to the ICT Act. According to the article, no provision of the ICT law would be considered unlawful, even if it is inconsistent with, or repugnant to any of the provisions of the constitution.
On these issues, some legal experts say the constitutional scope for filing an application to review the apex court’s judgement would not be applicable for the war crimes case against Quader Molla.
Even the provisions of the Jail Code for implementing death penalty will not be applicable for this case.
Molla’s counsels, however, after the verdict said they would file a review petition with the Supreme Court within 30 days of receiving the certified copy of the judgement as per the constitutional provision.
Convict’s family has already obtained an appointment to see him at the central jail this morning. Defence counsel Tajul Islam also told the Dhaka Tribune that they would try to meet the Jamaat leader today. Junior law minister Quamrul said the jail authorities would ask Molla whether he would seek the president’s clemency. “If he wants, then it will be sent to the president and if the president does not grant the clemency or the convict does not want to seek for it, the prison authorities can set any day to execute the final verdict.”
A five-member special bench of the Appellate Division headed by Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain gave the death penalty for Quader Molla by a majority, as one judge, even though finding him guilty, was against capital punishment for the Jamaat leader.
When the apex court pronounced its verdict in an open court, they did not mention who were the four supporting death penalty.
The full text of the judgement made it clear that Chief Justice Muzammel, Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha, Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain and Justice AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury Manik awarded death sentence in one of the six charges against Molla.
Only Justice MA Wahhab Miah was for awarding Molla life term imprisonment for the same charge which was related to the killing of Hazrat Ali Laskar, his wife, three daughters and his two-year-old son in Mirpur on March 26, 1971. One of the three daughters was raped but she survived and testified against the convict.
In the verdict delivered on February 5, the tribunal 2 had found Molla guilty for this offense and sentenced him to life imprisonment. Justice Wahhab upheld the punishment given by the tribunal.
All the five judges of the bench unanimously convicted Quader Molla in the charge for killing Hazrat Ali Laskar and others. Only Justice Wahhab did not find the war criminal guilty in the remaining five charges, but the other four judges held him guilty in those charges and awarded him imprisonment in different terms. In the charge related to the killing of poet Meherunnesa, her mother and two brothers in Mirpur on March 27, 1971, only Justice Shamsuddin said Quader Molla deserved death sentence for this offense too. But as he would not be hanged twice, the judge awarded him death sentence only for killing Hazrat and others.
Justice Sinha was author judge of the judgement. Chief Justice Muzammel and Justice Mahmud did not write their judgement separately; they only agreed with the judgement wrote by Justice Sinha.
Only Justice Shamsuddin agreed with Justice Sinha’s judgement but wrote his one separately.
Justice Sinha in his part of the judgement said the perpetrator had committed the most worst and barbarous types of crimes against humanity. “He participated in the killing and rape of innocent persons without just cause. His acts are comparable with none.”
Citing the records of witness Momena’s deposition given to the tribunal 2, Justice Sinha said: “A pathetic heart-breaking atmosphere seized the proceedings of the tribunal. If one reads her testimony, it will be difficult to control emotion.”
Justice Sinha said: “The murders were extremely brutal, cold-blooded, diabolical and revolting so as to arouse intense and extreme indignation of the community. It was perpetrated with motive.
“On a close reading of the evidence of Momena, one can instantaneously arrive at a conclusion that there is something uncommon about the incidents of murder which render sentence of imprisonment for life inadequate and deserve for a death sentence.”
He said: “The horrible picture of the carnage that had been unleashed was so brutal that the sentence of death is to be taken as the proper sentence. If no such sentence is passed in the facts of the case, it will be difficult to inflict a death sentence in other cases.”
Quader Molla, who was involved with Islami Chhatra Sangha and Jamaat-e-Islami politics before the 1970 general election at Mirpur, participated in the massacres in a planned and concerted manner with his cohorts. “Therefore, he cannot escape the maximum sentence for the offence he committed,” said Justice Sinha.
He also said the offences committed by Molla predominantly shocked the conscience of mankind.
Meanwhile, Justice Shamsuddin citing laws in some other countries and references of some prominent cases abroad said: “I have taken account of the predicament the victims and their close ones have been subjected to as well as the general impact it radiated on the society in its entirety.”
He said: “His monstrosity must have stunned all righteous people, not only in 1971 but also afterwards, may be through eternity, not only in Bangladesh but beyond.
“As such death is the only appropriate sentence,” said Justice Shamsuddin adding, “His acts were inconceivably ominous, frenzied and demon-like. Traumatic wounds of his paws caused for the whole society, will never be healed.”



