Old age, ill health and physical disability have become blessing for war criminal Abdul Alim as the International Crimes Tribunal 2 Wednesday spared him from the gallows on these grounds. It has created mixed reaction among the justice seekers and their lawyers.
Alim has faced trial for the offenses he had committed 42 years ago but he got an advantage for his age and weak physical condition. He got bail after his arrest on medical grounds.
“The dreadful and systematic planned crimes committed by a high ranking and well educated perpetrator [Alim] do not allow for a sentence other than capital punishment, we do not disagree,” said the three-member tribunal in its judgement.
But the tribunal, at the same time, set a precedent in the history of judiciary of the country by awarding Alim “imprisonment until death.”
Taking lenient view about the sentence, the verdict said: “No physically and mentally unfit person should face the gallows.”
The tribunal mentioned that Alim, now 83, needed wheel chair to move and was suffering from old age complications.
The verdict reads: “We need to pen our view emphatically that any mitigating circumstance must not in any way diminish the gravity of the offence.It mitigates punishment, not the crime.”
But there is an example of executing a physically disabled person in the country Col Abu Taher, a sector commander of the Liberation War and who was awarded gallantry award Bir Uttam for his valour contribution to the country’s independence. His left leg was blown off from above the knee in a battle in 1971.
Col Taher was hanged following a death sentence awarded in 1976 by an illegal martial law tribunal during Gen Ziaur Rahman regime. Col Taher was executed on July 21, 1976.
The International Crimes (Tribunals) Act, 1973, under which the war crimes cases are tried, says: “Upon conviction of an accused person, the tribunal shall award sentence of death or such other punishment proportionate to the gravity of the crime as appears to the tribunal to be just and proper.”
But the tribunal exempted him from the death penalty while the ICT Act says nothing about considering age, health or disability while giving punishment.
To explain, the tribunal said it was authorised to award any sentence, instead of capital punishment, if it “considers appropriate.”
The tribunal also said though Alim was found guilty for his “calculated brutal activities” resulted in the death of hundreds of civilians, “but the letters of law cannot be unkind in awarding sentence, ignoring his perceptible physical impairment.”
Prosecutor Tureen Afroz told the Dhaka Tribune that the tribunal law did not permit the consideration of old age and physical disability.
Despite that, Jamaat-e-Islami’s former ameer and symbol of war criminals Ghulam Azam was awarded 90 years’ imprisonment by another tribunal considering his age and health which also sparked adverse reaction among the justice seekers.
The government has already appealed with the Supreme Court seeking death penalty for Azam. Tureen said they would place this argument during the appeals hearing.
Shahriar Kabir, a leading campaigner for the trial of war criminals, said Alim had not spared any person in 1971 considering their age and health. “Then why this 83 year old was excused by the tribunal?”
He also blamed the prosecution for not questioning the “physical disability” of the former BNP minister during the trial, even though Alim had tried to escape before his arrest on March 27, 2011.
Also executive president of Ghatak Dalal Nirmul Committee, Shahriar Kabir expressed doubt about the convict’s illness and urged the government to form a medical board to find out the reality.



