The government can hang Jamaat-e-Islami leader Abdul Quader Molla till death after getting the certified copy of the order pronounced by the Appellate Division on Tuesday, legal professionals said. However, the defence claimed it would not be possible.
“What the apex court declared is the main or operative part of the verdict. So after getting its certified copy, the government can execute the death sentence at any time,” Additional Attorney General MK Rahman told the Dhaka Tribune.
Law Commission Member Prof Shah Alam, who played an important role in the improvement of the tribunal law, echoed the same view.
They said the war crimes cases are dealt under the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973, which has protection of the constitution. Section 20.3 of the Act states: “The sentence awarded under this Act shall be carried out in accordance with the orders of the government.”
Following the Appellate Division verdict, the defence lawyers of Quader Molla said they would file review a petition against the judgement. Quader Molla was given a life sentence by the International Crimes Tribunal on February 5 for committing crimes against humanity during the Liberation War.
MK Rahman refers to article 105 of the construction that says: “The Appellate Division shall have the power, subject to the provisions of any Act of parliament or of any rules made by that division to review any judgement pronounced or order made by it.”
He said the review was subject to the Act of parliament, and in this regard, the tribunal law too is an Act of parliament.
Law Minister Shafique Ahmed, Attorney General Mahbubey Alam, Law Commission member Prof Shah Alam and legal expert Shahdin Malik opposed the view of defence.
They were of the same view that the constitution curtails the scope of review petition of anyone who is convicted for crimes against humanity, and the tribunal law does not mention review, it just gives the right to appeal.
Moreover, according to the Appellate Division Rules 1988, a review petition could only be entertained when an apparent error is found in the judgement.
According to the Bengal Jail Code 1864, after getting the certified copy of the verdict of death penalty, jail authorities give seven days to the death-row convict to seek presidential clemency.
If he does not seek mercy within the stipulated time, then the death sentence will be executed not before 21 days and not after 28 days.
MK Rahman said: “It is the government who will decide whether they will follow the jail code or not, and it totally depends on the government in what process they will execute the death penalty.”
Prof Shah Alam told the Dhaka Tribune that if the defence moved to the apex court, their petition would be rejected.
Acting on short verdicts of the Supreme Court, the government earlier scrapped the caretaker government system from the constitution, while the Election Commission barred Jamaat-e-Islami from contesting in Barguna 2 by-polls after the High Court declared its registration with the Election Commission illegal.
Farid Uddin Khan, a key defence counsel for Quader Molla, claimed that execution was not possible on a short verdict.
He told the Dhaka Tribune: “When we get the certified copy, we will file a stay petition with the Chamber Judge of the Appellate Division. The judge will send it to the five-member bench headed by Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain as the Chamber Judge has no authority to stay execution of the verdict.”
Farid added that after getting the full verdict, the defence would lodge a plea within 30 days so the bench could review the judgement.
Moreover, the decision on seeking presidential clemency depends on him and his family, the lawyer said. “We have nothing to do with the matter of mercy. There may be prescription from Jamaat.”
He said: “Seeking clemency means Quader Molla admits his guilt.”
Prof Asif Nazrul, a teacher of law department at Dhaka University, told the Dhaka Tribune: “If the defence files a stay plea after getting the certified copy, and the top court rejects it, then the execution of death penalty on the basis of a short verdict is possible.”
He also said as the Appellate Division was the first court to give death penalty to Quader Molla, he should be given the right to review the judgement as per the principle of natural justice.
“In addition, the tribunal law does not say that review cannot be possible. It is ultimately the apex court which will decide whether there is any scope of review in war crimes cases,” he added.



