Victims of multi-level marketing companies and experts are skeptical of the effectiveness of the MLM law as it includes hardly any provision to address the financial losses of those who have already been cheated.
“How will we receive our deposited money from the defunct MLM company, Jubok?” former Jubok coordinator, Nazam Begum, told the Dhaka Tribune, “It is not stated in the ordinance how appointed administrators will pay back the deprived clients of MLM firms from Jubok, Unipay2U and Destiny.”
Former chairman of the Jubok Commission, Rafiqul Islam, said without strict implementation of law the MLM business would not be stopped.
“The wealth and properties of the fraudulent MLM firms should be seized by the government under the law for paying back their depositors,” he added.
Unnayan Onneshan Chairman, Rashed Al Mahmud Titumir, told the Dhaka Tribune the MLM business will not stop if the political backing for it continues. “Consumer rights in a country like Bangladesh is badly neglected,” he pointed out.
The Ministry of Commerce believes the fraudulent multi-level marketing firms will go out of business when the new strict ordinance comes into effect, official sources said.
“We do not want to spend huge money to set up a big administration to control MLM companies because after implementing the strict law, this MLM system will dry out,” an official of the ministry said Thursday.
The official also said the government had moved from the idea of setting up a directorate and will now only set up a registration office to be run by the National Consumer Rights Protection Department (DNCRP) or the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies and Firms (RJSC).
“The new law, if executed properly, should prevent the rampant swindling that has so far been practiced by various MLM companies,” the official said.
In the nine years since the practice began in Bangladesh, at least 100 large and small MLM companies have cheated at least 50m people out of their savings. Department of Cooperatives officials said roughly Tk100bn had been collected from clients by MLM companies in the last four years alone.
The Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs Thursday issued a gazette notification regarding MLM activities monitoring ordinance 2013, which will pass in the next parliament.
“The government will take action against fraudulent MLM firms to stop them from swindling common people within 90 days of setting up the MLM registration office,” Commerce Secretary Mahbub Ahmed told the Dhaka Tribune.
He also said they would open the registration office within a week and require MLM firms to submit their registration proposal within the stipulated time.
Regarding the registration of Destiny, the secretary said the now defunct MLM company would apply to the proposed registration office and its application would be verified according to the MLM law.
“The MLM directorate or registration office will appoint administrators if necessary, especially if that MLM company has already swindled people,” he said.
“People who will be involved in this kind of fraud will be punished with 10 years imprisonment,” he added.
Jubok, Unipay2U and Destiny were the big names in the MLM business.
Bangladesh Bank closed Jubok in 2005 for illegal banking and the government closed Unipay2u in 2010 and Destiny in 2012. Some MLM firms, such as Maxim and Uttar Investment, are still operating in the country.
Sources in the Department of Cooperatives said the expansion of Destiny 2000 Limited was exponential, boasting an asset growth of 359% from Tk10.76bn to Tk26.19bn during the 2011-12 fiscal year.
“The Destiny chairman and the managing director are now in Dhaka Central Jail but high officials of Jubok and Unipay2U are out in the streets because of loopholes in the criminal law,” officials at the Department of Cooperatives said.



