The High Court on Thursday declared the registration of Jamaat-e-Islami as a political party illegal.
A larger HC bench comprised of Justice M Moazzem Hossain, Justice M Enayetur Rahim and Justice Kazi Reza-Ul-Haq pronounced the verdict at 2:45pm.
Two judges of the three-member panel declared the registration illegal, while the remaining member of the panel disagreed with the decision.
The observation of the judges could not be known immediately.
The panel chief, Justice M Moazzam Husain, refrained from disclosing the names of the two judges who were in favour of the decision while pronouncing the verdict. He also did not mention the name of the judge who disagreed.
The party already filed an appeal with the Appellate Division seeking stay of the verdict.
Shahdin Malik, a lawyer for the Election Commission, said the verdict did not mean Jamaat could not operate as a political party, as there were many other unregistered political parties operating in Bangladesh.
"It does not mean that Jamaat can't run its political activities. The party also has the option to apply again for registration," he said, explaining the judgement.
"But at the current time, the party has lost the eligibility to run in election with its election symbol [scale]."
However, barrister Abdur Razzaak, the lawyer who represented Jamaat, said the verdict did not mean Jamaat could not take part in the elections since the issue is still sub-judice as Jamaat already filed an appeal.
Government's reaction
The High Court verdict would work as the first step of the legal procedure towards banning the party from politics, Junior Law Minister Quamrul Islam said while talking to journalists at his office after the verdict.
However, the state minister for law said: "This verdict is not enough to ban the political activities of Jamaat."
"The government will work on that," he said.
Jamaat-e-Islami's reaction
Syed Abdullah Md Taher, working committee member of Jamaat-e-Islami, called the verdict "unexpected" and "unacceptable" and said the government took this step to satisfy its ill motives.
"But eventually it would be a boomerang for the government, as the people of the country will never accept it."
Election Commission's reaction
In an immediate reaction, Chief Election Commissioner Kazi Rakibuddin Ahmed said the commission would decide its next course of action after getting the full text of the verdict.
"At this time, I don't think it would be appropriate to make a comment on the matter. We can't say anything about this now."
He said EC would hold a meeting to review the verdict in order to make a decision on the issue.
When asked whether Jamaat could participate in the election, the CEC said if their registration was deemed illegal, they would be ineligible to take part in the election as a party, but they could run an independent candidate.
BNP's reaction
MK Anwar, standing committee member of the main opposition BNP, told the Dhaka Tribune that the path to democracy would be clogged if the Election Commission moves to annul the existing registration of Jamaat after the verdict.
"Instead, the people of the country could make a better judgment through the ballot about whether party should operate or not," he said.
Expressing concern, Gayeshwar Chandra Roy, another standing committee member of the BNP, said the verdict could increase the ongoing political turmoil in the country.
Petitioner's reaction
The petitioner, Syed Rezaul Hoque, a central leader of Tarikat Federation, in an immediate reaction told the Dhaka Tribune that Jamaat-e-Islami "has no right to do politics ethically and ideologically" after the verdict.
He said: "The party is an enemy of Islam, and during the Liberation War it committed many serious crimes using the name of Islam."
Background
The Bangladesh Election Commission on November 4, 2008, registered Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami as a political party.
On January 25, 2009, challenging the EC's decision, Syed Rezaul Hoque, a central leader of Tarikat Federation, filed a writ petition seeking the apex court's order on EC to cancel its registration.
A two-member HC bench on January 27, 2009, issued a rule asking the Election Commission to explain why the registration given to Jamaat as a political party should not be declared "ultra vires" to the Constitution.
In reply, the EC admitted that some provisions of Jamaat's charter are against the country's constitution and Representation of the People Order (RPO) while Jamaat claimed the EC had not done anything illegal by registering the party.
The writ petition said the EC's decision of registering Jamaat as a political party is contrary to the Representation of the People Order (RPO). It said Jamaat could not be registered as a political party for at least four specific grounds.
Explaining the causes, the petition said Jamaat-e-Islami does not believe in principle that people are the main source of power.
It said according to RPO, any communal party cannot be registered as a political party, but Jamaat in its action proved it as a communal party.
According to the provisions of RPO, no political party can discriminate based on religion, gender or caste while selecting its leadership, but Jamaat does not allow non-Muslims or women to be leaders in the organisation, the petition claimed.
No branch of any political party can function abroad, but Jamaat is maintaining its foreign branch and also claimed that the organisation was born in India, the petition said.
On June 12 this year, the three-member HC bench concluded the proceedings as the submission of the arguments from all the sides completed.
Barrister Tania Amir moved the petition while barrister Abdur Razzak appeared for the party and lawyer Mohsin Rashid stood for EC.



