Salauddin Quader Chowdhury, a BNP lawmaker who is charged with committing numerous crimes against humanity during the 1971 Liberation War, now waits for the judgement of the International Crimes Tribunal 1.
The verdict could be delivered any day, said tribunal Chairman Justice ATM Fazle Kabir yesterday after wrapping up the closing arguments of both the prosecution and the defence.
The prosecution, which portrayed the accused as a superior responsible at regional-level for war crimes in 1971, yesterday concluded its arguments demanding his capital punishment. The prosecution sought death penalty since the charges include murdering civilians; collaborating with the Pakistani occupation army to kill and torture unarmed people, looting of valuables; persecuting people on religious and political grounds; and committing atrocities on the Hindus.
The accused was in the dock.
According to the charges, legislator Salauddin was involved in the killings of more than 200 people, including Nutan Chandra Singha, founder of the popular herbal medicine brand Kundeshwari Oushodhalaya.
On the other hand, the defence claimed that the prosecution had “failed” to prove any of the 23 charges. They placed witnesses for only 17 charges. They also claimed that the prosecution placed a “false” case with some “fake witnesses” against Salahuddin Quader. The accused earlier claimed that he had been in Pakistan from March 29, 1971 to April 20, 1974.
After hearing arguments for 11 days, the three-member tribunal, with members Justice Jahangir Hossain and Justice Anwarul Haque, kept the case awaiting a verdict delivery. The tribunal said they had drawn a conclusion to the case and kept it for CAV (Curia Advisari Vult, a Latin legal term, which means the verdict could be delivered any time). Earlier, the tribunal 1 took 30 days to deliver the verdict in Sayedee’s case and two months in the case against former Jamaat ameer Ghulam Azam after the closing arguments had been complete. The tribunal 2 took 25 days to deliver verdict in Abul Kalam Azad’s case, 18 days for Quader Molla and 23 days in Kamaruzzaman’s case.
Meanwhile, in the concluding arguments, the prosecution appealed to take the charge which the tribunal avoided during the charge framing. Prosecutor Sultan Mahmud said the charge was related to abduction, torture and killing of Abdul Wazed. He described the incident saying on August 20, 1971, freedom fighter Wazed had gone to an operation with his aides. Some of his fellows died while he was wounded. The next day Salauddin Quader went there. Wazed was then looking for some water to drink. Then the accused gave him urine to drink.
Following such humiliation, the prosecution said then Wazed was taken to the Goods Hill, house of the father of Salahuddin Quader used as torture cell. Wazed had been tortured and he died.
The prosecution claimed that they already proved the incident by placing the 23rd witness. So the tribunal might accept this charge under rule 39 (a) that states: “If the accused is charged with one offence and it appears in evidence that he committed a different offence for which he might have been charged under the provision of that section he may be convicted of the offence which he is shown to have committed, although he was not charged with it.”
On this, defence lawyer barrister Fakhrul Islam said the prosecution could not prove any of the 23 charges brought against the accused, “so they are trying to include another charge against Salauddin Quader.”
Justice Anwar then said: “Rule 39 (a) allows you to include a charge in an ‘alternative’ way but you cannot give any additional charge. You can include a charge by dropping another one.”
Before that, the defence completed their arguments. They said Profulla Chandra Singha, the son of Nutan Chandra Singha, told the tribunal that he had heard about the murder of his father from Jyotish Dhar while going to India during the liberation war. But prosecution witness Parag Dhar in his deposition said his brother had been in Bangladesh during the war. Defence counsel Ahsanul Haque questioned how Profulla Singha could hear about the incident from Jyotish who had not gone to India that time.
The defence also spoke about the topographical inconsistency. They claimed that none of the prosecution’s witness could explain properly about the Goods Hill which they claimed to be a torture cell.
Prosecutor Tureen Afroz defended this point saying that when some people were victimised and telling the story after 40 years, “how can we expect proper description from them?” She added that the victims suddenly witnessed all their known people dying. “We should take the witnesses humanly.”
On the defence’s arguments, Tureen Afroz said instead of attacking the merit of the prosecution case, the defence counsel all these days had mostly propagated his “personal philosophy” and “personal knowledge” which “bears absolutely nothing in legal, academic or professional arena. “It did not help the defence in any meaningful ways.”
She concluded with the defence’s seventh issue including application of International Law, evaluation of evidence, single witness and hearsay evidence. As the defence argued on single hearsay witness, prosecutor Tureen Afroz said: “A conviction can be made relying upon the testimony of a single eye witness and there is no need of corroboration. I humbly submit that in the previous decisions of Abdul Quader Molla, Kamaruzzaman and Ali Ahsan Muhammad Mujaheed, the tribunal 2 relied upon the evidences of single witness to prove particular charges.”
Salauddin Quader was arrested in the early hours of December 16, 2010 and the tribunal on January 17, 2011 ordered him jail in connection with the war crimes case recorded with it.
On November 14, 2011 prosecutors submitted the formal charges against Salauddin Quader citing his involvement in 24 incidents of crimes against humanity. The formal charge contains statements of 146 witnesses relating to the 32 counts of charges, they said.
Greetings exchange At the end of the trial session, members of the defence, the prosecution and family of the accused exchanged greetings with each other.
This time all parties thanked the media for their active role. When prosecutor Zead-Al-Malum ended his vote of thanks before the tribunal, the defence’s state counsel Salma Haider came forward and thanked the tribunal for picking her as the defence state counsel.
Then Salahuddin Quader stood up in the dock and said sportingly: “While everybody is greeting, then why not me? He said: “We all know our limitations. But the tribunal in the last two and a half years showed their patience. So I am grateful to them.”
When the tribunal members left the court room, Salahuddin Quader called Tureen and said: “You did a great job.” Surrounded by family members, the accused then spoke to Zead-Al-Malum and he looked very joyful.



