Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

The time to act is now

Update : 03 May 2013, 02:07 PM

The Savar tragedy is the most horrifying yet of a string of nightmares we – the Bangladeshi civil society, the global brands, the local manufacturers and the government – have refused to wake up from since the Spectrum factory collapse eight years ago.

Even if it is eight years and a thousand and more worker deaths late, we can now choose to wake up from this latest man-made tragedy and take collective action for change. Back in 2005, when the Spectrum factory collapse killed 64 and injured 70 or more workers, news reports heralded that the worker deaths and injuries caused by the factory collapse were a wake up call for Bangladesh’s RMG industry to address worker safety.

Fast-forward eight years – eight years during which we celebrated stupendous growth in the RMG industry, a growth accelerated by the global demand for low cost garments and our entrepreneurs’ ability to meet that demand using Bangladesh’s massive supply of low cost labour.

During those same eight years, we however took occasional breaks in our celebration of Bangladesh’s RMG success to mourn the killing and maiming of our workers caused by similar industrial “accidents.” Including the KTS Textiles fire in Chittagong in 2006, the Garib & Garib Sweater factory and the Hameem factory fires in 2010, the Tazreen factory fire in November of last year and the Smart Garments factory fire in January of this year.

Business as usual

After each avoidable industrial accident since the Spectrum factory collapse, we seem to have followed the same script. We, the public, immediately blamed and raged against the whole RMG industry and the global brands, and demanded change in our laws to punish those responsible for the tragedy.

The government, local RMG business and global brand leaders would respond to the public’s outcry against the whole industry with immediate denials of any wrongdoing or responsibility followed by blame shifting or allegations of “sabotage” and, when the public cries for justice would get too loud to ignore, the formation of commissions, commissioning of studies and vague promises of change.

As our collective memories of each tragedy and the pictures of the dead would fade with time, the situation would return to “business as usual” and the promised changes would not materialise.

Rewriting the script

Unless we rewrite the above script, it is unlikely that the Savar factory collapse will generate any meaningful change in the safety and working conditions of our workers in many of the smaller or less compliant RMG factories.

Unless we collectively act, our RMG industry will continue to lose its lustre as a result of more accidents and worker deaths that are sure to follow due to our inaction, and the global brands are likely to move their production to other low cost but less troublesome areas.

How do we rewrite the script? How do we ensure that our workers do not suffer another avoidable work place tragedy?

Based on recommendations made by various experts who have looked at this issue and discussions with stakeholders, I have outlined below a collective action plan that attempts to answer the above questions by:

(1) Reviewing the main causes of the worker deaths from factory fires and other accidents.

(2) Specifying the actors who need to change their practices to remove the main causes of worker injuries and deaths.

Main causes

A brief look at the causes of the worker deaths in the industrial accidents of the past few years point to causes that may be categorised under three broad headings:

• “Legal” related causes where owners intentionally or negligently flout their obligations under law, such as having factory buildings that are illegally constructed/not up to code/that use low grade materials, inadequate number of exits, locked or blocked exits and inadequate safety measures and equipment on the premises.

• “Compliance” related causes where owners due to ignorance or lack of resources fail to meet their obligations or where the inspections and audits fail to address the core issues, such as inadequate training of management and owners regarding safety and their obligations under law, inadequate training of workers on fire and other safety drills and inspections or audits that because of corruption or lack of training of the inspectors fail to address actual worker safety related issues.

• “Infrastructure” related causes such as narrow roads accessing the factory building which obstruct fire service operation and inadequate fire fighting and rescue equipment.

Main actors

The actors who are responsible for or should be held accountable for the above causes of worker injuries and deaths and who need to change their practices to minimise such causes are, in my opinion:

• The global brands who use the unique buyer-driven production model of the RMG sector to squeeze ever lower costs from the Bangladesh RMG manufacturers.

• The Bangladesh RMG manufacturers and specifically their associations (for example, BGMEA) whose standard response to any worker injuries and deaths at their factories has been to deny any accountability and unreasonably protect the at-fault factory owners.

• The government of Bangladesh and its agencies which have failed to: adequately inspect the RMG factories and enforce the existing building and worker safety laws, adequately manage rescue operations post-accident, and to a lesser extent, legislate adequate laws for the protection of workers. l

Global brands

Robert Reich, who served as the US secretary of labour from 1993 to 1997, wrote the following as his Facebook status on April 30:

“Walmart buys more than $1 billion worth of apparel from Bangladesh each year, making it the second-largest global purchaser ... after the Tazreen fire, major global retailers considered requiring their Bangladesh suppliers make safety improvements in a system they knew to be highly dangerous; the retailers would have to pay 10 cents more per garment to ensure factory safety.

Two participants in the meeting told the New York Times that Walmart played the lead role in rejecting the effort on the grounds it was not ‘financially feasible.’ Walmart’s profit that year was $15 billion.”

The safety agreement being referred to by Mr Reich is the Bangladesh Building and Fire Safety Agreement, which is a proposal developed by the Clean Clothes Campaign along with Bangladesh and global union and labour rights groups.

The above program proposes to replace infrequent and corruption-prone government inspections with an independent inspectorate involving worker committees to oversee all factories in Bangladesh, with powers to shut down unsafe facilities as part of a legally binding contract signed by suppliers, customers and unions.

The inspections would be funded by contributions from the global brands and all inspection reports would be disclosed to the public.

So far, only two brands – the company PVH, owner of Calvin Klein and Tommy Hilfiger, and German retailer Tchibo have signed up to the program. This program potentially has the reach and funding to impact the safety conditions in the 4,000 plus RMG factories in Bangladesh in the shortest time possible.

Furthermore, this program will provide more robust inspection and audit procedures for factories, which procedures are required as the existing factory inspection and audit programs have come up short in addressing safety problems both in the Tazreen factory (which passed inspections prior to the fire) and in the Savar factory collapse (where two of the RMG factories located in the Savar building passed the standards of a major European group that does factory inspections in developing countries).

Labour Behind the Label and various other groups are lobbying the global brands to sign up to this program. The Bangladesh diaspora can and should add its voice to these efforts. Furthermore, the BGMEA whose reception of this program has been lukewarm should consider its support of this program as the long-term impact on the Bangladesh RMG sector of this program will be far more positive than the continuation of the current state of affairs. 

Bangladesh RMG manufacturers

Ms. Rubana Huq, managing director of the Mohammadi Group, one of Bangladesh’s leading RMG manufacturers, opined in her recent piece in the Dhaka Tribune that the BGMEA and the manufacturers must take the responsibility of improving the worker safety issues beleaguering the industry as the “buck must stop here and now.”

She, along with many other successful RMG manufacturers, has seen her businesses grow and climb the value chain because of her company’s investment in improving the factory premises and working conditions and facilities of the workers.

Bangladesh’s star RMG manufacturers understand that it is good business to go above and beyond the minimum compliance requirements of the buyers; however, the negligent or illegal activities of unscrupulous RMG manufacturers destroy worker relations and customer goodwill and negatively impact the whole industry.

Accordingly, Ms Huq and other captains of the star RMG manufacturers need to lead the charge to implement change at the industry level.

In addition to the initiatives Ms. Huq suggested for the BGMEA to take to improve safety and working conditions, the BGMEA may consider the following as positive steps towards reducing the “legal” and “compliance” related causes (as described above) of worker deaths and injuries, and thus enhancing the safety and well being of the workers:

(1) Require all of its members to send the owners, directors and managers of production units to attend week long training programs focused on worker rights, workplace safety, facility inspection and corrective steps, compliance requirements that go beyond a simple checklist, legal obligations towards workers, etc.

(2) Enhance and speed up its current Train the Trainer program for factory workers on fire safety so that all production units are covered within a specified and short period.

(3) Require its members who are leasing facilities to check the property and building documents of the facility to see whether the property/building is in compliance with the local zoning/building codes – non-compliant facilities to be vacated within a specified period not to exceed 6 months.

(4) Require all of its members, in three different stages from the riskiest to the least risky production units, to obtain additional facility and workers safety insurance that will cover the workers and trigger higher one-time and monthly (over a period of 15 years) compensation for workers who are hurt or killed in accidents – in addition to ensuring payments to workers and their families from insurance proceeds, it will also increase the likelihood that safety issues will become evident from any insurance company inspections.

(5) As suggested by Sir Fazle Abed in his recent New York Times piece, reprinted by special arrangement in today’s Dhaka Tribune, allow and enable the RMG factory workers to unionise and engage in collective bargaining so that the workers may hold their employers accountable for workers’ rights and safety.

(6) If a reserve fund for payments to workers and their families has not already been established, to establish such a reserve fund and to require all of its members to contribute funds to such fund pro rata to their annual turnover amount.

Government and its agencies

The GOB’s failure vis-a-vis workers safety lies mostly in its and its agencies’ failure to enforce existing laws and standards at the factories and to mitigate industrial accidents by operating an efficient rescue operation.

The problem with lack of enforcement of existing laws is structural and endemic and unlikely to be solved at one specific industry level; however, the GOB could immediately increase the number and scope of factory inspections by significantly increasing the number of trained GOB factory inspectors from the current number of 18 inspectors (as suggested by Sir Abed in his recent NYT piece that was also published in the Dhaka Tribune).

Furthermore, the problem with not being able to manage disasters and run an efficient rescue program could be immediately addressed by the GOB seeking assistance and training from international organisations that have disaster management programs.

It is incumbent on all – the public, the BGMEA, labour unions and the media – to lobby the GOB to increase the number of factory inspectors, procure disaster management training for its fire and rescue officers and immediately purchase as much rescue equipment as possible and to allocate sufficient funds in the next budget for the balance of such equipment.

Furthermore, the government may consider amending its current laws on workers compensation for work-related death and injuries so that the amounts paid to workers and their families are high enough to:

Provide a sufficient living income for a family for a period of at least 15 years.

Act as a deterrent for the “legal” related causes of worker deaths and injuries.

Civil society, media and the unions collectively could and should push for such an amendment; furthermore, the BGMEA may add its voice in support of the above amendment, keeping in mind that any short-term pain for its non-compliant members would be far outweighed by the long-term positive impact of such a law on the whole industry, as it will mitigate further tragedies by discouraging the non-compliant prone members from taking short-cuts or violating laws.

The next steps

The Savar factory collapse has culminated in as many as 700 workers – maybe even more, and we may never know the exact figure - being killed and thousands more injured. The family members of many of the dead workers will not be able to bury their loved ones, as their bodies may forever be lost or decomposed beyond recognition under the rubble.

Many of the injured workers will need long-term medical care, and most will never be able to work. Impoverished families of the dead and injured workers will sink further into poverty. The tremendous outpouring of generosity from the public in the immediate aftermath of the tragedy is likely to dissipate with time.

As we pray for the dead workers and salute the volunteers who tirelessly worked during the rescue efforts, as we move forward towards implementing change in the RMG sector, let us not forget those who suffered.

We need to continue to provide long-term support to the workers and their families, either directly or through the various organisations who have designed long term rehabilitation programs for the victims of the Savar tragedy.

Masud Khan is a Corporate, Strategic, and Legal Advisor at The Legal Circle law firm.  

Top Brokers