Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Lockdown: Is the Indian model feasible for Bangladesh?

Experts believe special containment plans are needed in hotspot areas, including Dhaka and its neighbouring districts

Update : 04 May 2020, 11:16 AM

Although the coronavirus pandemic has already claimed 177 lives, Bangladesh is yet to identify hotspots of community transmission and enforce special lockdown measures instead of implementing a uniform shutdown across the country to contain the outbreak.

The National Technical Advisory Committee (NTAC) on the coronavirus situation recently recommended the government to identify heavily infected, medium infected and light infected areas through contact tracing and by measuring the size of the outbreak in the areas.

“Bangladesh should conduct a mapping of the coronavirus outbreak in the country and make specific action plans for each area,” said Professor Dr Md Shahidullah, head of the National Technical Advisory Committee.

“We are yet to receive any feedback from the government regarding the mapping. We have a meeting tomorrow (Monday) in this regard,” he told the Dhaka Tribune on Sunday.

“We strongly believe that the government will segregate areas based on the size of the outbreak in respective areas,” Professor Dr Shahidullah, also the president of Bangladesh Medical and Dental Council, added. 

Meanwhile, neighbouring India has already announced a new guideline to implement its extended countrywide lockdown using designated red, orange and green zoning system to ensure the containment of the outbreak.

However, unlike India, Bangladesh announced an extension of its ongoing general holidays (shutdown) until mid-May to ensure social distancing measures to tackle the pandemic.

Experts believe special containment plans are needed in hotspot areas, including Dhaka and its neighbouring districts.

The Institute of Epidemiology, Disease Control and Research (IEDCR), in its latest analysis, said of the total number of positive cases in the country, 56.02% were from Dhaka city. The Dhaka division, which includes Narayanganj and Gazipur, had more than 83% of all cases in the country till May 2.

Chittagong and Mymensingh divisions have another 8% of infected patients, consisting 4.4% and 3.5% respectively. The other five divisions make up less than 10% of the total number of positive cases in the country.

“If Bangladesh could only focus on hotspots like Dhaka, Narayanganj, and Gazipur by implementing proper lockdown measures, the number of positive cases would fall gradually,” said Dr Nazrul Islam, noted virologist and former vice chancellor of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib Medical University (BSMMU).

“It is very disappointing that the number of positive cases continues to rise as the enforcement of the lockdown has been relaxed across the country. So far, we have not been able to figure out where the lockdown should be relaxed and where not,” he told the Dhaka Tribune.

“As the government has received recommendations from different agencies for mapping hotspots in the country, it should be considered,” said Dr Tarque Hossain, former program coordinator of UNICEF. 

The Health Ministry, however, is yet to finalize any plans over zone mapping, but the issue has received much emphasis in several meetings in the last couple of days after India announced its new guidelines.

India’s lockdown model and Bangladesh’s limitations

India has been under lockdown since March 24, with more than 36,000 confirmed cases.

After May 4, the country extended its national coronavirus lockdown by another two weeks.

Over the period of the lockdown, India implemented sporadic containment measures including identification of hotspots.

Announced on Friday, India’s new lockdown guideline comes as an update to an existing measure of designating red, orange, and green zones of the outbreak.

Red zones are being considered as hotspots, whereas areas ensuring no new cases over a period of 21 days will be classified as green zones, according to the guidelines.

The guideline also permits considerable relaxation on restrictions in areas considered less dangerous as per the designation.

All of India's major metropolitan areas remain classified as red zones and will stay under strict lockdown measures.

The zone classifications have been described as "dynamic" and will be updated weekly, Indian officials said.

However, Bangladesh cannot consider putting its capital Dhaka under strict lockdown measures.

“Along with emergency services, many offices in Dhaka need to stay open as the entire country is managed from there,” Mustafizur Rahman, divisional commissioner of Dhaka division, told Dhaka Tribune.

On the other hand, the government allowed readymade garments factories to reopen in Dhaka, Narayanganj and Gazipur, all hotspots of the deadly outbreak.

The factory owners have been requested to follow all the health instructions provided by the government.

“Government should strictly monitor factories in red zones like Dhaka and Narayanganj,” Dr Tarque Hossain, former program coordinator of UNICEF, said.

Meanwhile, Health Services Division Secretary Asadul Islam told Dhaka Tribune: “We are planning to segregate Dhaka, Narayanganj, and Gazipur from others areas of the country by considering it as a red zone.

“We have prioritized the issue so that everyone can follow the government guidelines and stay safe,” he added.

How does Bangladesh implement its shutdown? 

The government has plans to extend the ongoing “general holiday” for another 10 or 11 days, until mid-May to help prevent the spread of coronavirus in the country and encourage citizens to stay at home and maintain social distancing.

As per the plan, no one will be allowed to leave their homes after 6pm and movement of people from one area to another will be restricted. The government also plans to take strict legal action against anyone violating the directive. 

Similarly, educational and religious institutions, passengers transport and shopping malls have been kept completely shut.

Besides, Bangladesh has allowed emergency services such as power, water, gas, fire, waste disposal, telephone, and internet services to remain beyond the purview of the holidays, alongside transportation of food, medical equipment, germicides, agricultural goods, fertilizer, industrial goods, and other essential products or daily necessities. 

Kitchen markets, food shops, pharmacies and hospitals will remain open. Pharmaceutical and export-oriented industries may be kept open if required.

However, such rules are applicable for all areas of country despite the outbreak not being the same everywhere. 

“Restrictions should be enforced considering the state of the epidemic rather than mass implementation, or else people may face other complications such as mental disorders,” Dr Nazrul Islam said while talking to Dhaka Tribune.

Top Brokers