Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Historic verdict ends 40-year dispute

Update : 08 Jul 2014, 09:18 PM

Bangladesh has gained a massive victory against India as Dhaka got 19,467 square kilometres of area out of total 25,602 sq-km of disputed area in the Bay of Bengal delimitation case.

“It is a victory for Bangladesh,” Foreign Minister AH Mahmood Ali told a press conference yesterday while disclosing the verdict of the case between Bangladesh and India.

He, however, congratulated the Indian government, saying it was the victory of friendship and a win-win situation for the people of the two neighbouring countries because the dispute had finally been resolved peacefully and according to international law.

“To achieve an equitable result, the tribunal awarded Bangladesh 19,467 sq-km area out of total disputed area of 25,602 sq-km,” the minister said.

Just after assuming office in 2009, the Awami League-led government made the political decision to resolve the maritime dispute with India through an international court as Dhaka and New Delhi had failed to come to a solution in the past 40 years. It filed a case at the Permanent Court of Arbitration on October 8, 2009.

The court based in The Hague handed over the verdict on Monday and it was officially announced yesterday.

Bangladesh won more than 118,813 sq-km of waters altogether comprising territorial sea and an exclusive economic zone extending out to 200 nautical miles (370km), Mahmood said.

“Bangladesh also has undeniable sovereign rights in the seabed extending as far as 354 nautical miles [around 656km] from Chittagong coast in the Bay of Bengal with all the living and non-living resources,” he added.

Bangladesh won another case against Myanmar in 2012 following which it received over 111,000 sq-km of area, including the disputed 25,000 sq-km.

In both the cases, India and Myanmar stressed equidistance method whereas Bangladesh pressed for equity.

The minister said the judgement would ultimately help both the countries to move forward as the issue had been pending for about four decades. “The verdict enables both sides to move forward confidently into a new future and build a new era of understanding and cooperation in the maritime sector,” he said.

Exploration blocks

Secretary of the Maritime Affairs Unit M Khurshed Alam said India had claimed 10 exploration blocks in the Bay but the judges ruled that all the blocks would be retained by Bangladesh.

In 2005, the government took the initiative to award 28 blocks in the Bay. But Myanmar claimed that 17 blocks had fallen inside its territory while India claimed 10.

“According to the verdict, Bangladesh will lose a very small portion of the blocks in the west side of the Bay of Bengal,” he said.

The unresolved maritime boundary created severe obstacles to exploration and exploitation of natural resources, affected deep-sea fishing and the Bangladesh Navy and the Coast Guard experienced severe problems in exercising sovereign rights in the maritime areas.

South Talpatti

Foreign Minister AH Mahmood Ali said now there was no existence of South Talpatti in the Bay as the island had been washed away two decades back.

According to the border demarcation map by Radcliffe Line in 1947, South Talpatti was never a part of Bangladesh. Formed after 1970, the island was washed away after 1989.

“We claimed Talpatti before 1980 but we could never prove in any of our maps that Talpatti was a part of Bangladesh,” the minister added.

Former foreign minister and agent in the case Dipu Moni said Bangladesh never had an ideal map and almost all the maps showed Talpatti in Indian territory.

The Radcliffe Line in 1947 demarcated India and the then East Pakistan in such a manner that the location of South Talpatti fell into the territory of India.

Note of dissent

Out of the five members of the Tribunal, Judge Pemmaraju Sreenivasa Rao dissented in part with the decision reached by the majority of the Tribunal.

Rao agreed with the majority on the location of the land boundary terminus, the delimitation of the territorial sea and the identification of base points for the construction of a provisional equidistance line in the exclusive economic zone and the continental shelf.

He, however, disagreed with the majority on the considerations that govern the adjustment of the provisional equidistance line.

He also disagreed – both as a matter of law and policy – with the creation of a “grey area” as a result of the adjustment the majority made to the provisional equidistance line.

Khurshed said: “The verdict was passed by 4-1 vote and [Rao’s] objection to some of the issues will not have any impact on implementing it.”

The verdict of the Permanent Court of Arbitration is binding to all parties and there is no option to file an appeal against it.

Grey area

The Tribunal noted that the delimitation line gave rise to an area that lies beyond 200 nautical miles from the coast of Bangladesh and within 200 nautical miles from the coast of India.

Within this grey area, the Tribunal noted: “Bangladesh has a potential entitlement with respect to the continental shelf, but not an exclusive economic zone, while India is potentially entitled to both zones.”

Khurshed said the area was about 50 sq-km and the water resources of the area would be enjoyed by India while Bangladesh would enjoy the resources under the seabed.

Resources acquiring

Khurshed said every year about 60 lakh tonnes of fish are caught in the Bay of Bengal while Bangladesh catches only 2.9 lakh tonnes.

“We have about 50,000 wooden boats and 150 trawlers which catch fish up to 50 nautical miles of the Bay,” he said.

After the verdict, Bangladesh has sovereign right over the resources of 354 nautical miles in the sea.

‘India respects verdict’

Meanwhile, in response to a question on the awarding, the official spokesperson of the Indian Foreign Ministry said: “We respect the verdict of the Tribunal and are in the process of studying the award and its full implications.

“We believe that the settlement of the maritime boundary will further enhance mutual understanding and goodwill between India and Bangladesh by bringing to closure a long-pending issue.”

He expressed hope that the verdict paved the way for the economic development of this part of the Bay of Bengal, which would be beneficial to both countries.

Top Brokers