Replacement of the existing Multiple Choice Question (MCQ) in the Public Service Commission’s preliminary examination with essay-type question is sure to spell disaster in the Bangladesh Civil Service (BCS) system as it will require 66,666 working hours to finish the primary shortlisting of the applicants.
A parliamentary watchdog on Tuesday recommended the government find out an alternative to the MCQ method.
At present, a machine readable script of the BCS preliminary examination can be read in a few seconds and the PSC can determine the number of a candidate. But an examiner will require at least 20 minutes to mark the script of a candidate if essay-type question is introduced, experts say.
Again, the PSC authorities is unlikely to get adequate number of quality examiners, ultimately deteriorating the quality of the public servants.
Over the last one decade, the PSC has been successful to complete the BCS (the last 33rd) in around 21 months, since the government gives requisition for officials. The PSC took around 39 months to complete 27th BCS examination. The commission now publishes the result of the preliminary test in maximum two months.
“This (MCQ) is an established system now. Yes, introduction of essay-type question in the preliminary test would require huge time,” Ekram Ahmed, the PSC chairman, told the Dhaka Tribune yesterday.
The chairman said he came to know about the recommendation from media and the official attending the meeting of the parliamentary standing committee on public administration ministry.
“We will send our opinion as soon as we get a copy of the resolution of the watchdog,” he said. The PSC is a constitutional body which can reject government decision on examination related issues.
Anwarul Haque, a former member of the PSC, told the Dhaka Tribune: “There is no need for altering the MCQ system which is now accepted by all quarters. A machine readable MCQ script can be read in a few second. But an examiner needs at least 20 minutes to see one script.
“So, how long the PSC will take to publish results of over 200,000 scripts”. Besides, he said, there was scope of corruption in the process.
“The essay-type question should no way be introduced,” he said.
A former chairman of PSC Professor SMA Faiz said that withdrawing MCQ will create many problems. “MCQ is a good system. We should think twice before its withdrawal.”
Faiz said that checking examination scripts will be a big challenge if MCQ is withdrawn. He said that PSC’s reform was a continuous process and any change should take place in consultation with its members.
Former Cabinet Secretary Akbar Ali Khan however said that the whole examination system of Public Service Commission should be reformed.
On Tuesday, the prime minister’s political adviser HT Imam, a former cabinet secretary, former home minister and bureaucrat-turned MP Muhiuddin Khan Alamgir and former central bank governor Farash Uddin Ahmed told the parliamentary watchdog that the MCQ system was not the right way of judging merit.
But Secretary of the Public Administration Ministry Kamal Abdul Naser Chowdhury opposed the idea of dropping the MCQ system saying introduction of the essay-type question in the preliminary test would make the BSC exam hugely time-consuming. The standing committee will meet again to discuss the matter next month.



