Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Public Exams: How to change the mindset of question makers?

This public exam process needs to be revisited, says an official

Update : 12 Nov 2022, 12:17 AM

The recent controversy over communally insensitive questions in the Bangla First Paper exams under the Technical Education Board has highlighted the greater issue of question paper quality in the country, academicians say.

They think substandard questions betray the skill level and mindset of the question makers and moderators, bringing into question whether they have the proper qualifications as per government guidelines.

On condition of anonymity, a government high official on Wednesday told Dhaka Tribune that question-making was an ancient practice in the country and the government was facing resistance to modernizing it.

"We need to change the assessment process. This public exam process needs to be revisited. Irrespective of the incident, they don't test merit; they just test memory at present," the official said.

He called for the Bangladesh Examination Development Unit (Bedu) to be institutionalized and given permanence as soon as possible so that they can work earnestly towards bringing about positive changes.

“The boards are only conducting exams at the moment. For a qualitative change, we need to bring a change to the assessment process itself,” he added.

Regarding the question incident itself, the official said it needs to be determined whether the controversial question was the result of the incompetence of a few teachers or an intentional plot.

Who train them?

The Bedu was formed by the Ministry of Education in 2002. It has been monitoring how teachers evaluate exam papers and providing them with training.

Talking with this reporter, Bedu officials said those involved in the preparation of question papers are properly trained, and they must have had personal motives to prepare such question papers.

Robiul Kabir Chowdhury, senior specialist (examination and evaluation) of Bedu, said: "We are providing sufficient training and logistical support to follow international standards in making master trainers across the country."

He added that teachers have received specific training for making question papers for board-level as well as internal exams.

“During the training, we also provided a guide to the teachers stating what to avoid and what to accept as question makers,” said Prof Robiul Kabir.

Shamima Akhter, a specialist (exam and evaluation) of Bedu, said incidents like the recent controversy could not be stopped unless there is a change to the mentality of moderators and question makers.

The experts also said that question makers should design questions that engage students to think critically, not questions that require them to regurgitate the information they have received.

They called for the creation of a model question bank so that teachers have examples to follow.

Who were involved in the recent incident?

Dhaka Education Board Chairman Professor Tapan Kumar Sarker said five people were primarily found to be involved in the inclusion of communal and provocative content in the question paper of the Bangla first paper in this year's HSC examination of Jessore Education Board.

All the accused are from Jessore Education Board.

The involved persons are believed to be Assistant Prof Prashanta Kumar Pal of Dr Saiful Islam Degree College in Jhenaidah's Moheshpur, Associate Prof Syed Tajuddin Shaon of Govt Victoria College in Narail, Associate Prof Shafiqur Rahman of Satkhira Govt Girls' College, Assistant Prof Shyamal Kumar Ghosh of Narail's Mirzapur United College, and Assistant Prof Rezaul Karim of Bheramara Adorsho College in Kushtia.

Prof Tapan said a committee was formed and instructed to file a report on the incident within seven days.

Asked what kind of measures would be taken, Prof Tapan said: “In the case of government teachers, disciplinary action will be taken based on divisional cases. Their MPOs may be cancelled or suspended.”

He added that those found to be involved might be banned for life from any board-level activities, including the formulation of question papers for examinations.

Education Minister Dipu Moni said: “No one will be exempted. Action will be taken against all those who are found to be responsible.

Top Brokers