Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

‘Hearsay evidence is admissible’

Update : 26 Aug 2014, 07:42 PM

The prosecution in the case against war crimes accused ATM Azhar yesterday placed a long argument on how hearsay evidence is acceptable under the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act of 1973.

In every case, defence counsels argued that if accepted, hearsay evidence must be viewed as credible, reliable and consistent by circumstantial evidence.

While submitting factual arguments in Azhar case, the prosecution for the first time felt that they needed to place legal argument on this mentioning that if they had cleared their position on hearsay witness, then the whole argument would be smooth.

Upon query, the prosecution urged the tribunal to consider the credibility of the hearsay prosecution witnesses for proving the charges made against Azhar, a Jamaat-e-Islami leader, by applying the International Criminal Law Jurisprudence.

On the seventh day of arguments yesterday, prosecutor Tapos K Baul said if the tribunal considered the prosecution witnesses’ collective memory and old evidence principles scheme, the whole criminal performance of the accused would be visible.

Tapos told the Dhaka Tribune: “We placed eyewitnesses, victims and hearsay witnesses against every charge to satisfy evidence. The tribunal raised questions to clear the evidences and we hopefully satisfied them.”

Prosecutor Tureen Afroz said during her submission that section 19(1) of the ICT Act allows admission of hearsay evidence in a trial before the tribunal.

The section reads: “A Tribunal shall not be bound by technical rules of evidence; and it shall adopt and apply to the greatest possible extent expeditious and non-technical procedure, and may admit any evidence…which it deems to have probative value.”

The tribunal said: “The tribunal 1 accepted hearsay evidence only when it was supported by eyewitness against the accused.”

Tureen then referred to some cases and added: “Hearsay evidence is not inadmissible…even when it cannot be examined at its source or when it is not corroborated by direct evidence.”

Citing the ICTY Trial Chamber in Simic, Tadic & Zaric (2003) case, the prosecution said: “There is no need to corroborate hearsay evidence with any direct evidence. Therefore, it follows that once admitted, the hearsay evidence can stand on its own to prove offence against an accused. 

Even, ‘anonymous hearsay evidence can be used to corroborate other evidence.’ However, in its recent decision of Ruto, the ICC Pre-Trial Chamber has held that ‘anonymous hearsay evidence’ alone is sufficient to prove a material fact.” 

Top Brokers