The defence counsel for BNP lawmaker Salauddin Quader Chowdhury reiterated his claim on Monday that the prosecution staged a drama before the tribunal on “false ground.”
“They placed false story against my client and also accuses Salahuddin Quader Chowdhury to harass him as a political person,” Ahsanul Haque told the International Crimes Tribunal 1 on the fifth day of argument session.
Monday was the last day for the defence’s closing argument. Before the lunch break, the defence pleaded for one more day as they could not conclude the arguments. They were conducting argument on charge 2.
The accused is facing 23 charges of crimes against humanity he had committed in Raozan and Rangunia of Chittagong during the Liberation War. However, Salahuddin Quader claimed in his deposition that the charges were false as he had been in Pakistan from March 29, 1971 to April 20, 1974.
Tribunal Chairman Justice ATM Fazle Kabir told them: “You have got till 4:30pm today [yesterday]. Think how you will be able to finish the session.”
After 4:30pm, the defence again pleaded for time extension. Ahsanul Haque said: “We are now at the stage of evidence and charges. We need some more days to complete the argument.”
The tribunal told: “You just have entered the facts. But the last couple of days you were beyond the fact.”
This time the accused requested the tribunal for extension saying that the tribunal did not have any case in the next two days due to the shutdown by a political party, Jamaat-e-Islami. Then the tribunal adjourned the session till today.
The defence in their argument said for charge 1, the prosecution was supposed to place Subal, Pramila Bishwas, Nirmal Chandra Sharma and Siru Bangalee. But they did not produce Pramila. Subal in his deposition did not name Salauddin Quader, Ahsanul said.
Another witness Nirmal is a lawyer. “He is a beneficiary advocate as he was appointed as an assistant public prosecutor during this term.” Nirmal said what he had heard from his uncle Damu. “When we crossed Nirmal, he said Damu is died. But the defence placed an affidavit that says Damu is still alive and he claimed he did not even know anything about the incident that Nirmal told.”
The defence also argued on Siru Bangalee’s deposition and cross examination. Ahsanul mentioned him as a “star witness” who had been arrested by the Pakistan army during the 1971 Liberation War and by the Indian Army by after the war. “He is also a hearsay witness. He had heard about the killings in Jagatmalla Para in Gohira from one captain Karim. “But the prosecution did not clarify who this captain Karim was.”
In his argument, the defence counsel said: “We want to stay in domestic law, not the international one because the charges are also domestic. Though the prosecution placed many international examples to prove the charges, hearsay witness is not acceptable to prove any case. He also pronounced an example that said the “only exception to accept hearsay witness is when it is in extra judicial confession.”
Ahsanul also argued on the camera trial of 17th prosecution witness, Umme Habiba Sultana. The counsel termed her “liar” and a “double star witness.”
“She told the tribunal that when her husband and father-in-law were abducted when they were on their own vehicle which was a Toyota starlet. But that brand was introduced in 1973 and they had no car of their own.”
The pointed at other contradictions of the witnesses too. Prosecution witness 28 Paritosh Kumar Palit claimed that he was an eye witness. “But during testimony, he said he never saw Salahuddin Quader before 1971.”
This time the defence counsel told the tribunal that the prosecution dealt with a “false case with the help of some false witnesses.”
Four people including Salahuddin Quader himself testified for the accused while 41 prosecution witnesses gave their deposition at the tribunal.



