Back-to-back attacks on opposition leader Khaleda Zia’s motorcade and flip-flopping by the Election Commission (EC) on whether or not to deploy troops for polls duty has muddied the waters ahead of the city corporation elections, political commentators said.
Consecutive attacks on BNP Chairperson Khaleda Zia’s motorcade on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday have left more than 20 people injured.
The three-time former prime minister alleges that shots fired in the attacks, which damaged her personal vehicles, were intended to kill her.
Against the backdrop of repeated violent attacks on the BNP boss’s motorcade, the EC thrice changed its position on the deployment of troops for polls duty.
The BNP categorically blamed the ruling party for carrying out “planned attacks” on its chairperson, while the ruling party claimed that the attacks were spontaneous expressions of anger by a public aggrieved by the BNP’s blockade and hartal programmes of the last few months.
“Things are getting complex. There is growing doubt whether people can turn up peacefully to cast their votes. The happenings of the last few days – including the attack on Khaleda’s motorcade and the EC’s about-faces on deploying troops – are ominous signs for holding fair polls.
“If the army does not patrol the streets, it will be tough to hold fair elections. The Election Commission, government and law enforcers are in the same boat. If they fail to ensure fair and peaceful elections, this will be a repeat of January 5,” political scientist Ataur Rahman said.
On Tuesday, the Election Commission said the army would be deployed during the three city corporation polls as a reserve and striking force and promised that a sufficient number of magistrates would be present at polling areas to maintain law and order.
But the very next day, the commission sent a letter to the Armed Forces Division stating that the army would not be deployed to election areas during the Dhaka and Chittagong city polls, but would remain in the cantonments as a reserve force.
The army would come out of the cantonments as a striking force only if requested to do so by the returning officers, according to the EC letter of Wednesday.
Yesterday, the EC amended its decision again. One of the election commissioners, however, described the move as a clarification.
The revised, and latest, letter to the Armed Forces Division says three army battalions – one for each of the three city corporations – will perform election duties for four days from April 26 to 29.
Abul Kashem Fazlul Haque, a professor of Dhaka University, said the last three days’ incidents were proof that the Awami League was losing its democratic character.
“The public wants free and fair elections. If the political parties do not return to the path of democracy, then army deployment will not be able to guarantee chaos or violence-free city polls,” he told the Dhaka tribune.
“If the army is deployed, the Election Commission should take service from them. If they act only upon the request of returning officers, this will not be fruitful,” former election commissioner Muhammad Sahul Hossain said.
The opposition BNP welcomed the move to deploy troops, but said their presence would be ineffectual if the army was not also given magistracy powers.
The BNP, Shujan and a number of mayoral and councillor aspirants, especially BNP-backed contenders, demanded the army be deployed ahead of the elections.
Political commentator Afsan Chowdhury said: “The incumbent government is sufficiently powerful. If the government wants peaceful elections, the polls will be peaceful. Yes, there have been some difficulties over the last few days, but the people are unmoved by it.”
Nazmul Ahsan Kalimullah, chairman of election monitoring group JANIPOP, said: “I welcome the latest decision of the Election Commission to keep the army in the cantonment unless requested by returning officers to depoly. Army deployment is an ad hoc policy and tarnishes the pride of other law enforcement agencies. Moreover, it is better to keep the armed forces out of the debate.”
Chief Election Commissioner Kazi Rakibuddin Ahmad yesterday said remaining on stand-by inside the cantonment was the best role for the army during the three city corporation elections slated for April 28.
“The cantonment is centrally located in Dhaka. The location is the best to move anywhere quickly…I think the cantonment is the best place [for them],” the CEC told reporters at the Election Commission Secretariat yesterday evening.
He reiterated that although the three battalions will remain inside the cantonment as a reserve force, they will act as a striking force if called upon to do so by returning officers.
“From the cantonment, it will be easy for them to move to Dhaka North and Dhaka South. So they were asked to stay inside the cantonment,” he said.
Election observer AHM Nouman said: “Time will tell whether the EC’s decision is right or wrong. This election situation is better than during the Ershad regime, but the people are concerned about the polls day atmosphere.”
Sakhawat Hossain, a former election commissioner, said: “Deploying the army during city polls has not been the norm. The army was never deployed like this.”
He added: “The way Khaleda Zia’s motorcade has repeatedly been attacked is alarming and unacceptable. It casts a shadow over the polls.”
Earlier in the day, Election Commissioner Shah Nawaz said there was no need for army patrols during elections for Dhaka South City Corporation, Dhaka North City Corporation and Chittagong City Corporation.
“The cantonments are in the city corporations. The army can remain inside the cantonments as a reserve force and act as a striking force, if called upon to do so. There is no need for patrols,” he said to reporters at his Election Commission Secretariat office.
The commissioner said an adequate number of regular law enforcement personnel, including members of the police, RAB, BGB, Coast Guard and Ansar will be deployed at polling areas for four days from April 26.
About the EC’s revised letter to the Armed Forces Division, Shah Nawaz said the clarification was made because the EC, in its first letter, did not mention where the army would be while discharging its election duties as a reserve force.



