Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Scope for review petition open

Update : 25 Nov 2014, 08:18 PM

The Supreme Court yesterday cleared the way for both the government and the convicted war criminals to seek review of the apex court verdict, removing confusion over the issue through the release of its full judgement on the review petitions of executed war criminal Abdul Quader Molla.

According to the judgement, both the parties will now be allowed to file a review petition within 15 days since the delivery of the full verdict in the appeals cases. The verdict will not be executed until the hearing on review petitions end.

The court said the jail code provision of seven days or 21 days would not be applicable in executing the sentence.

Another convicted Jamaat-e-Islami leader Kamaruzzaman, whose death penalty was upheld by the Supreme Court on November 3, can move a review petition within 15 days after he receives the certified copy of the judgement or be informed about it.

On the other hand, Attorney General Mahbubey Alam yesterday said they would now think about filing a review petition after getting full judgement of war criminal Delawar Hossain Sayedee’s case.

Jamaat leader Sayedee’s death sentence was committed to life imprisonment by the Appellate Division.

The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court had dismissed Quader Molla’s review petitions, as there was no error in the judgement delivered by it on the appeals, filed by him and the government, challenging the International Crimes Tribunal verdict of February 5 last year.

Known as “Butcher of Mirpur,” Molla filed the appeal seeking acquittal of the war crimes charges while the government sought his death penalty. The tribunal 2 had sentenced him to life imprisonment.

Full text of the 65-page Supreme Court verdict on Molla’s review petitions was released yesterday and uploaded on the Supreme Court website after the five judges of the apex court bench, led by Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain, signed it. 

The other judges are Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha, Justice Md Abdul Wahhab Miah, Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain and Justice AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury Manik.

In the judgement, the court said: “As per rules of this [Appellate] Division, review petitions shall be filed within 30 days but this period of limitation is not only inconsistent with the provisions of the Act but also not applicable. We are also not unmindful that the convicted person should be given a reasonable time to file a review petition. What is reasonable time is a matter to be considered in the context of the matter. There is no hard and fast rule in this regard.

“An aggrieved party can file a review petition against any order of the [war crimes] tribunal within seven days as per Rules framed by it. In the courts of small causes, a period of 15 days limitation is provided for filing review petition from its judgement.”

It said: “This has been done with a view to securing finality of litigation. In some cases it has been observed that if this bar of time is not placed on the power of review it would mean that a judgement can never become final. Taking into consideration the surrounding circumstances it is our considered view that 15 days’ time will be a reasonable time. This will secure the ends of justice.

“It must be borne in mind that, by assumption, every judgement passed by a court is a considered and solemn decision on all points arising out of the case, and further that every reason compels towards the grant of finality in respect of such judgements delivered by a court which sits at the apex of the judicial system.”

The judges observed that a review could not be equated with an appeal.

“It does not confer a right in any way to a litigant. It is now settled point of law that a review of an earlier order is not permissible unless the court is satisfied that material error manifest on the face of the order undermines its soundness or results in miscarriage of justice.

“A review of judgement in a case is a serious step and the court is reluctant to invoke its power – it is only where a glaring omission or patent mistake or grave error has crept in by judicial fallibility. Despite there being no provision in the [tribunal] Act of 1973 for review from the judgement of this [Appellate] Division on appeal, securing ends of justice a review is maintainable.”

The court said: “In exercise of the inherent powers from the judgement of this [Appellate] Division subject to the condition that where the error is so apparent and patent that review is necessary to avoid miscarriage of justice and not otherwise, and the execution of a sentence shall be suspended until the disposal of the review petition if the same is filed within the period as above.”

Saying that the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act 1973 was a special law, the judges said: “It is distinguishable from other special laws in operation because this piece of legislation has been protected in respect of detention, prosecution and punishment of any person, who is a member of any armed or defence or auxiliary forces or any individual, group of individuals or organisation who is a prisoner of war for genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes and other crimes under international law.

“Under the Act, such person cannot challenge the legality of the proceedings on any of the grounds contained in Articles 26, 27, 28, 31, 35, 44 by resorting to Article 102 or other provisions of the Constitution.”

The judges observed that the intention of safeguarding the tribunal law was obvious as “it is promulgated for trial of a person who has committed offences of crimes against humanity or war crimes and other crimes under international law.

“There is, however, no prohibition either expressly or by implication to move a review petition from the judgement of this [Appellate] Division on appeal from the judgement of the tribunal. A plain reading of this non-obstante clause of the Constitution will manifest that a review petition from the judgement of this [Appellate] Division passed on appeal from the judgement of the tribunal has not been ousted. Alternatively, it may be said the power of this [Appellate] Division as the appellate forum to review its judgement has not been ousted either directly or indirectly by Article 47A(2).”

According to the provision, the trial of a case should be concluded expeditiously, and “the tribunal shall guard that any irrelevant issue or statement should not be allowed to be raised which may cause unreasonable delay in the disposal of a case.

“Section 13 of the Act restricts adjournment of the trial of a case unless the tribunal is of the opinion that the adjournment is necessary in the interest of justice, that is to say, the tribunal shall not allow any unnecessary adjournment of the trial of a case.

“Even a time limit for disposal of an appeal has been specifically mentioned. Of course, this time limit is not mandatory. A combined reading of these provisions suggests the intention of the legislature that the trial of offences specified in the Act of 1973 should be concluded as early as possible. The object is obvious.”

The top court also said: “There is already delay in undertaking the trial of the offenders of crimes against humanity, genocide, war crimes etc. because of political polarisation in the country after the killing of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman.

“People of the country want that the perpetrators of these heinous offences should be brought to justice and that the real story of our liberation struggle should be reflected in our nation’s history without distortion.” 

Top Brokers