Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Why the national power grid collapsed

Update : 02 Nov 2014, 07:20 AM

There are flaws in the setup of the Bheramara power sub-station, as a result when it tripped yesterday, the entire national electricity grid collapsed, sources from the Power Grid Company of Bangladesh told the Dhaka Tribune.

Bangladesh began importing power from India in October last year through a 400-kilovolt transmission line that runs from Baharampur in West Bengal to the southwestern Bangladesh town of Bheramara.

The sub-station can receive more than 400MW power at a time, but it cannot transmit anything more than that. India normally supplies 250MW to 350MW to the high voltage DC substation in Bheramara under an agreement for supplying 500MW.

In recent times, this sub-station tripped at least twice when the transmission line from India brought in more than 400MW. On those occasions, no disaster took place because both demand and generation were touching the higher threshold of around 6,000MW as most power stations here were operative.

But yesterday, some of the power stations around the country were kept shut because it was a weekend and demand was in the lower threshold of 4,500MW. So, there was no backup in case one of the supply sources tripped.

“Today [Saturday], 444MW was supplied [from India] in the morning, triggering a technical glitch,” Md Aksad Ali, PGCB chief engineer for system operation, told the Dhaka Tribune.

“As a result, some power stations in the Ashuganj area tripped as frequency came down to 45hz from the normal level of 48.9hz-51hz. The aggregate demand for power in the country was 4,500MW at that time. However, because all the power plants are interconnected, demand came down to zero instantly, causing the blackout,” he explained.

However, according to BBC Bangla, the Eastern Regional Load Despatch Centre (ERLDC), the Indian authority that supplies power to the Bheramara sub-station, claimed that there had been no fault from their side.

An Indian official told the BBC Bangla that one of the two lines that transmit power from Baharampur to Bheramara, tripped for about a minute or so yesterday. “In case one trips, then the other gives backup. The backup line is always kept charged. So, the power supply to Bangladesh did not stop for a second.”

They categorically claimed that the national grid collapse in Bangladesh was not a result of any flaw in the Indian side.

Ideally, generation should always be exactly the same as demand at any given point in time. Frequency slowdown is generally caused by shortfall in generation compared to demand. When frequency falls below the normal level, power stations trip, professionals say.

Yesterday, when the technical glitch occurred at Bheramara, the supply from that source stopped, causing a generation shortfall. Instantly, because of the slowed down frequency, some other stations started tripping, bringing frequency further down and eventually leading to the countrywide blackout.

Professionals have also said even if there is a 10% gap between generation and demand, the national grid may collapse.

As a result, when the Bheramara sub-station tripped, it took out 444MW power from the grid which was roughly 10% of the demand of 4,500MW at that point.

Chowdhury Alamgir Hossain, director of Power Grid Company of Bangladesh (PGCB), told the Dhaka Tribune that the high voltage direct current (DC) substation at Bheramara in Kushtia shut down in the morning because of a technical glitch.

The blackout hit around noon and took down all those parts of the country that were connected to the national grid, with other power stations near it starting to close down one by one, he said.

PGCB Managing Director Masum Al Beruni told the Dhaka Tribune that Bangladesh was currently not receiving any power from India.

“Most power stations in the country are already operative. But the Bheramara sub-station is not. This means that there must be some problems there, otherwise they could have also brought it alive,” said Abdul Hasib Chowhdury, associate professor electrical engineering at Buet.

He also said: “Our grid system is very weak, especially in the west zone. Moreover, the Dhaka-centred design of the national grid is also problematic.”

He suggested that the government should think about modernising the existing power transmission mechanism in the country to avert similar disasters in future.

On November 16 and December 14, 2007, the country went through two similar national grid failures.

Top Brokers