A war crimes tribunal that handed down death sentence to Jamaat chief Motiur Rahman Nizami yesterday, said in its observation that he was “criminally responsible for all criminal activities committed by al-Badr Bahini and shall be liable to be punished because of his superior status.”
Tribunal also included in its judgment that “a civilian superior need not to be the official superior of the perpetrators rather a de facto command over the perpetrators is enough to hold someone responsible.
“Nizami being the president of ICS exercised his superior position in transforming Islami Chhatra Sangha [ICS] into Al-Badr Bahini knowing the consequence of his actions that substantially encouraged his fellows giving them moral support.”
Explaining how Nizami was responsible as a superior commander, the tribunal highlighted four things: “...an international crime has been perpetrated by someone other than the accused; [there] existed a superior-subordinate relationship between the accused and the perpetrator; the accused as a superior knew or had reason to know that the subordinate was about to commit such crimes or had done so; and finally the accused as a superior failed to take the necessary and reasonable measures to prevent such crimes or punish the perpetrator.”
In the words of the tribunal, Nizami’s ties with the al-Badr members was such that “the accused’s superior power, a position and authoritative influence on al-Badr is a fair indication to hold that he had causal relationship with the members of Al-Badr as his subordinates, having effective control over them.”
Explaining why Nizami had to be punished as he had been, the court said: “...he cannot be relieved from the responsibility for the planned crimes committed by the members of al-Badr Bahini with whom he had de facto superior-subordinate relationship. It is evident on record that during Liberation War the accused gave a lot of provocative speeches before [the] members of ICS who ultimately became members of al-Badr Bahini and committed crimes against humanity at random.”
Referring to the International Criminal Tribunals in Yugoslavia (ICTY) and Rwanda (ICTR), the tribunal here said: “The doctrine of command responsibility is also applicable to the political leaders and other civilian superiors in position of authority. The crucial question is not the civilian status of the accused but the degree of authority he or she exercised over his or her subordinates.”
The tribunal also observed: “From the documents submitted by both the parties [prosecution and defence], it is an admitted fact that accused Motiur Rahman Nizami was the president of East Pakistan Islami Chhatra Sangha for three years, thereafter he became president of the All-Pakistan Islami Chhatra Sangha from 1969 to 1971. The accused himself admitted the above fact in an interview published in an Urdu book titled ‘Job Huh Nazime-Ala’.



