Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Apple seeks $2 billion from Samsung

Update : 02 Apr 2014, 10:51 AM

Apple has sought $2 billion from its South Korean rival Samsung for supposedly copying the iPhone in 2010 at a time of internal crisis.

The claim comes as part of a new copyright infringement lawsuit that Apple has placed against Samsung Electronics, International Business Times reported on Tuesday.

In the court documents Apple claimed that Samsung phones and tablets infringed on five of its patents, while a lawyer for the Korean corporation accused Apple of trying to make up for the losses it sustained in the smartphone market due to Samsung’s growing dominance, especially outside the US.

Harold McElhinny, a lawyer with Morrison & Foerster, which is handling the lawsuit for Apple, was quoted by Re/code in his opening arguments in court as saying the evidence in this case will be that Samsung copied the iPhone and it also took many other Apple inventions that had not yet appeared in Apple products.

“Copying the iPhone was literally built into the Samsung development process,” said McElhinny.

According to him, the jury will be provided with internal Samsung documents that will prove that the company was aware of the fact that it was copying Apple’s intellectual property.

“Samsung sold 37 million infringing phones and tablets in the US, and Apple is now seeking an average of $33 in damages for each phone as well as reasonable royalties on unsold devices,” McElhinny added.

As Apple is claiming that Samsung products, including the Galaxy S3, infringed five of its patents, Samsung has alleged that nine Apple devices, including the iPhone 5, infringed two of its patents, and is seeking $6.9 million in damages.

“The South Korean tech giant’s phones use Google Inc.’s Android operating system, so the features Apple is claiming to own were actually developed by Google,” John Quinn, a lawyer for Samsung, told the jury.

Reuters quoted Quinn as saying we will prove to you that, yes, Apple is a great company but they don't own everything. What this case is really about is Apple trying to limit consumer choice and to gain an unfair advantage over its one main competitor, Google's Android. It’s an attack on Android.

McElhinny countered that by saying the case is not about Google, because it is Samsung that decided to add the features to its phones.

According to him, it is Samsung, not Google, which is “selling these products for a profit” and “keeps on infringing Apple’s intellectual property.”

Apple was awarded nearly $1 billion after the decision in a 2012 trial went against Samsung in San Jose, California, however the former failed to convince US District Judge Lucy Koh to issue an order blocking the sales of Samsung phones in the country.

The latest case is Apple vs. Samsung, US District Court, Northern District of California, San Jose.

Top Brokers