For years, the state-run sugar mills have been incurring hundreds of crores of taka in losses after having failed to sell their products because of high production cost and the by-products getting wasted because of strictly social reasons.
The Bangladesh Sugar and Food Industries Corporation (BSFIC), the authority in charge of the 15 state-owned sugar mills, has nearly for a year involved in a rat race with the market price of sugar.
In the middle of last year, it decided to sell its stock of sugar at a wholesale price of Tk53 per kilogram. That price could be reached only after giving Tk30/kg subsidy because the production cost in the sugar mills was Tk83.
But that decision came to no use for the government as the market price of sugar was Tk40 then, because imported sugar cost the private sellers much less. As a result, the BSFIC failed to dispatch its stock of one lakh tonnes.
However, in the meantime, the price of sugar slumped in the international market, enabling private refiners to now sell sugar atTk1-2 less than Tk40/kg.
In December last year, more sugarcanes were procured from the farmers and more sugar was refined, taking the unsold stock to 1.8 lakh tonnes. The harvesting season of sugarcane is from November to March.
The government was slow to react again. Two weeks ago, a decision was made to increase subsidy to Tk43/kg and bring down the wholesale price of sugar to Tk40. But the private refiners were already by then selling imported sugar at around Tk38/kg.
BSFIC officials said the stockpile may cross two lakh tonnes unless the government immediately did something about it.
It incurred a provisional loss of Tk250 croreduring the last fiscal year. The losses may stagger around Tk200 crore in the current fiscal year, officials predicted.
The economic survey of 2013 puts the loss incurred by the corporation in 2011-12 at over Tk290 crore and over Tk170 crore in 2010-11. In 2009-10, the figure hovered around Tk170 crore.
Cause of high production cost
According to its official website, among others, the following are the aims of BSFIC: (1) ensure production of high yielding and high sucrose variety of sugarcane; and (2) maintain stable price of sugar in the domestic market through efficient marketing.
The fact that the corporation has failed to ensure the first thing has meant that the second aim could not be achieved either.
High yielding and high sucrose sugarcane would mean that more sugar could be produced from the same amount of sugarcane.
At present, the government sugar mills extract up to seven tonnes of sugar by crushing 100 tonnes of non-high-yielding sugarcane. That represents a recovery rate of 7%. “If we can take recovery to 10%, the production cost will come down,” said BSFIC Secretary Abdar Hossain.
He, however, admitted that they were still to take HYV sugarcane to the farmers.
BSFIC officials said although the 15 government mills required at least 21 tonnes of sugarcane every season, that target had hardly ever been reached in recent years. Last year, the factories got only about 15.62 lakh tonnes of sugarcane.
“Sugarcane cultivation needs at least 12 months. So we cultivate it on fallow or marshy land as other crops grown on fertile highlandsgive quick return,” saidMatiur Rahman, a sugarcane grower from Pabna.
Near yet so far
Molasses, the by-product of sugar production, is generally used as food for farm animals in Bangladesh.
However, the Carew Sugar Mills in Darsana in Chuadanga, the only profitable government sugar mill in the country, has been using the molasses for producing foreign liquor, country liquor, rectified spirit and denatured spirit – something that the rest of the world does with the by-product from sugar production.
BSFIC officials said the Carew and Company makes a profit of at least Tk50 crore by refining 17,000 tonnes of molasses to produce 10 lakh proof litres (one litre is equal to 1.68 proof litres) of fine liquor every year. The liquor and the other items meet the local demand.
Meanwhile, last year, the Carew Sugar Mills incurreda loss of Tk15 crore by producing 4,500 tonnes of sugar.
On an average, the 15 sugar mills produce 60,000 tonnes of molasses every year.
A bulk of that amount – around 47,000 tonnes– is sold at Tk7,000/tonne in the local market to be used mainly as food for farm animals. A little of the remaining volume is exported to India at prices lower than the domestic market price.
The remaining volume gets mostly wasted because the mills do not have sufficient storage capacity.
“We have to sell the molasses [at cheap prices]because we cannot produce more liquor for the local market that has limited demand for liquor,” said BSFIC Secretary ASM Abdar Hossain.
He said the government had been thinking seriously about setting up more distilleries; but the main obstacle was the market. Setting up distilleries under public-private-partnership could be an option, he added.
During the tenure of the army-backed caretaker government in 2007-2008, an American investor proposed setting up a distillery for liquor production; but the authorities snubbed out that proposal, officials said.
“The successive governments have discouraged the production of liquor considering people’s sentiments. So, we have nothing to do about it,” an official told the Dhaka Tribune.



