Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Accounting professionals split over draft financial reporting act

Update : 31 Aug 2013, 05:50 PM

Chartered Accountants have taken a swipe at the draft Financial Reporting Act (FRA) 2013, saying the proposed law is flawed and ambiguous.

They, however, recommended strengthening the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Bangladesh (ICAB), a professional independent accounting body, instead of forming oversight body of Financial Reporting Council (FRC) under the proposed Act.

The observation emerged from a roundtable on the “Proposed Financial Reporting Act-2013-Contradictory and Unnecessary” organised by ICAB in Dhaka yesterday. 

On August 19, the cabinet approved the draft of the first-ever FRA mainly to set up FRC for strengthening the monitoring of the accountancy profession.

“If the law is enacted, internationally approved ICAB will not only lose its independence, but a stalemate will be created in controlling accounting and audit profession, affecting the trade and commerce,” said ICAB President Abdus Salam.

He said the proposed law is riddled with many errors. “Definition of financial statement was not prepared in line with the international reporting standard,” he said.

“Like any other regulatory body, ICAB is a legislative body. So, if FRC is set up, there will be two organisations for the same job, making the situation messy,” he said.

In sharp contrast, Ferdous Ahmed Khan, partner of Octokhan Chartered Accountants, said there is a need for an independent body to coordinate the activities of the professional bodies and other developed and developing countries have such practice.

He said as there is a controversy about the self-regulation and auditing quality supervised by ICAB, it should be cooperative rather than opposing the Act.

In response to Khan’s observation, ex-ICAB President Md Humayun Kabir said: “Your conception is not correct. Such organisation in this form does not exist in the world, then how it should take place here.”

He said FRC will fail to deliver its purposes as there will be dual bodies in the same job.

About the conflict of interest he said: “ICAB was ready to welcome any reform or amendment if the present situation was not up to the standard. But why two bodies for the same job?”

The necessity for an independent financial reporting oversight body was first recognised by the World Bank, which, in its report on observance of standards and codes for Bangladesh, recommended the establishment of the FRC.

Former Chairman of National Board of Revenue, Muhammad Abdul Mazid said it is important to give a second thought about the formation of an oversight body, despite a legislative body ICAB have already been existed.

The government had formed bodies like PDB, DESA in suggestion of the World Bank but we are yet to get any expected benefit from these, he said.

“There are a huge gap between purposes and activities of the proposed FRC. Some section of the proposed law is contradictory and unclear,” he said.      

Economist Mamun Rashid said the draft FRA was prepared haphazardly and without consulting with the stakeholders. “There should be more cooperative, consultative and inclusive before preparing the draft of Financial Reporting Act.”

The audit system of the financial institutions is now run by two major institutions – ICAB and Institute of Cost and Management Accounts of Bangladesh (ICMAB).

According to the draft FRA, a 12- member FRC will be formed under the leadership of Bangladesh Bank’s governor as per the law including the Bangladesh Securities and Exchange Commission Chairman, NBR Chairman, Chairman of Insurances Development and Regulatory Authority and representatives of the finance ministry’s Banking and Financial Institutions Division.

The council will have three departments – standard setting, monitoring and enforcing.

Top Brokers